Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 496 N Indiana Ave, Sellersburg, IN 47172
Phone: (812) 246-3346
Website: https://sherrillispizzeria.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizza Restaurant in Sellersburg Indiana | Sherrilli’s Pizzeria – Local …
We make the best pizza in Sellersburg, but we also have the best deals! Our mission at Sherrilli’s Pizzeria is to continue to grow the business with the …
Sherrilli’s Pizzeria | Sellersburg IN – Facebook
Sherrilli’s Pizzeria, Sellersburg. 4118 likes · 155 talking about this · 929 were here. Squarely the best.
Sherrilli’s Pizzeria 496 North Indiana Avenue – Order Online
Sign in for a faster ordering experience. Sherrilli’s Pizzeria 496 North Indiana Avenue. 496 North Indiana Avenue, Sellersburg, IN.
Reviews
Jani Sherrill
hehe hi guys yes I work here but I can still review right?? I personally enjoy pepperoni and sausage, and that’s after eating this pizza all the time for 6 years now! anyways if you’re reading this review you should come check us out, if you screenshot this review and show it at the counter you get $5 off your order!
… moreRandy Brooking
Ordered pizza at 5:30pm for carry out at 7pm. When I arrive several other people were also waiting for carry out orders. One person I talked to said they had been waiting an extra hour! It took my order an extra 45 minutes to be ready.
I had also ordered Papa John’s for delivery & they were able to pull off delivery on time with 12 pizzas. Not okay & will never make that mistake again.
… moreI had also ordered Papa John’s for delivery & they were able to pull off delivery on time with 12 pizzas. Not okay & will never make that mistake again.
Venetia Lacy
Group of unruly teenagers with a younger child were in the dining room making not just a little noise, like you expect kids to do when out without an adult, they were literally shouting at one another and being very disrespectful of other diners in the area. Spilled their drinks, then one took his hoodie off, knocking the recess light out of its socket, and then went to the restroom. He returned with a wet hoodie and proceeded to sling water at his group. We asked the staff to please reign them in but that didn’t help. These young kids live locally because they arrived and left on foot. The food was okay, might had enjoyed it better of the overall experience had been pleasant. I’m sure if their parents saw how they were acting they would be appalled. Won’t be dining in again- ever! It was that bad!!!!
… moreJames heath
Dudes working here are very friendly… Try the house flavor wings!!!! They are straight money!! The pizza didn’t look anything special but it was cooked perfect, then the crust was thin and crispy, just right on point!!! My kids absolutely loved the large soft pretzel with warm cheese…. Again props to the owners/management as these young dudes working were right on point with everything… Can’t wait to stop back in next time we’re in the neighborhood
… moreThe Traveling Man
My first time here since Covid hit. Back then it was Sir Danos. The pizza was ok but the dining area and buffet are not following Covid protocols. Numerous people inside, nobody wearing a mask not even employees, people coughing not covering their mouths plus using the same plate on multiple trips to the buffet including employees of Clarksville Wastewater, there was 3 of them wearing the shirts driving city vehicles. People were eating the same old pizza that was out no new was ever brought out. Terrible experience. I’ll never be back.
… moreElliott & Becky Pinegar
Great lunch buffet! Pizza is very hot, with a nice variety. When busy you might have to wait a few minutes for more pizza, but it will be piping hot and loaded with toppings. Well worth the flat $10 cash price!
… moreYakky Doodle
Update to review…the pizza WAS good in the beginning…now it is overcooked and never cut all the way through. Good luck getting past the smoke filled room (smoke from ovens) to pick up your pizza. Oh and you will need tough skin while being waited on by the teen staff…the last time I was in there the gal that waited on me dished out a lot of attitude…she even rolled her eyes at me during our transaction…not welcoming at all. Think I will go elsewhere for awhile.
… moreLindsay Hall
Always amazing pizza and made just right. Doesn’t last long in my house!
… moreJeremy Vonsenden
2nd time we have tried since new ownership. Horrible both times. Burnt pizza both times. Sauce and cheese was uneven. Just a huge disappointment since this used to be my favorite pizza. Will not be giving them a third chance.
… moreSteven Land
Was in town for work and got two pizzas for lunch, delicious , hot, fresh pizza really hit the spot. 16″ Supreme and 14″ BBQ Chicken was outstanding. Me and my crew really enjoyed it. Didn’t catch the name of the lady that helped me. But she was very friendly. My pick up time was 11:50 and it was hot and coming out the over wheb I walked in. Highly recommend you guys. When i am back in the area, guarantee a return for sure.!!!
Thanks Again
Steven Strange, Elizabethtown, Kentucky
… moreThanks Again
Steven Strange, Elizabethtown, Kentucky