Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Shelsky’s of Brooklyn is a non-traditional Appetizing and Delicatessen shop that aims to revive “an old tradition that never really died from partners chef Peter Shelsky and Rudi Shenk. The Appetizing and Deli features classics like whitefish salad, nova, sable, chopped liver, and latkes, plus an array of creative smoked fish and deli sandwiches.
Classic Jewish deli doling out creative smoked fish sandwiches, plus bagels with spreads & knishes.
Hours
| Sunday | 8 AM–4 PM |
| Monday | 8 AM–4 PM |
| Tuesday | 8 AM–4 PM |
| Wednesday | 8 AM–4 PM |
| Thursday | 8 AM–4 PM |
| Friday | 8 AM–4 PM |
| Saturday | 8 AM–4 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 141 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
Phone: (718) 855-8817
Website: http://www.shelskys.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Shelsky’s: Homepage
Brooklyn’s finest appetizing, smoked fish, delicatessen, and hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, homemade bagels, epic sandwiches, homemade baked sweets, and so much …
Shelsky’s of Brooklyn (@shelsky_s) – Instagram
Appetizing and Deli Counter 141 Court Street – Brooklyn, NY (718) 855 8817 …
Shelsky’s of Brooklyn: Appetizing & Delicatessen – Facebook
Shelsky’s of Brooklyn: Appetizing & Delicatessen. With a nod to the traditional Lower East Side, Shelsky’s Smoked Fish marries tradition to the new Br.
Reviews
Alfonso R.
Walked to Shelskys on a cold windy Brooklyn Friday afternoon, but when I say it was worth it….it was worth it. After about 5 min of browsing, we decided on the Tuna Salad, which is served with sliced jalapeños and a spicy shrimp paste. It’s got some heat, but nothing a Mexican from Chicago cant handle! Everything you see is fresh, and you can taste it. Prices aren’t cheap but sometimes you gotta treat yo self!!! 10/10!
… moreJasmine –
$28.61 for a Sandwhich. 1 single Sandwhich! Is insane to me. But I’d traveled from uptown Manhattan so I thought let me try it once after hearing about them. The place is clean and well organized, staff polite and friendly. Corned beef was dry and bread soggy. Left utterly dissapointed.
Update: I’d like to reply to the response on my review. Almost $30 for a corn beef Sandwhich is not the norm – I live in Manhattan and have been to places like Barneys, where the Sandwhich is less costly and packed with more meat. **up in checking other pics posted on here, I received what looks like only half the amount of meat than usual. Not sure why if I paid full price for it.
If you guys offer/offered fatter cuts, it would have been helpful to have that communicated while ordering the sandwich – I would have loved the fattier cuts. The over abundance of mustard is what made the bread soggy, I believe.
… moreUpdate: I’d like to reply to the response on my review. Almost $30 for a corn beef Sandwhich is not the norm – I live in Manhattan and have been to places like Barneys, where the Sandwhich is less costly and packed with more meat. **up in checking other pics posted on here, I received what looks like only half the amount of meat than usual. Not sure why if I paid full price for it.
If you guys offer/offered fatter cuts, it would have been helpful to have that communicated while ordering the sandwich – I would have loved the fattier cuts. The over abundance of mustard is what made the bread soggy, I believe.
Palm Artists
Look. The bagels here are fine. I’ve been coming here for years and years. What I don’t appreciate is being lied to. A breakfast bagel is listed as ~$8 on the board, but when I paid (I added sliced tomatoes) it came out to be over $12. That’s over 30% marked up undisclosed until after I paid. When I asked about it, I was told they just “updated the system two days ago”. Ok, great. But your displayed prices aren’t accurately reflected and I wasn’t informed that until after I paid. This is extremely misleading. How can anyone walk away from this with a positive review? I’m a loyal customer. Should I have just walked away without purchasing, effectively wasting the food prepared? Should I file a consumer complaint? I get the economy is hard right now but this is plain wrong. I won’t be coming back.
… moreHannah Maka
Came here at the recommendation of The Sporkful where I learned that they still hand roll their bagels here. The bagel was good, but the chopped cheese was amazing. Rich and greasy with flavorful tomatoes and a seeded bread that was tough enough to hold up against all the juice inside the sandwich.
… moreElizabeth Yang
Amazing cured fish!! They really are the best of the best. I had the Peter Shelsky bialy sandwich with gasper nova, pickled herring in cream sauce and sable. Incredible.
… moreRudy A
Was here twice, and both times overcharged. Got bagle with lox and scallion cream cheese with a small coffee. Ended up spending $23. Customer right before me ordered Member of The Tribe loaded bagle with extras for $17. Second time I came in for the same item, price was completely different. Food is good. But there’s plenty of good bagle spots in Brooklyn that are more consistently priced. Not worth the hype.
… moreJessica Juarez
Good bagel spot! They had many options 🙂
Just a littttleeeeee bit on the pricier side.
They had a small seating area in the front
… moreJust a littttleeeeee bit on the pricier side.
They had a small seating area in the front
Seth Miller
I’m a bit of a Jewish food nerd, but not quite at the level of the folks running Shelsky’s. So I was pleased to find “chopped herring salad” as a menu item. I had a salt and pepper bagel with the herring salad, tomato and onion. Absolutely delicious. The peppercorn combined with the onion and the herring was priceless. But the herring was runny, a demerit. And made with sweet herring, not like the forshmak in the Russian appetizing place in my neighborhood, which uses schmaltz herring. And I couldn’t taste the apple in it. But, nevertheless, a rare find, and loved it alot.
Eating here will cost ‘ya. One sandwich, with coffee and tip, over $20.
… moreEating here will cost ‘ya. One sandwich, with coffee and tip, over $20.
Pallas Farrow
Fantastic gluten-free bagels! Literally the best I’ve had. Great spreads: horseradish cream cheese and scallion cream cheese also the best I’ve even had. Ordered delivery and bagels arrived nice & hot & toasty.
Now I’m back home in Los Angeles after this work trip with my boss, and both of us crave these fine GF bagels.
… moreNow I’m back home in Los Angeles after this work trip with my boss, and both of us crave these fine GF bagels.
Harper Spero
I love this place. The staff is so nice. The bagels are outstanding. My favorite half sour pickles ever. I just ordered for an event and they totally nailed the order. Everything was great. Can’t recommend this place more.
… more