Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Super-sized pizzas & Italian favorites served in a relaxed, BYOB setting with several flat-screens.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 912 Penn Ave, Turtle Creek, PA 15145
Phone: (412) 646-2560
Website: http://www.shellypiepizza.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Shelly Pie Pizza | Large Pizzas and Italian Specialties | 912 Penn …
CLICK ON THE SHELLY PIE LOGO TO ORDER A VIRTUAL GIFT CARD. Original_Shelly … LIKE US ON FACEBOOK! Shelly Pie Pizza. 912 Penn Avenue. Turtle Creek, PA 15145.
Shelly Pie Pizza | Turtle Creek PA – Facebook
Hearty pizzas, italian specialties, daily specials and a full service bar. We have plenty of room bu… See more. Pizza place · $$ · (412) 646-2560.
Shelly Pie Pizza – 912 Penn Ave, Turtle Creek, PA 15145 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Turtle Creek, PA! Shelly Pie Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy …
Reviews
Bobbie Trolio
This place is awesome. The food is so darn good and the pizza, well it’s animal by itself. You can’t leave hungry. Even the side salad is big and delicious! If you get the garlic knots… You might just want 3. The biggest I have ever seen.
… moreMekhrinissa Crowe
We tried Shelly Pie’s last Saturday. The food was absolutely delicious. Service was nice and quick. We ordered mini cheese pizza, buffalo chicken pizza and garlic knots. Everything was served fresh and hot. Everything was so delicious. We just loved it.
… moreMarissa Russo
A greasy pie with a doughy crust to back it up. One slice = two slices in the real world so order according. We also got the stuffed banana peppers which we could smell being cooked as we waited for our food, and two cups of wedding soup which paired perfectly with the cold weather we’re having!
Our server Colleen was a rockstar, so kind and quick with all of her tables.
This style of pizza is a must try, once-in-a-while treat, but their full menu makes you want to come back and try other things.
… moreOur server Colleen was a rockstar, so kind and quick with all of her tables.
This style of pizza is a must try, once-in-a-while treat, but their full menu makes you want to come back and try other things.
Marianne Schafer
Excellent pizza and has a unique taste! Definitely read the reviews about pizza size. A small can easily feed two hungry adults.
… moreMakayla Zonfrilli
I got a small (easily can feed 2 people). At the recommendation of several Monroeville lifers, I came to Shelly Pie today…well! The best Pizza East of Chicago and South of New York! This pizza is now my favorite. The crust was fresh and I ordered my pizza “to the edge” and “well done” at the recommendations of my co-workers.
I ordered a half cheese / half pepperoni, mushroom, sauteed banana peppers, spinach, and jalepeno. Sadly my spinach ended up on the “just cheese” side instead of mixed in with the other toppings, BUT even this small mistake does not take away from the AMAZING taste of the pizza. I will be going back! Although I’ll probably just get a cheese / pepperoni. I loved all the toppings but it was way to much for us to eat. The toppings range in price, about 2 to 4 dollars extra per topping but it is worth it.
Hands down. The best pizza I’ve had since Chicago (Pequad’s). I can’t wait to post my photo and go back for the bar experience. I got my Keychain today!
… moreI ordered a half cheese / half pepperoni, mushroom, sauteed banana peppers, spinach, and jalepeno. Sadly my spinach ended up on the “just cheese” side instead of mixed in with the other toppings, BUT even this small mistake does not take away from the AMAZING taste of the pizza. I will be going back! Although I’ll probably just get a cheese / pepperoni. I loved all the toppings but it was way to much for us to eat. The toppings range in price, about 2 to 4 dollars extra per topping but it is worth it.
Hands down. The best pizza I’ve had since Chicago (Pequad’s). I can’t wait to post my photo and go back for the bar experience. I got my Keychain today!
Damian Polen
Very good food. The pizza was amazing. They are very generous on the toppings and the sizes are huge.
… morecathey sirna
Every time we go here, I’m just more and more impressed with this restaurant. We always get the pizza, but this time I got the lasagna and wow! Delicious! The meal came with soup so I got the wedding soup. So fresh, so tasty. We got there in time for happy hour apps, so we got the hot pepper cheese balls (a favorite!) and the pub pretzels. The prices are a little high, but the quality of the food makes up for it. I’ve never had bad service there, but we got Diana this time and she is truly amazing. She was attentive, super friendly, and has a great sense of humor. It was like visiting with an old friend. Thank you for having such wonderful people on your staff!!
… moreBob and Dara Raffaele
Fantastic pizza. Especially if you are a fan of thick dough. Excellent service . Nice atmosphere. Great selection of appetizers .
… moreThat Guy
What a sad excuse for a pizza. I think Shelley should have stayed with Vince and learned how to make a pie.
Ordered a “Sicilian”. Barely better than middle school lunch. No sauce. Toppings unevenly added. The “Pizza Potato Skins” are not worth your time so don’t even bother. Very disappointed. Should have gotten a Little Caesars.
… moreOrdered a “Sicilian”. Barely better than middle school lunch. No sauce. Toppings unevenly added. The “Pizza Potato Skins” are not worth your time so don’t even bother. Very disappointed. Should have gotten a Little Caesars.
Greg Berberick
Shelly Pie is absolutely amazing! The pizza was gigantic! Katie V was our server and she was on point with everything! We loved it and can’t wait to go back!!!
… more