Social Profile: 
… View more
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 7 AM–2 PM |
| Wednesday | 7 AM–2 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 7 AM–2 PM, 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 7 AM–1 PM, 2–10 PM |
| Sunday | 7 AM–1 PM, 2–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 511 S Main St, North Webster, IN 46555
Phone: (574) 834-7550
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sheila’s Sweet Treats Ice Cream Parlor | North Webster IN – Facebook
50’s style ice cream parlor with hand dipped and soft serve flavors available…. See more. Restaurant · $$ · (574) 834-7550.
Sheila’s Sweet Treats & Diner – Visit Kosciusko County
Sheila’s Sweet Treats & Diner. Address: 511 S Main St, North Webster IN, 46555 … Great place for breakfast, lunch or to fulfill your sweet tooth! Known for …
Sheila’s Sweet Treats & Diner – North Webster – MapQuest
Located in the heart of North Webster, IN, Sheila’s Sweet Treats & Diner is a charming ice cream shop that delights locals and visitors alike.
Reviews
Shari Benyousky
If you’re looking for a fun diner full of atmosphere and French fries with skins, this is your place. Betty Boop everywhere. Sheila is awesome. Check out the fall Cinnamon Caramel Apple Bread.
… moreJerry Velasco
I was going to have an ice cream breakfast but learned there is no ice cream – Its coming back 6-12 months. The wait is long but it’s worth it. Coffee was perfect. Great breakfast. My whole party of 6 were completely satisfied. I would definitely recommend this eatery.
… moreJennifer Fugate
Delicious ice cream and shakes! And the scoops are very generous. It was busy when we were there with a line out the door, a crowd waiting for their orders, and limited seating.
… moreTyler Hoover
Stopped in for brunch with my baby on 3/19/25 and had the nicest experience. Our server was very bubbly, sincere and accommodating! Food was fast and delicious. I recommend the skillets!
The hours here can be tricky but definitely worth the trip. if you like a retro diner feel, you’ll LOVE this place.
… moreThe hours here can be tricky but definitely worth the trip. if you like a retro diner feel, you’ll LOVE this place.
Brittany Shroyer
They get 100 all around from me! This is our go to breakfast spot has been for about 8 years now my husband an I can both eat and leave a tip for about 30$ the price is very reasonable and the amount of food you get is definitely plenty. The service has always been top notch . Thankyou for always being there to feed us!!! Definitely don’t sleep of the melting pot b&g is great too.
… moreAmber Likens
Dirty tables, terrible service, my malt was so thick I couldn’t drink it, wasn’t mixed, went up and asked to add milk they told me that’s how the malts were. I said ok could I at least get it mixed and the girl looked at me n said I would have to ask her, assuming it was the owner only for me to ask for it to be mixed and her ask what I meant! I said there was chunks of ice cream she took my lid off and stirred it with a spoon!! I could have done that myself. I couldn’t believe the rudeness and immaturity of her stirring my malt. I told her to stop multiple times and she just kept being dramatic and stirring! My malt went in the trash and I will tell everyone I know about my experience from my home town ice cream store. So upsetting!
… moreTeresa Weideman
This was our first time eating at Sheila’s and it was very good! We had a short wait because they were very busy, but once we were seated, our waitress was taking our drink order. Shortly after that our food order was taken. As busy as they were are food came out in a timely manner, hot and very good! We will definitely be back and to try lunch! Great job to all the staff! Tables were bussed and cleaned quickly and efficiently, so others could be seated!
… moreJeanne Deangulo
Cute, little 50’s style diner with friendly service and a smile. Menu is not extensive, but what they serve is good! The locals love getting breakfast here. Very clean restaurant!
… moreWar Monger
It was just ok. There was no detectable seasoning in my omelet or hashbrowns. I asked for 1 ingredient to be left out of my omelet, it was still in it. The hashbrowns were “dry”, no buttery goodness, but at least they werent dripping with oil. The toast had the barest hint of butter. Frankly, i was told it was the best breakfast in north webster and it didnt live up to the hype for me as i usually go to Maria’s. Maybe i just got a dud due to how busy they were
… moreChristine Ford
We visit the area seasonally. We only come to Sheila’s for the ice cream which is very good ice cream..however the service is always terrible. They’re very rude. We’ve been coming here for years and putting up with the service because we, especially our kids, love the ice cream. Today they had a sign up saying they’d be serving ice cream from 11-2 Saturday and Sunday only. We arrived around 11:15 on a Sunday and we were told by an annoyed employee that they wouldn’t serve us ice cream because they had too many other customers waiting for breakfast and lunch to serve. Are all customers not important? Or worthy of the money they could potentially make off the sale on their product? We would have been willing to wait patiently but we were turned away immediately. Other trips we have been treated similarly… Also who loves ice cream more than kids? Is it too much to ask to provide a kid sized scoop?
… more