Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5701 NY-23A, Haines Falls, NY 12436
Phone: (518) 589-0438
Website: http://www.selenasdiner.com/new-page
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Selena’s Diner & Pizzeria | Tannersville NY – Facebook
Selena’s Diner & Pizzeria, Tannersville. 755 likes · 15 talking about … Haines Falls, NY · Tannersville, NY · Elka Park, NY + 2. Contact info. . (518) …
Selena’s Diner (@selenasdiner) · Haines Falls, NY – Instagram
640 followers · 8 posts · Official business account for Selena’s Diner and Pizzeria. Neighboring Hunter Mountain and the Catskills of New York. ⛷
Selena’s Diner & Pizzeria | Great Northern Catskills of Greene County
Selena’s Diner & Pizzeria … Daily Specials. Find us on Facebook. outside building >. Property Information. 5701 Rt. 23A Haines Falls, NY 12436. All Year. Visit …
Reviews
Halyna Perederii
If you want a truly authentic diner experience, this place is it. The vibe is exactly what you hope for when you think of a classic small-town diner in the mountains. The food was delicious, the menu had a great variety, and everything came out incredibly fast.
What really made the visit special was the very friendly beautiful Selena — she made the whole place feel warm and welcoming. The diner was clean, cozy, and had that genuine local charm you can’t fake.
After a long hike to the waterfall, stopping here felt absolutely perfect. Good food, quick service, and that relaxed small-town mountain atmosphere — exactly what you want after a day on the trail.
Girl, your makeup is awesome ❤️
… moreWhat really made the visit special was the very friendly beautiful Selena — she made the whole place feel warm and welcoming. The diner was clean, cozy, and had that genuine local charm you can’t fake.
After a long hike to the waterfall, stopping here felt absolutely perfect. Good food, quick service, and that relaxed small-town mountain atmosphere — exactly what you want after a day on the trail.
Girl, your makeup is awesome ❤️
Bill Lozano
Heading to North Lake to hike we met friends at Selenas Dinner for lunch. We have driven past it many times over the years but this was our first visit here. It’s an old time dinner. The menu has pages of items to choose from. Service was excellent. Our server came over as soon as we sat down and the busboy refilled our drinks when they were getting low.
I had a Cuban sandwich with fries. My wife and one friend had grilled cheese sandwiches. Our other friend had broccoli and cheddar omelet.
If you want a good meal for a good price, you should stop into Selena’s Dinner. They have wifi if you are there to get some work done as you eat. We will be back.On our drive to North Lake, we decided to finally stop at Selena’s Diner for lunch, a place we’d passed countless times. This was our first visit, and it’s a classic, old-time diner. The menu is extensive, offering pages of choices.
The service was excellent right from the start; our server was at our table immediately, and the busboy was attentive, refilling our drinks as soon as they ran low.
For our meals, I ordered a Cuban sandwich with a side of fries. My wife and one friend both had grilled cheese sandwiches, while our other friend opted for a broccoli and cheddar omelet.
If you’re looking for a satisfying meal at a great price, Selena’s Diner is the place to stop. They even offer Wi-Fi if you need to catch up on work while you eat. We definitely plan on returning.On our drive to North Lake, we finally decided to stop for lunch at Selena’s Diner, a place we’d passed countless times over the years. This first visit revealed a classic, old-time diner with an incredibly extensive menu offering pages of choices.
The service was a highlight: our server was immediately attentive upon seating, and the busboy was vigilant about refilling our drinks.
For lunch, I ordered a Cuban sandwich with fries. My wife and one friend both chose grilled cheese sandwiches, while our other friend enjoyed a broccoli and cheddar omelet.
Selena’s Diner is an excellent stop for anyone seeking a satisfying and good-priced meal. As a bonus, they offer Wi-Fi for those who need to work while they eat. We definitely plan on returning.
… moreI had a Cuban sandwich with fries. My wife and one friend had grilled cheese sandwiches. Our other friend had broccoli and cheddar omelet.
If you want a good meal for a good price, you should stop into Selena’s Dinner. They have wifi if you are there to get some work done as you eat. We will be back.On our drive to North Lake, we decided to finally stop at Selena’s Diner for lunch, a place we’d passed countless times. This was our first visit, and it’s a classic, old-time diner. The menu is extensive, offering pages of choices.
The service was excellent right from the start; our server was at our table immediately, and the busboy was attentive, refilling our drinks as soon as they ran low.
For our meals, I ordered a Cuban sandwich with a side of fries. My wife and one friend both had grilled cheese sandwiches, while our other friend opted for a broccoli and cheddar omelet.
If you’re looking for a satisfying meal at a great price, Selena’s Diner is the place to stop. They even offer Wi-Fi if you need to catch up on work while you eat. We definitely plan on returning.On our drive to North Lake, we finally decided to stop for lunch at Selena’s Diner, a place we’d passed countless times over the years. This first visit revealed a classic, old-time diner with an incredibly extensive menu offering pages of choices.
The service was a highlight: our server was immediately attentive upon seating, and the busboy was vigilant about refilling our drinks.
For lunch, I ordered a Cuban sandwich with fries. My wife and one friend both chose grilled cheese sandwiches, while our other friend enjoyed a broccoli and cheddar omelet.
Selena’s Diner is an excellent stop for anyone seeking a satisfying and good-priced meal. As a bonus, they offer Wi-Fi for those who need to work while they eat. We definitely plan on returning.
Jun Simons
Nice people and a convenient location if you are hiking or skiing on the catskills. They kept the coffee coming and portion sizes are large.
The food is nothing special, typical diner breakfast as you would expect.
… moreThe food is nothing special, typical diner breakfast as you would expect.
Oat
This place has a wonderful atmosphere and the service was very friendly. The food is great diner food. I had the thanksgiving sandwich. The pizza was ok but, I’m mostly used to NYC style pizza, this was little thicker than that.
… moreAndrea Pinto
I came here with friends and my partner last Saturday around 7 pm. The service was good as it was almost empty, but they took a few mins to take our order. The diner looked that someone of us was gonna get a stomachache.
I got the Californian burger, apparently, the last one. It looked good and the fries too. Overall it was okay.
However, that burger gave me the worst food poisoning. At 3 am I was in the bathroom non stop. The worst part is that I was at a campground.
I wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone.
… moreI got the Californian burger, apparently, the last one. It looked good and the fries too. Overall it was okay.
However, that burger gave me the worst food poisoning. At 3 am I was in the bathroom non stop. The worst part is that I was at a campground.
I wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone.
Elvin Frias
Honestly, I’m really disappointed with how this place is run. From the moment we walked in, the energy was off. My group and I came in friendly and polite — “Hi! Good morning! How are you?” — and got nothing back. No smile, no welcome, just a flat “How many people?”
We said “eight,” and the host looked instantly tired and unenthusiastic. It was still morning! Was it really that bad for a group of people to come in after church to enjoy breakfast together?
The diner looks nice in the front, but they seated us all the way in the back, where it felt like a plain storage room — four walls, a ceiling, lots of tables and chairs, and zero charm. The front had open space, but for some reason, we were placed in the back. At first, we brushed it off. But then we noticed something that didn’t sit right — the only other groups seated in the back were non-white, like us. That made the whole situation feel even worse.
The service didn’t improve. We waited around 45 minutes just to place our order. When the server came by, we said clearly, “Just water for now, we’re ready to order our food.” They didn’t even acknowledge us — just dropped off the waters and walked away.
When the food finally came, it was terrible. I ordered steak and eggs (medium) and got an overcooked steak and one scrambled egg. That was it.
Overall, it was a disappointing experience from start to finish. The atmosphere might be nice if you’re sitting up front — but if you’re not white, don’t expect the same treatment. Save yourself the frustration and order somewhere else.
… moreWe said “eight,” and the host looked instantly tired and unenthusiastic. It was still morning! Was it really that bad for a group of people to come in after church to enjoy breakfast together?
The diner looks nice in the front, but they seated us all the way in the back, where it felt like a plain storage room — four walls, a ceiling, lots of tables and chairs, and zero charm. The front had open space, but for some reason, we were placed in the back. At first, we brushed it off. But then we noticed something that didn’t sit right — the only other groups seated in the back were non-white, like us. That made the whole situation feel even worse.
The service didn’t improve. We waited around 45 minutes just to place our order. When the server came by, we said clearly, “Just water for now, we’re ready to order our food.” They didn’t even acknowledge us — just dropped off the waters and walked away.
When the food finally came, it was terrible. I ordered steak and eggs (medium) and got an overcooked steak and one scrambled egg. That was it.
Overall, it was a disappointing experience from start to finish. The atmosphere might be nice if you’re sitting up front — but if you’re not white, don’t expect the same treatment. Save yourself the frustration and order somewhere else.
Angry Panda
Came here twice in two days. Ordered a cheese pizza to go day one, it was excellent! Sat down to dinner on day two. Highly recommend the chicken wings with raspberry habanero sauce. Cooked perfectly with a nice crisp. Sauce was a great blend of sweet and spicy. Fettuccine carbonara was delicious and rich with real slices of thick bacon as well as fresh onion and garlic. Roast beef was tender and mashed potatoes were creamy. Awesome! Rice pudding was a great end the to the meal.
Prices were absolutely reasonable. Server was very attentive and polite. Best of all, the receipt didn’t tell me how much to tip, nor was I charged extra for credit use. Old school diner feel that we much appreciated. I prefer dining here over downtown Tannersville.
… morePrices were absolutely reasonable. Server was very attentive and polite. Best of all, the receipt didn’t tell me how much to tip, nor was I charged extra for credit use. Old school diner feel that we much appreciated. I prefer dining here over downtown Tannersville.
Lexi C
Eggs Benedict was delicious. They have a huge menu and a ton of selections including an entire pizzeria as well. Could’ve spent the entire weekend eating here for each meal with the variety they have. Sister said the French toast was amazing too. Good prices.
… moreAna Amelia C
We’ve been here 3 or 3 times, the sandwiches are SOO good! It’s perfect
… moreSanji Azad
We visited Kaaterskill Falls and stopped at a diner on our way back, hoping for a cozy experience. Unfortunately, it turned out to be a poor choice. The food was undercooked or overcooked and below par, and waiting 40 minutes for soup, salad, a sandwich, and appetisers felt excessive. We didn’t want to complain since they were about to close, but we felt it was important to warn others: avoid this place during your visit. It’s a waste of money, and you won’t find the warm atmosphere or food you need after a hike.
… more