Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Long-standing, bustling locale for massive steaks & an extensive wine list in nostalgic surrounds.
Address and Contact Information
Address: W1688 Sheboygan Rd, New Holstein, WI 53061
Phone: (920) 894-3598
Website: https://schwarzsupperclub.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Menu – Schwarz’s Supper Club
W1688 Sheboygan Rd. New Holstein, WI 53061 · GUEST HOUSE. We look forward to welcoming you to our supper club, where you can experience exceptional dining and …
Schwarz’s Supper Club: Home
New Holstein, WI 53061 · GUEST HOUSE. We look forward to welcoming you to our supper club, where you can experience exceptional dining and a warm, inviting …
Schwarz Supper Club | New Holstein WI – Facebook
Details. . 98% recommend (1,850 Reviews). . $$. . Closed now. . W1688 Sheboygan Rd, New Holstein, WI, United States, 53061 ; Links. . schwarzsupperclub.com …
Reviews
mark wong
We came here to try out for birthday celebration. A coworker recommended this place. We got there at 4:10 on a Saturday as we heard place gets very busy. We had my parents and my handicapped wife who use walkers and a mobile scooter. A customer arriving same time was super nice and told us how the ordering process works. The bar/ordering area was only about half full at time. We ordered, had a drink at bar which was very well made, and within half hour they called us to table. By 5 the ordering area was mostly full. The food was excellent, and service particularly was great. They were very busy but the servers worked together to be efficient and responded quickly to any requests. Decor was nice for Christmas as well. We had great first visit. Was 55 min drive from Appleton but well worth trip. With handicap. People I would note when at full capacity the bar ordering area was standing room only full. To exit out front would have been pretty challenging. There was side door that we found to escape outside thankfully to avoid.
… moreColissa Erickson
Best broiled scallops I’ve had in a while. Had flavor and cooked to perfection. Tenderloin was also cooked exactly as requested. Assorted mushrooms were a definite treat. Had a glass of ice cold milk with my meal. It was a great pleasure to have that kind of option. My favorite thing of all were the baby corn that came with our salad. I have never had corn like that before, so juicy it blew my mind. I could keep going on and on about this place. Great parking, enclosed smoking room with ventilation. Claw machine for the little one ❤️ the only thing I could say to an opposed stand point was the uncertainty of where to go to check in. Nobody greats you and there isnt clarity on where to go. We sat in the middle section of the bar to ask for assistance. Waited for about 10 minutes while others on both sides of us that sat down or came up after us were served before us, over and over like we were invisible. It was Very odd Eventually someone greated us and we had a chance to ask and inform them of our 1.5 hour travel and first time visit. Everything after the guidance made up for the awkward uncomfortable entering moments. Probably won’t order the calamari again as each bite was inconsistent. One would be good and crunchy and the next would be hard and rubbery or inedible. Other than that, We will definitely come back as our waitress, food and competent chefs have made this a great memory with many more to come.
… moreRachel
Great place! They have quite the system for getting people served in a timely manner. Our steaks were both great and our waitress was very nice and attentive. We will definitely be back!
… moreKeith Lennop
Food is as good as any supper club, the steak plates ate always a plus. We pass a lot of other really good supper clubs on the way to this and it is an hour drive which is what makes this one hard to rank at the top. I dont love the atmosphere in the bar area but that is just my opinion, I feel like they could make it a lot nicer. The eating/sitting area is nice though because they decorate for the seasons. Wait staff always does a nice job also.
… moreMarilyn Carlson
A great old fashioned supper club! Fabulous food and good prices. The service was wonderful. Everyone was friendly, upbeat, and very helpful. There were a lot of people in a lounge areaf, but we ordered before being seated and only waited about 10 minutes before being seated at a table. Delicious!
… moreBruce Danek
Great supper club. All of our food was very good. Friendly service, too. My prime rib was tender and tasty. The double baked potato was just right. Cheese cake was big and scrumptious.
… moreTim F
Our first experience visiting… a little nervous because we didn’t know how it worked, but it was great. Get a menu, pick out your food, stand your menu up and boom they take your order and call you to your table when it is ready. The salad is already set and you sit to eat. The food was delicious, I loved the Union rings and crab cakes plus the prime rib was delicious!
I highly recommend and will eat here again!
… moreI highly recommend and will eat here again!
Eric T
We traveled North just to experience this place. We enjoyed ourselves to the fullest. The food was delicious, affordable and they serve generous portions.
Excellent experience.
… moreExcellent experience.
Ralph Brookens
True Wisconsin Supper Club experience! The place was packed on a race night with a hour plus wait but it was well worth the time. They’re best known for their steaks but the salmon and prime rib were also well received.
… morejason puls
Schwartz’s was a destination supper club for our group and was worth the trip! The best part about it was the great people serving at the bar and in the dining area. Awesome service! Our food was very good well prepared and very tasty! Definitely worth checking out!
… more