Brandy Hart Carroll
I stopped by because of the mini coconut cream pies and they did not disappoint. I ended up picking up things for my family and my mother for Secretary’s Day. The banana pudding is a favorite of my husband and daughter. I tried a banana strawberry pie parfait (I don’t remember the name of it so it was like a killer). The fruit was fresh and tasty and I loved the pie crust crumbles added and fresh whipping cream. The lemon bar was wonderful! The cream puff was out of this world! It was the first time I’ve tried any of her cookies and oh my goodness…. Amazing!!!! We had 2 chocolate chip cookies and a Mac daddy cookie which had nuts and coconut with a chocolate drizzle. I will forever be getting cookies up there! The best cookies we have had in this valley for sure.
… moreArika Jayne (AJ)
I LOVE Sarah’s Bakery! I could list all the items I love, but we’d be here all day. The service is always prompt & courteous. The baked goods will blow your hair back, and the dinner and sides options are always a hit at my house. Do yourself a favor, and go grab a creampuff!
… moreJessica Newman
I went to Sarah’s Bakery my 1st time today and got a few things. Everything looked so good. The peanut butter cupcake was so good.
… moreLisa Williams
Great service and fresh baked items. The taste holds fresh ingredients. Cinnamon rolls were delicious and icing was not too sweet but generous. Our second visit disappointed when cinnamon rolls were sold out at 10:00am due to a large order. That tells you all you need to know. Enjoy the pictures and make it a must stop by on your way through. Our families enjoyed the whoopie pies, coconut pie, cream horns, snickerdoodle, and cheesecake. The cheesecake was very good but not your heavy authentic cheesecake.
… moreApril Pauley
I bought a little of everything yesterday for my first time at Sarah’s Bakery. Their hummus and pimento cheese are both so freaking good – I served them with crackers for a family get-together. I also had their banana pudding – it’s a new fave. And their cupcakes, lemon bars, and pumpkin whoopie pies…all also delicious. The staff is super friendly, which is always a plus.
… moreMkv_James
Cookies are large, they were definitely on the stale/hard side though. Came later in the evening. May have played a part in it.
… moreJoel Bailey
Sarah’s is a great little bakery and always has a great selection and very nice staff. Their Curry Chicken Salad is incredible and I always get some of that when i see it there. This visit I picked up a few things for Valentine’s Day that all look great, and if they’re half as good as they look they’ll be amazing. Definitely give them a try if you’re in the mood for something sweet, or give their salads and pasta mixes a try if you want something else.
… moreAnna Crane
Hands down the best chocolate covered strawberries I’ve ever had… I can’t wait for my moms to try em… thanks guys so much. Everyone was nice and the place looks and smells amazing, honestly glad I could support locally instead of chains!!!! I would give you 100 stars if I could!!!
… moreMyra Kennedy
Ive been dying to come here! I don’t currently live in West Virginia, so now that I’ve got the chance to come, I took it! I adore the home feeling inside and so excited to try all of the treats!
… moreCozy Hope
We got a bakers dozen of cukecakes and a blueberry breakfast cake today and we could not be more happy with the service and the atmosphere of the shop. When we renew our vows we are definitely getting something nice from here! I can’t wait to come back and get more!
… more