Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1030 Payne Ave, North Tonawanda, NY 14120
Phone: (716) 957-3903
Website: http://www.mypizzaamore.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Wood-Fired Pizza in Buffalo & Grand Island Pizza Amore | Pizza …
Location #2 & Hours Pizza Amore “The Wood Fire Way” 1030 Payne Ave North Tonawanda, NY 14120 716-957-3903 · Monday · Tuesday · Wednesday · Thursday · Friday.
NT – Pizza Amore “The Wood Fire Way” | North Tonawanda NY
North Tonawanda FB page for Pizza Amore “The Wood Fire Way” – serving Wood Fired Brick… See more. Pizza place · @pizzaamore64 · $$ · (716) 957-3903.
Order Pizza Amore The Wood Fire Way NT – Uber Eats
Use your Uber account to order delivery from Pizza Amore The Wood Fire Way NT in North Tonawanda. Browse the menu, view popular items, and track your order.
Reviews
Paul Lanier
Pizza Amore “The Wood Fire Way” has built a strong reputation as a go-to pizza spot in North Tonawanda, earning generally positive ratings for its flavorful wood-fired pies and welcoming service. Many customers consistently praise the unique taste of the crust, noting its slightly smoky flavor and fresh ingredients, while specialty pizzas — including creative combinations and chicken wing–inspired options — are frequently highlighted as standouts that set the restaurant apart from more traditional pizzerias. Reviewers often describe the staff as friendly, attentive, and efficient, whether dining in or ordering takeout, and several mention that the casual, comfortable atmosphere makes it a convenient spot for families and small groups. At the same time, feedback suggests that experiences can occasionally vary, with some customers commenting that certain pizzas have been softer or greasier than expected due to generous cheese portions, and a few mentioning longer wait times or minor order mix-ups during busy periods. Despite these criticisms, the overall tone of online reviews reflects satisfaction with the restaurant’s quality, value, and distinctive wood-fired style, with many loyal patrons saying they return regularly because the flavor and service outweigh occasional inconsistencies, making Pizza Amore a well-regarded and popular dining choice in the local community.
… moreMarissa
I am NEVER disappointed. The food is always amazing, the service is not only friendly but fast & organized.
If I could give more stars I would!
The picture below is their breakfast pizza – 10 out of 10!
… moreIf I could give more stars I would!
The picture below is their breakfast pizza – 10 out of 10!
Michelle Yakich
New to the area and this place was extremely disappointing! Do not recommend. The price was outrageous for what we received. Arrived on time and was told it would be another 15 minutes. Ordered a Greek salad with cheese and 2 different dressings on the side because of allergies and they didn’t put the cheese on the side, they ran out of feta, then said it would take 10 more minutes to remake it as well as didn’t give us the correct extra dressing flavor that was paid for. No discount or remedy for it. Or friend the salad was ordered for wasn’t able to eat the salad because of the cheese allergy, complete waste. Atmosphere and customer service was appropriate to a fast food restaurant not an expensive pizza place.
That being said the pepperoni pizza and wings were good, the cannoli pizza was okay, and we won’t return or recommend.
… moreThat being said the pepperoni pizza and wings were good, the cannoli pizza was okay, and we won’t return or recommend.
DREDDU
Actually very good. Nice and cheesy, delicious crust and pepperoni cups has a real nice spice. White pizza with anchovies was real good. Definitely order from there again.
Went back and ordered cheese and pepperoni and a single order of bbq wings with hot sauce on it. WOW. Wings are baked in the wood fired pizza oven and they taste amazing, the wood gives it a very delicious flavor. My new go to place, easily. Service was the best, friendly, quick, i wish I would have got the young lady’s name that served me. Place was very clean and you literally look right into the oven as they make your food. Can’t wait to try the other food on the menu.
… moreWent back and ordered cheese and pepperoni and a single order of bbq wings with hot sauce on it. WOW. Wings are baked in the wood fired pizza oven and they taste amazing, the wood gives it a very delicious flavor. My new go to place, easily. Service was the best, friendly, quick, i wish I would have got the young lady’s name that served me. Place was very clean and you literally look right into the oven as they make your food. Can’t wait to try the other food on the menu.
Vanecia C
Food was way too burnt
Love the fact that they bake the fries & wings but they kept it in the oven way too long. Crust on the pizza was also burnt! 1st and last order from this place. I just received this order 15 minutes ago.To the (Owner) On the website which is where I ordered from it didn’t give a option for a “lighter char” and the pizza still shouldn’t have been charred/burnt!! A friend of mine said I should have call u guys to complain but I had already left the review. Fries should’ve been delivered charred to hell & unable to eat though!! Make sure each order is properly cooked next time.
… moreLove the fact that they bake the fries & wings but they kept it in the oven way too long. Crust on the pizza was also burnt! 1st and last order from this place. I just received this order 15 minutes ago.To the (Owner) On the website which is where I ordered from it didn’t give a option for a “lighter char” and the pizza still shouldn’t have been charred/burnt!! A friend of mine said I should have call u guys to complain but I had already left the review. Fries should’ve been delivered charred to hell & unable to eat though!! Make sure each order is properly cooked next time.
Ula Jebara
If you like pizza that’s similar to Neapolitan, and open before 4pm grab some pizza amoreee.
Their pizza was actually very good.
Saucy! Pizza is always better hot & on the spot as any pizza via dlvy cools down & will not be the same. It was far better than I expected and these days,’ You’re not spending less than 25 plus on a pie. Pricing was actually very good because I can go down the street and spend double on a pie etc, that’s not nearly as good.
It’s filling as well and the young lady there was very helpful.
It’s easy to miss this place just because of the traffic & area. Try not to and thank me later ☺️The only thing I would say and maybe some more cheese on the slices? But that’s just a Ula request. The pizza is supposed to be exactly how It was made. I was impressed.
Thank you!
… moreTheir pizza was actually very good.
Saucy! Pizza is always better hot & on the spot as any pizza via dlvy cools down & will not be the same. It was far better than I expected and these days,’ You’re not spending less than 25 plus on a pie. Pricing was actually very good because I can go down the street and spend double on a pie etc, that’s not nearly as good.
It’s filling as well and the young lady there was very helpful.
It’s easy to miss this place just because of the traffic & area. Try not to and thank me later ☺️The only thing I would say and maybe some more cheese on the slices? But that’s just a Ula request. The pizza is supposed to be exactly how It was made. I was impressed.
Thank you!
Becky Phillips
We’re visiting the area and needed lunch while we were doing some errands and sightseeing. We saw this place and whipped in. We ordered a large Godfather. We both got a coke and our total came to $32.40 plus tip. We sat outside on this beautiful day. We had plenty leftover for later. The pizza was delicious.
… moreCrowned Alpha Barbershop
Great place to get some pizza!!! Went to this location for the first time after trying their pizza that they served off of their food truck! It was GREAT!! Plenty of parking right in front, super friendly staff, pizza made to order and out the door in less than 15 minutes. Everything was made exactly how I asked and I even tried their cannolis…. Very good by the way. Thanks guys I’ll be back for sure… keep up the good work in North Tonawanda.
… moreJerry Boye
We ordered a large Dee’s Hot Honey. What a limp, sloppy, soupy mess! Is it always this bad or does it just not travel well during a delivery?
… moreKelli
So I recently started a job across the street and I didn’t feel like making dinner tonight just so happened I checked the reviews on Google and they weren’t great but I was feeling lazy wanted to try something new and didn’t want to cook boy am I glad I got pizza from Pizza amore Literally The best stinger pizza I’ve ever had in my life no joke I got pepperoni pizza for the kids it was also really good no complaints we will be ordering from here again for sure!!! The staff was amazing!!!
… more