Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 611 Myrtle Ave, Punxsutawney, PA 15767
Phone: (814) 938-8443
Related Web Results
Defelice Sarah L The Original Pizza House | Punxsutawney PA
Defelice Sarah L The Original Pizza House, Punxsutawney. 836 likes · 127 were here. Pizza place.
Sarah L Defelice Pizza House: Discover Authentic Pizza in …
Welcome to Sarah L Defelice Pizza House, a cherished gem located at 611 Myrtle Ave in Punxsutawney, PA. Known for its irresistible, creamy pizza sauce and …
Sarah L Defelice Pizza House – The Punxsutawney Spirit
Pizza in 611 Myrtle Ave, Punxsutawney, PA 15767.
Reviews
Duck Hodges
One of the best pizza’s in town! Similar to Laska’s pizza style but I like Sarah’s a lot better.
Only open weekends and different hours but definitely worth it!
… moreOnly open weekends and different hours but definitely worth it!
Deacon Bair
Honesty not bad maybe a little sketchy lol but not bad it’s like Laskas Pizza but I’m my opinion a little worse. The sauce is sweet and pretty similar honestly. It’s definitely more soggy than Laskas tho. You go up the like a side pouch and wait for a light to turn on then order I think it’s just the one lady who makes everything but the pizza is DIRT CHEAP! So it’s actually very good for its price.
… moreTealy Tina
1 size pizza- around 14 inches- 8 slices
Choose between pepperoni or cheese. Thin crust but not crunchy. $14 for both pizzas
I don’t know what the sauce is but it was creamy good.
Pizza pickup out of a home.
… moreChoose between pepperoni or cheese. Thin crust but not crunchy. $14 for both pizzas
I don’t know what the sauce is but it was creamy good.
Pizza pickup out of a home.
Garry Leckemby
No matter where I go un life, I always yearn to return to my hometown of Punxsutwaney to enjoy a Defelice’s pizza. There is no other pizza in this world that I enjoy more. You the best!
… moreRobert Lichy
We moved from Punxsutawney in 1970 but never forgot our favorite pizza. We have been telling people for 54 years that the best pizza in the country is right there at Sarah Defelice House. Yesterday, we had the opportunity to go back to Punxy just to have our favorite. It did not disappoint. We sat in our car across the street and enjoyed. It’s still the best pizza in the country.
… moreKris Mroskey
Absolutely love this pizza. My family has been getting them since the early 70’s. This is the original and the best !!
… moreJD
The OG pizza in Punxsutawney and better in every way than Laska’s Pizza. Defelice wins on taste, customer service, price, and convenience. OG for a reason.
… moreElaine Berry
My family has been getting pizza from Mrs. Defelice since I was a little girl in the 60s. It’s not a fancy pizza, only comes with pepperoni (and not very much, at that). But the sauce and the cheese blend is something me, my children, my siblings, my parents, my cousins, everyone in the family, just CRAVE. None of the family live in Punxsy anymore but when we come to town, we always order massive quantities. Always.
… moreMichele White
Best pizza in Punxsutawney hands down!
I grew up on these pizzas and now that I live in Texas I miss them.
Always have to get them when I come home. They are AMAZING.
… moreI grew up on these pizzas and now that I live in Texas I miss them.
Always have to get them when I come home. They are AMAZING.