Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 322 N Commercial St, Neenah, WI 54956
Phone: (920) 725-2671
Website: https://www.sammyspizzaneenah.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sammy’s Pizza In Neenah | Pizza | Neenah, WI
Serving the Finest Pizza Since 1958. Freshly Made, Old-World Style Pizza. Sammy’s Pizza In Neenah isn’t making fast food. We make pizza from homemade dough.
Sammy’s Pizza – Neenah WI – Facebook
We will be Closed this evening. We’ll be back Open on Wednesday for Lunch (11am- 1pm) and Dinner (4:30pm) Stay safe and thanks for the continued support! We …
Sammy’s Pizza In Neenah – Your Go-To Spot for Delicious Pizza
Sammy’s Pizza In Neenah has quickly carved a niche for itself among local pizza enthusiasts. Situated at 322 N Commercial St, this cozy eatery not only boasts a …
Reviews
TravelerfromNineTwoZero
Unbelievably good pizza at a price that makes you feel like you are a millionaire all in a true pizza location. Definitely stop in and enjoy the Za!
… moreSara Johnson
Love their pizza! and the garlic crust is so good! I normally like thick crust pizza more but they have me hooked. A friend introduced me and now I’m addicted. They are also always so friendly when I go get my pick up order:)
… moreManuel Vivas
From the moment we entered until when we left, we were treated very nicely. The menu is simple and I felt that the prices were fair. While we waited, we played a few of the claw machines by the entrance, which was a nice time waster. To top it all off, the pizza was nothing short of amazing. I ordered the house special and enjoyed it thoroughly. I’ll probably be coming back here again. Also, if you save your receipts, your 16th order is free!
… moreManny
Sammy’s is a fabulous restaurant and the staff is friendly and accommodating. We love their pizza! The garlic bread is superb and everything was cooked just perfectly
… moreMarcus Burr
place has a cozy atmosphere. the staff are very polite. Occasionally the place gets very busy in the evening and there is a bit of a wait but the staff do a good job of estimating how long it will take to get to your order. Possibly one of the best tasting pizza’s out there. certainly the best pizza in the valley.
… moreDaniel Wahlstrand
Tom and his staff are very friendly and his lunch special is too good to pass up sometimes!
He’s always got something good on TV, too, usually horror genre films.
… moreHe’s always got something good on TV, too, usually horror genre films.
Patricia Katzman
A great place for pizza for a family night out on a Sun. night. One of our favorites. The Cheese Garlic Bread is always a must. We had the 12 inch Sammy’s Special. Others a large Pepperoni & a large Sausage for a family of four. It was good as always. Thin crust is pefect. Friendly efficient service. If you still have room they have complimentary ice cream sandwiches with pizza orders. We were all too full to have one. We will be back. Worth the little extra trip from Appleton to Neenah.
… moreChazz
Its all about the pizza and their recipe is damn near perfect. Im surprised more people haven’t tried Sammy’s
… moreR H
Ordered a large pepperoni and extra cheese pizza with a side of garlic bread from Sammy’s we were told about an hour for delivery which was fine I believe it came in under an hour. I love pizza and have had it in many cities and states and Sammy’s is another in a long line of family pizza places I have tried. It was very good as was the garlic bread there was plenty of cheese and Pepperoni on the pie and the crust was excellent. I have one complaint I don’t think they have a warming oven in there delivery vehicle as both the pizza and garlic bread were a bit cool now I’m not going to deduct anything from the pizza or Sammy’s as there are many places just like them who sometimes don’t have them in there delivery vehicles and having learned that over the years I had the oven on to warm the pie and bread back up. So no harm no foul I only mention it so that folks can be be aware and get there pizza back up to temperature. No insult intended Sammy’s. Good pie.
… moreKatie Driggers
This place was awesome. Best tasting pizza in Neenah. Menu is simple and not over complicated. And who can beat free ice cream sandwiches with your meal?! Prices are so affordable. We will be back!
… more