Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
The story of SALT started with Keith and Ali’s love for Shelter Island. SALT was designed as a come as you are restaurant with a focus on fresh and local foods, that anyone can enjoy. They wanted to create a place they would want to go for dinner or drinks and find friendly service from other people who live and love Shelter Island. We treat locals like celebrities and celebrities like locals!
Indoor-outdoor site on the water with creative eats, cocktails & a kids’ menu, sundecks & boat dock.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 63 Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Phone: (631) 749-5535
Website: https://www.saltshelterisland.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Salt Shelter Island
A fresh coastal-inspired cuisine in a cozy, boat-friendly setting with dockside dining, marina views, and a touch of laid-back island elegance.
SALT Waterfront Bar and Grill | Shelter Island NY – Facebook
SALT Waterfront Bar and Grill, Shelter Island, New York. 5374 likes · 15761 were here. SALT Waterfront Bar and Grill – Fresh food and frozen drinks on…
SALT Shelter Island (@saltshelterisland) – Instagram
6K+ followers · 649 following · 382 posts · @saltshelterisland: “Family-owned restaurant featuring locally sourced food located on the West Neck Harbor on …
Reviews
Jen D
Great location on the dock overlooking the marina. I sat outside on the covered deck area. Service was friendly. Food was very fresh and good.
… moreDavid Joseph
I came here on a Sunday afternoon during Labor Day weekend on a day trip to Shelter Island from East Hampton with two others. We made the reservation for a lunch table two days prior on Yelp. Just to start off with, who uses Yelp for reservations any more? This is so dated and honestly emblematic of the experience we had.
The setting of the restaurant is fine. Along a Mariana that has covered outdoor seating and plenty of parking. The food is terribly expensive and not good. I got the lobster roll thinking that no one could mess up a lobster roll but I was wrong. The lobster was over cooked and lacking flavor. The snow crab roll was inedible.
The people who worked at the restaurant were friendly but a bit odd and like they didn’t really know how to work in a restaurant or communicate effectively.
I realize there are not a lot of options on Shelter Island in the summer for meals but I would not go back here and I would not recommend.
… moreThe setting of the restaurant is fine. Along a Mariana that has covered outdoor seating and plenty of parking. The food is terribly expensive and not good. I got the lobster roll thinking that no one could mess up a lobster roll but I was wrong. The lobster was over cooked and lacking flavor. The snow crab roll was inedible.
The people who worked at the restaurant were friendly but a bit odd and like they didn’t really know how to work in a restaurant or communicate effectively.
I realize there are not a lot of options on Shelter Island in the summer for meals but I would not go back here and I would not recommend.
Zyaki
SALT is one of my favorite spots on Shelter Island. The setting is beautiful, right on the marina, and it has such a relaxing vibe. I’ve been a few times now and the food is always fresh and delicious. The lobster roll is a standout and the fish tacos are also really good. The staff is friendly and the service is quick, even when it gets busy. It’s a great place to sit outside, enjoy the view, and have a nice meal with friends or family. Every time I go, I leave happy. Highly recommend if you’re visiting the island.
… moreVincent Gatto
The fact I couldn’t get pictures of the two entree’s should be very telling. Every dish we ordered was fantastic, made with such talent and love. Please do yourself the favor of trying the seared Tuna sandwich!!!! Fantastic. And the Carrot cake is good enough to save the world. A great variety of drinks as well. Blue crab roll is distinctly East end, a diverse taste that feels at home on the docks of SALT. I wish the Artichoke had some more garlic/ginger or just another primary flavor to enhance the artichoke texture and taste. Looking forward to seeing this place in full summer bloom. Come check it out!!
… moreAimee Slappay
Drinks were eh but the food was good! The vibe was nice , right on the water. We got the Lobster Cobb Salad and the Tuna Poke Bowl.
… moreAngela H
We made reservations through Open Table and were seated promptly upon arrival. The wait staff was friendly and always had a smile on their faces. Salt is a nice laid back and cozy eatery with nice views. The menu had a nice mix of food to choose from and was amazingly well prepared. We had a wonderful time and will definitely be coming back.
… moreJackie Gordon Singing Chef
We had the sweetest waitress! She was not only super bubbly but she was on top of everything.
Nice clam chowder.
While it was fresh, we thought the poke bowl was a bit dull considering how many options there are when you go to a poke restaurant Throwing on some toasted sesame seeds, scallions, edamame, nori flakes, sliced cucumbers shredded carrots, shredded red cabbage, crispy onions from a jar, etc. could go a long way in making this dish more tasty, delightful and colorful without increasing the food cost very much.
BF enjoyed his lobster roll which was expensive but had a lot of lobster on it. Probably enough for two lobster rolls in the city.
… moreNice clam chowder.
While it was fresh, we thought the poke bowl was a bit dull considering how many options there are when you go to a poke restaurant Throwing on some toasted sesame seeds, scallions, edamame, nori flakes, sliced cucumbers shredded carrots, shredded red cabbage, crispy onions from a jar, etc. could go a long way in making this dish more tasty, delightful and colorful without increasing the food cost very much.
BF enjoyed his lobster roll which was expensive but had a lot of lobster on it. Probably enough for two lobster rolls in the city.
Mr. Kyle Carroll
Salt was great for a Sunday lunch. The GF and I, took the ferry over in the morning. Drove around and checked out the island. We ate lunch at Salt. I recommend you make reservations as it fills up fast. I had the Lobster Roll and she had a sushi roll. We sat outside, right next to the boats docked. The atmosphere was great on a beautiful Sunday. Service was great and the food was delicious. We plan to return.
… moreSteph Wells
Service was A++++, our server, Jackie, was such a gem, wow. The best attitude, so friendly, just amazing vibes. She was such a bright light in our evening. Also, the food was fantastic, actually the best lobster roll I’ve ever had!!
… moreEugenia T
Everything was so delicious, we can.e there 2 times, mussels, shrimp with polenta was my favorite, crab cakes that we ordered 3 times in a row, carrot cake was fire! Beautiful location!
… more