Sally’s Apizza was founded in New Haven, CT by Salvatore “Sally” Consiglio in 1938. We hand-craft authentic New Haven pizza in custom-designed ovens, using the original recipes. Famous for our distinctive tomato sauce and chewy, crispy crust with an iconic oven-kissed char, Sally’s draws pizza fans from around the world.
John Cox
We had 3 amazing pizzas, the 3rd was a surprise! White clam and added bacon, hot honey, ricotta and pepperoni and the stinger pie! The surprise, the Stinger was not ordered but we were given it! We were debating getting it and they surprised us with it! It was both sweet and spicy! I enjoyed the white clam pie the best! Great atmosphere and excellent customer service! Our waiter, Brandon, was very attentive! Will definitely come back!
… moreDenise A.
We have been multiple times to the original Sally’s New Haven location and this was our second vist to the Fairfield location. My son who lives in Maine has declared this to be his favorite CT pizza place ( yes, he has been to Pepe’s and Modern) so we were so glad to be able to make reservations at this location for his recent visit.
We arrived about 10 mins before the reservation and were soon seated, provided with menus, and drinks, orders take.
We ordered 3 pizzas, one large pepperoni and sausage, one small extra mozzarella and pepperoni, and one small tomato and mozzarella with garlic and 1/2 meatball.
The pizzas came fast and we tasted just as fantastic as they always do; nice char, great tasting sauce and cheese, and piping hot! This location’s pizza is comparable to the NH location without the hassle of finding parking and waiting in an endless line. It might even make the pizza taste better! And the olive oil cake is amazing, so get it to take home if too full.
The service was great and we so enjoyed the whole experience. The esstablisment and restrooms were very clean and there is ample off street parking.
We will be coming back.
… moreStefanie Moghadasi
Had such a wonderful event at Sally’s Apizza in Fairfield! Helen, James, Kyle, and Brandon all made the experience amazing. They created such a fun, welcoming environment, and the pizza making was a huge hit. The combination of delicious pizza and great people made it an unforgettable event. The girls attending had a blast and such a fun time, and we are so thankful to the team for allowing us to do this. Every worker we met was so kind and helpful
… moreHeart
Was a little nervous about going here because of the architecturally-hostile rich-people apartment complex it resides within, but this was really great. the service was wonderful & the pizza was delicious (potato & rosemary and Calabrian). Corny wall decor though!
… morechez San
Napoli style Pizza mixed with various toppings.
Taste was good but Napoli pizza is not my favorite Lol.(That is why I deduct 1 star)
Service was excellent.
Atmosphere was good.
… moreAtiya Sample
6-21-25
On a Positive Note: The shrimp scampi pizza was yummy!
Pepe’s had a line out the door, so we decided to give us a try. We were happy we did. The pizza was absolutely delicious. The reason why I only gave it. Four stars is because my mom‘s burrata pizza wasn’t hot, but we didn’t complain.
The service was great. I ordered the olive oil cake to go. It looked averaged, due to being wrapped to go but the taste was perfect. (I tried it as soon as I reached home.) The cake wasn’t too sweet and it was moist. Our server explained that it is made with olive oil instead of eggs.
The Verdict: We will be back soon.
A Daily Diner
… moreYogi Brian Buturla
We have had many a great family occasion here! Comfortable, spread out and perfect ambience. You can breath here, catch up with life and eat great food. People who work here get it right and try hard to do so. We thank you from our family for being awesome to your own uniqueness. The Farfield community and beyond is blessed to have such a great place to unwind from the fast pace of life. Don’t forget to order a coffee (it is great too) to complete the reboot.
… moreAmelia H
Run don’t walk for Sally’s pizza! We loved our experience, our server Brandon was great. Checked in on us and made sure we always had water. We ordered the Caesar salad which was perfect and we enjoyed the pickled onion in the salad. The meatballs had the great sauce. Pizza was by far the star of the show. We got the tomato pie which is great if you don’t like greasy overly cheesy pizza. They also have on the table Parmesan cheese, oregano, garlic, salt and pepper on the table so you have everything you need. If you like New Haven pizza you must try it.
… moreJust Jazzmine
This pizza was ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE and well worth the visit. This pizza was so good I could have polished off a large completely on my own. (I am a small female) I actually had to stop myself from bingeing on the pizza. Eat here please.
… moreEva Jay
I’ve been wanting to come here to see the comparison to New Haven. Sally’s is my favorite apizza. The location is beautiful. The staff was kind. We sat at the bar. The pizza is definitely not the same, it wasn’t bad just different. I would still drive to New Haven
… more