Maddie K
Baja Tacos were good, the Mahi was cooked well. The fried pickles were perfect. Waitress was very nice and accommodating
… moreTom Galligan
Home away from home. Casual, friendly, warm and inviting with one of the city’s best bartenders slinging drinks on weekends and Tuesday nights. Have Will make you a cocktail and fight off Scurvy with a pineapple wedge. Excellent food options (Strip steak was a perfectly cooked medium-rare) with a very flexible menu and kitchen staff willing to adapt. (“Buffalo chicken breast on a salad? No problem!”) Loaded nachos tray was bigger than my first apartment. Convenient spot on Lane Avenue with easy parking. Even when the front lot is busy, their best kept secret is the massive lot around the back (loop around the Whole Foods) that is never packed because newcomers don’t know it’s there. Pizzas, wings, peel and eat shrimp in Old Bay seasoning, all excellent. Phenomenal spot with excellent staff. Should’ve bought shares in it when it first opened. I’d be rich.
… moreCrystal Neely
I had finger food so I can’t really say if the food is amazing or not. What I had was nice but can’t mess up on chicken tenders. Atmosphere was nice and crowded. I would bet this is a great spot to meet up with friends for drinks and cocktails.
… moreDaniel Novakovsky
Came for an event for Mr. Putsch, was my first time in the resturant and I cannot say enough about the staff at this location. Nick was my go to for everything and his customer service was top notch! All the staff was friendly (as friendly as you can be on a packed Friday night), however big props to all involved! Will most definitely recommend and be visiting again many times.
… moreMadison Blosser
I had made a reservation for 2 at 5:15pm, we were really late arriving at 6pm. They were really busy, they hostess explained that they cancel the table after 30mins, we understood and said we can wait, but the hostess was able to set us right way.
We were quickly greeted by Chris. The service was great, the food was amazing, beverage was delicious, and we really enjoyed our time at The Rusty Bucket in Upper Arlington.
We ordered the Chicken Parmesan, and Beef Stroganoff with a Tequila Sunrise.
… moreCrystal Miller
Service was great but the food was phenomenal! Steak was cooked perfect and super tender. The corn salad was very delish too!
… morePaul Edwards
Food and service were both great! They even gave my grandson free dessert for his birthday.
… moreBethany Swedberg
Came here for dinner and drinks with a friend. The cincinnati chili is to die for, and the drinks specials during happy hour are awesome! The only negative thing I have to say is about the service. We sat at the bar and the bartender was extremely rude. I’m not sensitive to those things typically, but it felt like she went out of her way to be mean. The manager on duty was awesome though. Love rusty bucket overall. Will be back!
… moreVincent Lam
Rusty Bucket is one of my favorite American restaurant brands. Their sandwiches and burgers are always fresh and juicy. This place has a large dining room, a patio and a great bar with many big screens. Their service is excellent. WiFi is fast.
… moreshane Conners
We have visited the rusty bucket multiple times after dance competitions at upper Arlington high School. The food has always come out in a timely manner and we never leave hungry. The bartending staff are always upbeat and more professional than your typical pub Bartenders.
… more