Andrew McCaughna
I find it very hard to pick favorites, but this wins it for my favorite pizza place. I have been coming here since I was a kid, so I’m sure I’m biased, but something about this oven and the people over the years who have operated it really make it happen for me.
(Please note this is a pickup place only)
The current person is very kind and pleasant to speak to and I hope people get the chance to meet her. She puts a lot of love into her work. She does the old store name of “Don’s” justice as I remember growing up with this pizza. Great job!!
… moreJoshua Vaughn
The pizza was delicious! I haven’t had pizza made that well since I lived in Texas and the cinnamon sticks we also ordered were amazing. The manager came out to drop off our food and she was extremely kind and professional. My pregnant wife devoured a good amount of the pizza and cinnamon sticks so I would say she will be in a much better mood now that she got her cravings in check. Overall, we will definitely be going back for more delicious chicken bacon ranch pizza.
… moreDyana Gebauer
Let’s be honest—when you first pull up to Round Lake Pizza, located inside an aged gas station, you might question your choices but trust me—push past the looks, step inside, and prepare to have all doubts erased by some of the best local pizza!
Being such a small shop means wait times can be long—but that’s only because they’re putting in the effort to make every pizza just right. And it’s worth it. The crust is perfect, the toppings are generous, and the flavor? Unreal. It’s my absolute favorite local pizza and I keep coming back for more.
Round Lake Pizza is a hidden gem.
… moreSteve Moody
First time getting pizza here. Definitely worth the short drive. Plenty of toppings and tasted great. Ordered a 12″ made a large instead and got for the price of a 12″
… morejeffrey S
Round Lake Road Pizza is a must-try, one-of-a-kind hidden gem that deserves all five stars! All fancy writing aside, don’t miss out on this; I promise it’s worth it.
… moreJamie Benner
We stayed at Sleepy Hollow State Park and on our last night we found Round Lake Pizza through Google. 10 minutes drive from the campgrounds. The pizza was fantastic!!! The service on the phone and at the counter ter was friendly and polite. I highly recommend this place. pick up only.
… morePhilip Van Ee
This is the best pizza in the area in my opinion. When we get pizza this is where we go. Everything about it is just better than anyone else around. It is carry out only so the 5 star on Atmosphere is for the convenince store it is located in. They have a very impressive liquor, beer and wine selection along with all the other usual convenice store items.
… moreMichele M Dixon
This place is AMAZING! If you are looking for a new pizza spot, you need to come here. We ordered pizza, cheesy breadsticks and then decided to get dessert. So we got cinnamon sugar breadsticks. All my family and I can say is WOW! Love supporting local small business as well.
… moreJust Melissa
We ordered two pizzas cheese breadsticks and cinnamon sticks. Everything was absolutely wonderful and very tasty!
Would recommend and definitely get the cream cheese with the breadsticks! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
… moreRob Just
This is the best pizza I ever ate. when i ate this pizza, Lebron James appeared in front of me, he said I love round lake pizza.
Def Mario approved let’s-a-go
… more