Alex Graber
Pretty good fish fry! The potato pancakes were very crispy – almost like a hashbrown. The fish was crispy yet light. A bit confused why applesauce isn’t just included and counts as a separate side. The old fashioned was good, average. Good service. I definitely recommend trying it.
… moreDavid Fannon
Very nice place to visit on the lake. Great food and apps.
… moreDane Dorn
Came in with family from the boat. Appetizers were decent. The burgers look good but were a bit over cooked and dry. Service was marginal and slow.
… moreKevin Stauske
We went on a Sat. Afternoon. Sat at bar, bar was not that busy. Waitress pretty much ignored us for 8-10 minutes. Flagged her down and asked if we could get a drink, she tried to not look at us saying when I have time. Any good server would look at you and say I’ll be right with you, correct? Not her. Then 6 of our friends came a little bit later. She took care of them. When we were ready for our second drink, again just ignored us, two of our friends tried to get her attention but she just kept walking past!! We just got up and left then. Never had such a bad bartender if you don’t like your job quit then.
… moreBrian Lewin
Great pub across the street from Green Lake. Nice breezes in the afternoon after a day on the Lake or on the golf course. Drinks are great! Colton our bartender and server was friendly and knew the menu well. The cheese blocks are unlike anything I’ve had before. Gooey Cheddar cheese in a very light, crispy batter. Better than cheese curds! Reilly roll is essentially a Reuben egg roll and features thick pieces of homemade corned beef. The pretzel sticks are chewy with a little crust. Homemade beer cheese is delicious. (Try dipping the cheese blocks in the beer cheese that comes with the pretzels). The burgers are solid. The Reuben’s, however, are outstanding! The corned beef is thick sliced, with just enough sauerkraut. Oreo cheesecake was phenomenal! So good we came back the next night.
… moreLaramie Weiss
This review is for the margarita pizza. I’ve been to Reilly’s before and generally like it. But the amount of balsamic drizzle on the pizza was overwhelming to the point of it being unappetizing I don’t recommend it.
… moreDavid Else
Green Lake Terrace area. Hadn’t been back to Wisconsin in four years. Needed some burgers, cheese curds, and some brandy ole fashioned’s. While seated at the bar had a view of Green Lake. Many TVs with different stations being played simultaneously.
… morePaul Drayna
They were short staffed which made wait for table exceptionally long and service slow. But staff was extremely friendly and apologized. Food was solid. Drinks were large and strong.
… morejen pavlich
Good Atmosphere. Saturday night was a beautiful night to be able to sit out on the patio area. I tried their chicken, bacon, ranch pizza on cauliflower crust. Usually I get their Rubin sandwich which is always good but was in the mood for something different. The pizza was really good- the crust had a really nice flavor and crunch. I would definitely get again.They had live music which was set up across the street. There is a bartender outside in that area as well so you do not have to go back in for a drink.
… moreAlan Martens
My wife and I have gone here three out of the last four Fridays in a row. Every time I’ve ordered the butterfly broiled garlic shrimp with a baked potato and a tossed salad. Just the right amount of food and the shrimp has got to be fresh because it is just so good. I start thinking about going Thursday evening already.
… more