Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Stalwart pizza parlor serving whole pies & specialty slices along with wings, subs & calzones.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1 Garfield St, Waverly, NY 14892
Phone: (607) 565-2004
Website: http://www.pudgiespizza.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Waverly – Pudgies Pizza
Location. Pudgies Waverly. 1 Garfield St Waverly, NY 14892. Working Hours … 2025 Pudgies Pizza | All rights reserved | Proudly created by Rugglion Media.
Pudgies Pizza – Southern Tier’s King of Pizzas Since 1963
#1 Since 1963 · PIZZA · PASTA · SUBS · Our Delicious Menu · Areas We Serve · What Our Customers Say.
Waverly & Sayre Pudgie’s Pizza, Pasta, & Subs – Facebook
Details. . Closed now. . 1 Garfield Street , Waverly, NY, United States, 14892. Links. . pudgiespizza.com. Contact info. . (607) 565-2004. . kbrown@ …
Reviews
Nicki Bratz
Mediocre chain style food. Should be in Pennsylvania not New York. Everything tastes bland and boring. The puffy “pizza” iz more like flavored bread painted with canned tomato paste and plastic cheese. The sandwiches have no no flavor they’re just thrown together with generic ingredients. Itz like eating a shoe. The atmosphere is pretty much safety cone orange everywhere. If you’re starving it’s an easy and quick grab. For the area it’s probably considered good cuz of low expectations
… moreCheifin Keif (CheifinKeif)
I stopped here while on a work excursion and the pizza was good! Very Thick crust and good flavor of sauce. While i did enjoy the pizza it had reminisce of a lower quality pizza like a Pizza Hut deep dish, and exactly 4 pepperonis on each slice which just seemed weirdly proportional. Still devoured though and if it wasn’t for high price of food would return!
… moreJohn
The pizza tasted better than it looked, but was small. The service was slow.
… morebelinda wood
Pizza is always consistent. The boneless wings are delicious. Staff is always extremely friendly and helpful. Any issues are always addressed and made right. Very pleased with the last pie we ordered. Well worth the money.
… moreMadison Derrig
First, when I called, the lady that answered the phone was very rude, and had an additude with me, i was very nice and patient, i called an hour before the time I wanted to pick the pizza and wings up, so I was also being generous in giving them plenty of time so they didnt have to rush. We get to pudgies to pick up order and my boyfriend said that she had additude with him aswell, and seemed like everyone was in a bad mood. When we got home and opened the pizza every slice had exactly 3 pepperoni in a straight line at the tops of each slice. The ranch I got with the boneless wings was like jello so I passed on that and used my own. Not impressed at all. Never going there again.
… moreAmanda Rice
We had delivery to farmland animal park for my kids birthday and it was on time and the delivery driver had a great attitude.
… moreJacob Otto
This place is basically me and my family’s go to place to eat out. If they ever mess anything up they apologize with another whole sheet pizza it’s amazing and I would definitely recommend coming and eating here. Pizza from the past year has not been bad at all and it’s been delicious . The chicken wings are amazing too with the taste being absolutely delicious. 10/10 keep up the amazing job.
… moreMark Eikost (Ike)
Their thin crust option is great. Personal pizzas are the perfect size. We did take out. They were done quickly and the price was good
… moreSirrena Vose
I traveled to my hometown 2 years ago on Oct 16. (My nephew & my oldest sons birthday). They LOVE pudgies. My nephew had muscular dystrophy and hadn’t seen his cousins ( my sons) in many years. They were young men now. My youngest son, we had ” deliver” the pizza. We filmed as he entered the house, asked for a tip and behaved inappropriate for a delivery person. I told the manager what we were doing and she generously lent me a uniform. My nephew was so surprised, he said it was one of his best birthdays ever. So surprised . We lost him that following January. A huge thank you to your staff! They seemed so involved and interested in how it all went.
… more