Diane Anthony
Ordered a square thick crust with 3 toppings, got home and barely any toppings, and crust was so tough that you had to hold the slice with 2 hands to bite and keep the top on it. Called about the pizza that it wasn’t worth the $33 we paid for it. Chad wasn’t too concerned, said Sorry next time you order talk to a manger to ensure your order is correct”. REALLY!!! Guess we won’t be getting pizza there again
… moreRobert S
Delicious little pizza joint in Prospect. Got two of their thin crust pizzas, one regular with cheese and one specialty pie called the Margherita and they were both delicious. The crust was nice and well done, held up the pizza perfectly, and the toppings were all fresh and delicious. Would highly recommend.
… moreSamantha Ridgeway
I used to love this place but the quality of food is going down especially with their hoagies … 100% dough and very little meat!
The best pizza everrrrr
… moreDanae McDowell
Always delicious- you can’t go wrong with anything you chose, pizza, salads, calzones! The crust is so good. Prospect Pizza is easily our family’s go-to pizza shop! The staff is always so friendly too!
… moreD
Our first visit was awesome! Interesting to read mixed reviews after having the best pizza in the area. Everything about this place, from the friendly service, fresh tasting pizza and cute outdoor seating area was a positive experience. Loved the cornmeal sprinkled crispy crust with a delicious chewy center. Perfect amount of sauce and cheese. Pepperoni and mushroom toppings were plentiful. Happy we did not read reviews before ordering or we would have missed out on a great pizza experience.❤️
… moreAshley DeFonde
Terrible service called to order a pizza they said one hour I called back at a hr and half and my food is just sitting there and the kid tells me that they dont know when it will be delivered like it would of been 2.5 to 3 hrs till I got my hard nasty sandwichs unbelievable. Then was told to come get it so I paid a delivery fee why??? Also when arriving asked for a manager the kids laughed and said there really isnt one.. woww prospect do better i work in the food industry and I would be very disappointed to call this good customer service.. I would like a refund but u cant even get ahold of anyone till nighttime when there are no mature people.
… moreBrett Hutchison
I ordered in the past when the old owners owned Prospect Pizza and were always good. I finally had a chance to try it with the new owners and the pizza appeared good but there was a weird taste to it. My daughter thought the same thing. She only ate 1 slice and I had 2 out of a 12 cut. The young lady that waited on me was really polite and friendly though. I thought about complaining but I didn’t. They’re like a half hour away each way so I wasn’t driving back.
… moreAdam Quinn
Horrible service, sold me chicken Parmesan hoagie an item that’s not even on their menu, this was unknown to me. The manger is about as clueless as the rest of the workers there. Utter failure from the top down. Do better.
… moreSadler Priest
Great local spot! Pizza topping were fresh and sauce was on point!
… moreBen Bowman
First visit today, we will return any time we’re back in the area! Found you guys on maps, it was a good recommendation! The Mad dog and garlic bites took care of 4 hungry kids! Spent a few minutes talking with the owner while waiting for our order…great guy, great crew, and even better pizza!
… more