Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Casual Italian eatery serving a menu of serving pizza, subs, calzones, pasta & wings.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 30 Market St, Potsdam, NY 13676
Phone: (315) 265-5500
Website: https://www.toasttab.com/little-italy-potsdam-30-market-st
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Little Italy | Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria, Potsdam NY 13676
Fan Favorites · Some of our customers Go-To favorite dishes at Potsdam Little Italy · Established in 2001 · Whether you’re looking for quick bite to eat such as …
Potsdam Little Italy 30 MARKET ST – Order Online
Potsdam Little Italy 30 MARKET ST · Make Your Own Pizza Roll. $9.50 · Fried Chicken Roll. $10.25 · Broccoli Chicken Roll. $10.25 · Italian Pizza Roll. Ham, salami, …
Potsdam Little Italy – Facebook
Potsdam Little Italy, Potsdam. 3742 likes · 5 talking about this · 574 were here. Little italy located at 30 market Street in Potsdam. Pick up, dine in,…
Reviews
Lauren Chrisman
Afternoon lunch with my Mom, we were cold and hungry, left warm and FULLy satisfied. Natalia was our server; she was super nice and very attentive. We had an incredible lunch and hands down the best poutine! Kitchen/Staff were great , this was by far the best Little Italy I’ve been to. Perfect spot for a quick bite & take out! My Mom got mild chicken wings w/blue cheese, and a house salad w/ranch, their dressings were PHENOMENAL! My calzone was (pepperoni, mushroom, onion, black olive, and broccoli) HIGHLY, recommend.
… moreCris T.
The wings were super good and very big. I liked that they weren’t stingy with the ranch and give you a good amount of it. The garlic knots were nice and warm. It was pretty packed when I went so, I guess you can say it is a very popular spot.
… moreDia Fariha
I was craving for chocolate lava cake and saw that they have it on the menu and was excited to get it, but it’s just regular chocolate cake that was drizzled with chocolate syrup on top, didn’t have any molten chocolate coming out when I got to the middle. Their pizzas are great, but if they don’t know how to bake a lava cake, they shouldn’t have it on the menu.
… moreDustin Staires
UPDATE 08/29/2025
RIBEYE PHILLY CHEESESTEAK
I just spent around 5 months in and around Philly this past year, have eaten more Cheesesteaks than I’d like to admit, and this is the most legit one I’ve seen in Northern New York!
Most people think that a legit Cheesesteak comes standard with Peppers and or Mushrooms and that could not be further from the truth.
100% ! Highly Recommend trying this Cheesesteak as is and let it blow your mind!
UPDATE 07/16/2025
REVISED: 02/18/2026
OKAY! within the past few months the owner changed the dough recipe on their pizza and it is awesome for this area! It’s crispy and light. The ratios have definitely been dialed in compared to what it was. Also they have Cup & Char Pepperoni which is delicious. My absolute favorite is the Margherita Pizza cooked Well Done.
After traveling and eating Pizza all over I had to revise this review and be 100% honest.
I do believe it would be much better if the dough was fermented for at least 48 hours. The quality of the Cheese could be better for me personally. Also after careful consideration the sauce was really just mid at best.
There’s serious potential here and I hope things keep changing for the better.
UPDATE 03/14/2025
I lived in Utica, NY (Home of Chicken Riggies) for around 3 years of my life and I can say with confidence these are the best in all of Northern New York that I’ve had thus far and that includes Watertown.
ORIGINAL REVIEW:
I’ve been coming here on and off for years and in the past there were times I had minor issues. Within the past 6 months I’ve been here a bunch and every single time I’ve had excellent food and service! The Garlic Parm Wings and Homemade Blue Cheese Dressing are by far my favorite items on the menu. I really do enjoy a nice well done Cheese Pizza from here as well. If you had a poor experience here in the past give them another shot like I did. I explain to them what I want and how I want it and they give me exactly what I want!
… moreRIBEYE PHILLY CHEESESTEAK
I just spent around 5 months in and around Philly this past year, have eaten more Cheesesteaks than I’d like to admit, and this is the most legit one I’ve seen in Northern New York!
Most people think that a legit Cheesesteak comes standard with Peppers and or Mushrooms and that could not be further from the truth.
100% ! Highly Recommend trying this Cheesesteak as is and let it blow your mind!
UPDATE 07/16/2025
REVISED: 02/18/2026
OKAY! within the past few months the owner changed the dough recipe on their pizza and it is awesome for this area! It’s crispy and light. The ratios have definitely been dialed in compared to what it was. Also they have Cup & Char Pepperoni which is delicious. My absolute favorite is the Margherita Pizza cooked Well Done.
After traveling and eating Pizza all over I had to revise this review and be 100% honest.
I do believe it would be much better if the dough was fermented for at least 48 hours. The quality of the Cheese could be better for me personally. Also after careful consideration the sauce was really just mid at best.
There’s serious potential here and I hope things keep changing for the better.
UPDATE 03/14/2025
I lived in Utica, NY (Home of Chicken Riggies) for around 3 years of my life and I can say with confidence these are the best in all of Northern New York that I’ve had thus far and that includes Watertown.
ORIGINAL REVIEW:
I’ve been coming here on and off for years and in the past there were times I had minor issues. Within the past 6 months I’ve been here a bunch and every single time I’ve had excellent food and service! The Garlic Parm Wings and Homemade Blue Cheese Dressing are by far my favorite items on the menu. I really do enjoy a nice well done Cheese Pizza from here as well. If you had a poor experience here in the past give them another shot like I did. I explain to them what I want and how I want it and they give me exactly what I want!
Jim Sheppard
I have ordered from Little Italy in Potsdam on several occasions. Recently, I placed a pickup order for myself and some friends. Overall, it was a great experience. Everything was ready when I arrived. The online ordering process was simple. The staff were very friendly. I enjoyed my create your pasta dish, one friend had a calzone, and another had a buffalo chicken pizza. The one complaint was that the Buffalo Chicken Pizza was definitely on the mild side. My suggestion might be to add a hot sauce or honey hot drizzle to the ordering options.
… moreRiley Dashwood
Every single time I’ve ordered from here I’ve had nothing but fantastic experiences. Friendly employees, great cooks, and great delivery drivers and service. Everyone here is always friendly and willing to go the extra mile for their customers. They’re also notoriously quick to deliver most times while also following delivery instructions to the letter. The delivery drivers always leave a text or will call you directly to inform you of their drop off and every employee I’ve spoken with was always polite and welcoming! Highly recommend their wings and poutine. Their salads are also some of the freshest I’ve tried in the area.
… moreVerminDigital
The “buffalo” fries arrived with no buffalo sauce. Literally just fries and blue cheese.. when we notified them they said “we tossed it in buffalo sauce” .. look at this pic. There is NO buffalo sauce.
We also ordered eggplant parm, and they gave us a flavorless, soggy, eggplant parm sandwich..
… moreWe also ordered eggplant parm, and they gave us a flavorless, soggy, eggplant parm sandwich..
Sarah Hartman
The restaurant isn’t much and the pasta was meh, but my goodness those garlic knots were unbelievable. Price on pasta was way too high but not on the golden knots.
… moreDan Simmons
Was in town for the evening and wanted pizza and wings. Pizza with bacon, sausage, pepperoni and the maple bacon wings. Pizza was doughy and bland. Maple wings were made with artificial maple syrup. The wings weren’t even number of flats and drums, got 9 flats and 3 drums. Considering you can order all flats or drums for $3 more I figured they would be an even split on a regular order. Should have gone to the Pizza Hut around the corner.
… morejeremy riedl
I haven’t ordered pizza here for a couple of years soni thought I’d give it a try. We ordered an extra large pizza with half meatball and half fresh garlic, mushrooms onions and peppers. We also ordered a dozen garlic knots and an antipasto salad.
The salad was ok. It was what you might expect from a local pizza place. The garlic knots were also ok. One box was pretty good and the other six were clearly old and had been sitting around for hours. The pizza was absolutely disgusting. I love pizza and can forgive a lot of things, but this was raw in the middle. Clearly whoever is in the kitchen has no idea what they are doing. The meatball half was swimming in grease. It was pooled in the middle. The veggie half was soaking wet and clearly had not been cooked enough. I would have taken it back except my whole family was starving and so we choked down a couple pieces and threw out the rest see pictures below if you want to see what Little Italy in Potsdam is selling customers.
… moreThe salad was ok. It was what you might expect from a local pizza place. The garlic knots were also ok. One box was pretty good and the other six were clearly old and had been sitting around for hours. The pizza was absolutely disgusting. I love pizza and can forgive a lot of things, but this was raw in the middle. Clearly whoever is in the kitchen has no idea what they are doing. The meatball half was swimming in grease. It was pooled in the middle. The veggie half was soaking wet and clearly had not been cooked enough. I would have taken it back except my whole family was starving and so we choked down a couple pieces and threw out the rest see pictures below if you want to see what Little Italy in Potsdam is selling customers.