Portofino Bay Restaurant

  3.6 – 165 reviews   • Italian restaurant

Social Profile:

✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in Portofino Bay Restaurant 53948

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Restaurant, Lake Views – Portofinobayrestaurant – Mauston, Wisconsin

Menu · Portofino Marina Page. Portofino Bay Restaurant. N6895 Ridgewater Drive, Mauston, Wisconsin 53948, United States. 608-350-0555. Copyright © 2023 …

Portofino Bay | Mauston WI – Facebook

Waterfront restaurant & bar on beautiful Castle Rock Lake featuring American and Italian cuisine.

Portofinobayrestaurant

New Deck Bar Menu. Friday Fish Fry. Menu · Portofino Marina Page. Portofino Bay Restaurant. N6895 Ridgewater Drive, Mauston, Wisconsin 53948, United States.

Reviews

Tom S
Very limited menu. Not what we expected. Small portions. Nice outdoor seating. Limited staff. Nothing like what is advertised on the website. Only thing Italian is the frozen pizza. Was the 2nd day for the waitress but she was nice.
… more
Tiffany Coloni
The food was really good and our waitress was awesome, very attentive and even compt my mom a salad because her cod was small. The view and the live music made my night. I will definitely be returning again and again.
… more
Joseph Bokota
Gilligans is the coolest beach on the lake and is a great place to boat up to for a game of volleyball or spend some family time. They should build another tiki hut to have as a food stand and have a DJ/loud music or band during the weekends when it’s crowded.
… more
Dan Prigge
Nice looking place. Wreaks of sewage from the porta potty’s. Poor communication, we called 5 times before we came, with no answer during business hours. We were the only one there when we got there, stayed a few hours. No more patrons after a couple hours. Even the musician didn’t know what was going on due to poor communication from the owner. I can’t recommend the establishment. However they hire good entertainment. Even the bartenders were awkward and not real personable. Also poor beer selection for the area.
… more
Carmen Walters
Great atmosphere. Had the three mushroom swiss burger and it was good.
… more
Dan Simonetti
Good food, great atmosphere, great place to hear a band but do NOT expect good service. The service is absolutely horrible. Inexperienced bartenders and virtually no servers. Could be the best spot on the lake if they staffed it with quality bartenders/servers or at the very least train the ones you have.
… more
Tony Waski
New chef and menu, food was great. A few in our party of 10 had the Friday Fish Fry, it was excellent. The crispy chicken sandwich and fries were also excellent. We would have like Ice Tea and a kids menu but that did not put a damper on a great meal. Still the best view on the lake!
… more
Melissa Thomas
The view and outdoor seating was amazing…and the restaurant very nicely decorated inside. We were the only 3 customers in the entire restaurant, at 7:30. There were 3 servers in view and it took forever for us to get a server and we waited even longer for the drinks. We were the only people in there! Food came out relatively fast and was good. Drink refills during dinner were ridiculously slow again . I’d hate to be here if there were TWO tables to wait on AT ONCE!!
… more
Melanie Gray
Prettiest spot on the lake. Great bar both inside and out. Sand beach for kids to play on, pool, great docking for boats. Our meal was wonderful. We had fish fry, great service, great food. This place has struggled with food service in the past but they have it figured out now so don’t let the negative reviews scare you.
… more
Ashley Gehrke
New chef and awesome food! David is a fantastic bartender and there is also a new bartender for the summer and he makes an awesome mojito as well as other specialty drinks.

I highly recommend the homemade meatball appetizer and/or sub, the CUBAN sandwich is the best I’ve ever had and all of our party agreed. The Philly is also so delicious….don’t forget to order the amazing truffle fries.

This place has had incredible improvements and we’ve been back several times this summer. We have always loved the bands on the weekends but some great things are happening here!
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment