Fred Penix
In the area doing some emergency electrical work and called upon Pops two days in a row. Great both times. Pizza and subs last night, which was on point. Good crust with just the right crunch and pepperoni with the perfect amount of curl. Ital sub for lunch today. No complaints from this crew! If we’re ever in the area again, we will be calling Pops pizza again. Thanks to the ladies there for doing what they do!
… moreKyle Douglas
Best pizza I have had in a very long time. Keep up the good work. Awesome friendly staff.
… moreNoah Dunn
A Pizza shop in the middle of nowhere has no right being this good.
I ordered a large Taco Pizza and it was phenomenal. My buddy and I took down the whole thing. I hope I get the chance to stop and eat here again.
… moreTasha Kenerly
Pop’s Pizza has the best Chicken,Bacon Ranch Pizza that I’ve ever tried. I used to work near this establishment but since retiring I still go back for this amazing Pizza. If you are in the area it’s a must try you won’t be disappointed.
… morewally brown
Home town pizza place that supports baseball for the community. It is dated however perfect for stepping back into hot food, great service with a smile.
… moreJenifer Somerlot
Pop’s Pizza Parlor is the definition of small-town pizza done right! Their Southwest Chicken pizza is absolutely amazing—loaded with flavor and just the right amount of kick. It’s my go-to every time! Whenever I have out of town buyer’s looking in the area, I always recommend they try this spot out for a quick meal.
… moreEdmund Gregory
Used to order pizzas here years ago while working at Honda ELP, went inside for the first time and the restaurant was very dated and dirty.
The subs looked good, but unfortunately, both my coworker & I felt sick the rest of the day after eating.
… moreGabriel S.
Honestly the best pizza I have ever had! The Sub Pizza is legendary but there is nothing wrong with anything I have tried there. I live near Columbus and sometimes it is worth the drive to East Liberty. The staff are always great and I wish they would expand and have more locations.
… moreHolly R. Miller
Best pizza there is! Always hot & fresh. I love their crust. It’s a pan crust but it’s not too thin. The sauce is great. Just everything about it is wonderful. I live in Florida & whenever I come to Bellefontaine to visit my parents, I always want Pop’s Pizza to complete my trip!
… moreDana Lewis
Really wanted this to be a good place due to not wanting to run into town and support local business. But pizza had no taste with little toppings. Chefs salad had a tiny bit of ham and no other meat. Garlic cheese bread was burnt and hard. The cut back on ingredients was not shown in the price. I paid $31 to be disappointed. I love my pizza and you can always tell the owners love of pizza in the quality. To be honest store bought would have been better.
… more