Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Old-fashioned counter serve burger joint with ice cream, sundaes, malts & a homespun vibe.
Address and Contact Information
Address: N87W16459 Appleton Ave, Menomonee Falls, WI 53051
Phone: (262) 251-3320
Website: https://www.popscustard.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pop’s Custard: HOME
Pop’s Frozen Custard is a family-owned frozen custard and burger staple of Menomonee Falls, WI. Our menu features a wide variety of delectable treats.
Pop’s Custard | Menomonee Falls WI – Facebook
Drum on down to Pop’s for the last flavor of the day! Vanilla custard with chocolate drizzle, peanuts and waffle cone pieces makes one of our classic flavors …
After 45 years, Pop’s Custard in Menomonee Falls is closing Aug. 31
After 45 years in business, Pop’s Custard in Menomonee Falls will close Aug. 31. Portrait of Cathy Kozlowicz Cathy Kozlowicz. Milwaukee Journal …
Reviews
David Sparks
We were in the area and a hot and humid day DEFINITELY called for custard! Since we have not tried this location, it was an easy decision. While walking in, someone was carrying out onion rings – that made it onto my order because they looked great! The onion rings and curds were very good. The huge selection of custard was difficult to decide but we were able to finally narrow down our choices. The root beer float custard and cotton candy blend were good choices! The workers were very friendly even though it was very hot and they were pretty steady with customers. This place is worth a stop, and then go back again! Love the look of the place also.
… moreMatthew Wawa
I’ve been going to pops with my family since i was a child, the place is only getting better.
The potential to dominate your younger sibling at TicTacToe at the table before your food is ready. Then to get served some of the BEST burgers, malts and sodas in the wisconsin area. We ordered the butter burger and a side of cheese curds, both being incredibly tasty and probably one of my top 5 places for cheese curds after this visit. Along with this the strawberry malt hit the spot, and the coke was unironically the best i’ve ever had. No idea what they have going on with that soda machine but it was delicious. All in all pops is what i remembered as a kid- great food and atmosphere.
Please go by pops and support this staple, phenomenal food for literally years.
… moreThe potential to dominate your younger sibling at TicTacToe at the table before your food is ready. Then to get served some of the BEST burgers, malts and sodas in the wisconsin area. We ordered the butter burger and a side of cheese curds, both being incredibly tasty and probably one of my top 5 places for cheese curds after this visit. Along with this the strawberry malt hit the spot, and the coke was unironically the best i’ve ever had. No idea what they have going on with that soda machine but it was delicious. All in all pops is what i remembered as a kid- great food and atmosphere.
Please go by pops and support this staple, phenomenal food for literally years.
Gordon Duer
I HAD THE ANGUS 1/3 IB BURGER WITH CHEESE ketchup mayo fried onions pickles. The food was hot and freshly made. The fries were coated with light batter. The food was delicious. Their staff were friendly and professional. They have a very large food and custard selection. Will definitely go there again. The restaurant was clean, the decor was unique. I give it a check it out if in the area. So much better than Wendy’s, Burger King or McDonald’s
… moreBill Old
The best tasting burger of my holiday. Fries were great too. Delicious hot food and wonderful sundaes for desert. Not the biggest of places, but delicious food for its type….
… moreBryDeV
Small but super cute burger & custard joint. Custard window is great for a quick stop. We had the mushroom Swiss jumbo burger, a black angus cheeseburger, and a patty melt. All were great.
… moreCharlie White
We had some of the creamiest, most wonderful custard we’ve ever tasted here. My stepson had the vanilla, which was completely free of ice crystals and absolutely smooth and dense.
I had a special flavor of the day called “French Silk,” and it was a rich chocolate confection with dark chocolate pieces in it. It was simply exquisite.
We’ve always liked this place, but I think it’s even better now than it was years ago.
In addition, the staff was exceptionally friendly and helpful, and made us feel welcome. Overall, it was a perfect frozen custard experience, Wisconsin style!
… moreI had a special flavor of the day called “French Silk,” and it was a rich chocolate confection with dark chocolate pieces in it. It was simply exquisite.
We’ve always liked this place, but I think it’s even better now than it was years ago.
In addition, the staff was exceptionally friendly and helpful, and made us feel welcome. Overall, it was a perfect frozen custard experience, Wisconsin style!
Teri T
The ladies inside were very friendly & I got a strawberry shake that is really good. Today was my first time trying this place and I mostly likely won’t return. My first sandwich was missing items and then the second one my burger is raw. I got back late from lunch and still had nothing to eat. Very disappointed.
… moreKarl Schroepfer
This place is very popular so be prepared to wait. This is one of those times where the wait is absolutely worth it. Using grilled cheese sandwiches instead of bread is a pretty crazy idea for a patty melt, but it was delicious. Don’t tell my trainer. Get yourself a burger while you still can!
… moreNada View
Love this gem my #jbabe took us too!! Babe said they have been around for a long time and I’m sure I know why?!! The place itself is very welcoming and cozy. The staff and service was perfect, and the custard was on point!! We have yet to try the all American food so that will definitely be our next visit. So far the BEST custard I’ve ever had!!! Way to end our Sunday Funday!!! Thanks guys!!
… moreDiamante Lara
Looking for a sweet frozen treat that will keep you cool during the hot summer months? Look no further than Pop’s Frozen Custard! This local custard shop offers a wide array of delicious flavors that will satisfy any sweet tooth.
From classic vanilla and chocolate to seasonal favorites like pumpkin and peppermint, Pop’s Frozen Custard has something for everyone.
But it’s not just the variety of flavors that makes Pop’s Frozen Custard a standout. The quality of the custard is truly exceptional – creamy, rich, and perfectly textured. This is a testament to the fact that all of their custard is made fresh on site, using only the finest ingredients.
And if you’re in the mood for something a bit more indulgent, be sure to check out Pop’s selection of toppings and mix-ins. Whether you prefer candy, nuts, or fresh fruit, there’s something for everyone here.
One thing that really sets Pop’s Frozen Custard apart is the friendly and welcoming staff. From the moment you walk in the door, you’re greeted with a smile and helpful advice on the best flavors and toppings to try. This makes every trip to Pop’s feel like a special occasion.
The only reason I’m not giving Pop’s Frozen Custard a five-star review is because, at times, the lines can get quite long during peak hours. But even then, the wait is always worth it for the delicious, high-quality custard that awaits.
Overall, if you’re looking for a sweet and satisfying treat in town, Pop’s Frozen Custard should definitely be at the top of your list. With delicious flavors, high-quality ingredients, and a friendly staff, it’s no wonder that this place is a local favorite. Check it out today!
Facebook: diamante/lara/realtor
️ Community Member & Real Estate Services
Buy / Sell / Invest
… moreFrom classic vanilla and chocolate to seasonal favorites like pumpkin and peppermint, Pop’s Frozen Custard has something for everyone.
But it’s not just the variety of flavors that makes Pop’s Frozen Custard a standout. The quality of the custard is truly exceptional – creamy, rich, and perfectly textured. This is a testament to the fact that all of their custard is made fresh on site, using only the finest ingredients.
And if you’re in the mood for something a bit more indulgent, be sure to check out Pop’s selection of toppings and mix-ins. Whether you prefer candy, nuts, or fresh fruit, there’s something for everyone here.
One thing that really sets Pop’s Frozen Custard apart is the friendly and welcoming staff. From the moment you walk in the door, you’re greeted with a smile and helpful advice on the best flavors and toppings to try. This makes every trip to Pop’s feel like a special occasion.
The only reason I’m not giving Pop’s Frozen Custard a five-star review is because, at times, the lines can get quite long during peak hours. But even then, the wait is always worth it for the delicious, high-quality custard that awaits.
Overall, if you’re looking for a sweet and satisfying treat in town, Pop’s Frozen Custard should definitely be at the top of your list. With delicious flavors, high-quality ingredients, and a friendly staff, it’s no wonder that this place is a local favorite. Check it out today!
Facebook: diamante/lara/realtor
️ Community Member & Real Estate Services
Buy / Sell / Invest