Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 678 Stewart Ave, Garden City, NY 11530
Phone: (516) 962-2251
Website: https://www.pizzasuprememenu.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Pizza Supreme – Garden City, NY – 678 Stewart Ave – Hours, Menu …
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-8:45 PM; Shop address is 678 Stewart Ave, Garden City, NY 11530678 Stewart Ave, Garden City, NY 11530; (516) 228-4300.
Pizza Supreme
Pizza Supreme – the taste that has been bringing Long Island back for over 50 years! 678 Stewart Avenue, Garden City, NY 11530. Contact Pizza Supreme! (516) …
Pizza Supreme – 678 Stewart Ave, Garden City, NY 11530 – Slice
Buffalo chicken and mozzarella cheese. $7.00. $6.65. Chicken & Broccoli Pizza Slice. Chicken, broccoli, tomato sauce and mozzarella.
Reviews
Luv4Polish&Books
I now live in NC , and WISH they shipped to other States, we don’t get to NY often but when we do or my Son goes in the Summer it is a MUST to bring a Square Pie Home! Though he was to late this Past September ):
I used to live down the Hall from the Owners or Old Owners in the 80’s and always loved going in there. We’d been going there since they were in Roosevelt Field. We’ve been in NC 10yrs now and the ONLY thing I miss about LI is Pizza Supreme!
… moreI used to live down the Hall from the Owners or Old Owners in the 80’s and always loved going in there. We’d been going there since they were in Roosevelt Field. We’ve been in NC 10yrs now and the ONLY thing I miss about LI is Pizza Supreme!
Shomik Das
It’s an old timey pizza joint that has a decent enough pepperoni slice. The service is prompt and friendly. It’s not a bad choice if it’s the only option in the area. The crust is crunchy enough and the toppings are okay. Granted things are pricey now, but I do expect more even from a humble slice. Hopefully next time is better
… moreDaniel Pino
Pizza Supreme
Est. 1958
Layout/atmosphere
*12 tables; TV; parking lot
Food/drink
*Square slice – solid; thin crust
*Buffalo chicken slice – fine; late heat from seasoning on chicken; fragmented crust underneath
… moreEst. 1958
Layout/atmosphere
*12 tables; TV; parking lot
Food/drink
*Square slice – solid; thin crust
*Buffalo chicken slice – fine; late heat from seasoning on chicken; fragmented crust underneath
Cesar Alvarez
I had a disappointing experience at this place due to its lack of cleanliness. During my visit, I ordered some pepperoni slices, and I noticed The staff member who had just handled money proceeded to grab the pizza toppings with his bare hands. He dug into the bucket of pepperoni without wearing any gloves, highly unsanitary. This lack of basic food safety practices is alarming and discouraging.
… moreCourtney Gentry
Usually I love this place, like order 2ishx a week love. but the last few times I’ve ordered delivery the pizza has looked like this. The driver doesn’t bring change when paying cash and this happens often… I’ve called a few times and have been told the owner or manager will call me but never does.
… moreMaison Reese
Didn’t get greeted when walking in. Snatched money out of my hand and didn’t say a single word to us. An old white lady walked in and their moods immediately changed. Pizza is mid, service sucked, and vibes were completely off. Will absolutely never return.
… moreJoseph Lanzarotta
Definitely one of the better Sicilian slices I’ve had especially out on Long Island lots of sauce good amount of cheese nice crisp on the pie came fresh out of the oven definitely will be back for this Sicilian great spot great sauce!
… moreK L
Great square slices. Always fresh. Garlic knots are some of the best I have ever had. Can eat just the knots with a side of sauce as a meal. Covered in oil, garlic and spices will have you wanting more. Great staff and great service.
… moreDan Tyler
We got a supreme pizza from Pizza Supreme and it wasn’t your average supreme. It was WAYY above average, with slices soo big and toppings piled high. Their wings are also top notch! Ordered for delivery, they were super fast!
… moreArely
Called ahead to order a grandma slice. After the left the store, I saw that it was a small size corner slice basically toast bread. This should’ve been half the price not the full price of a grandma slice.
It was already too late to go back and let them know to give me a different slice or a refund.
… moreIt was already too late to go back and let them know to give me a different slice or a refund.