Nick Huffman
We tried Pizza Paradise for the first time this evening and we’ll definitely be ordering again! The Island Classic and garlic knots were both really good…I’d suggest 2 orders of the garlic knots if you plan on sharing. The pizza was damn good and I REALLY liked the thicker crust which was still super crispy, sauce was on the sweeter side and really good as well. The staff were friendly both on the phone and in person. Highly recommend checking this place out!
… moreMadison Eggleston
We just tried Pizza Paradise for the first time this past Friday for our family dinner! It was so yummy! We had three different pizzas and the garlic knots! All very good. I ordered online easily, and it was ready for pick-up at my selected time! We are happy to have another pizza option in Logan, especially a family-owned small business to support!
… moreCharlene Wood
I got their newest pizza and it’s delicious. Loaded with toppings and the sauce is the best
… moreSamantha Stickle
We drove past this place the other day and noticed it was new, decided to give it a try. We’re so glad we did! We ordered the pesto pizza and it was amazing! The garlic knots.. *chefs kiss* so good. Its stone oven pizza and the crust is so good and crunchy. They make all their own stuff including pesto and sauce which both are 10/10. Definitely a more upscale pizza feel that I think we needed around town. Sauce is a little more on the sweeter side which I personally love. I had a few minutes to talk to the owners to while I waited and they were so nice! Can’t wait to try their other stuff and tell our friends about them. So happy we found this place.
… moreCynthia Barnes
Went in and ordered and everyone working there was so kind and helpful!! Everything looked well maintained and like a good environment to be in. AND THEN on top of everything.. the pizza tastes amazing and definitely will be getting again! 10/10
… moreAura Miftari
I usually never write reviews, but this one is different, simply because I think you guys are losing a good opportunity out there. Unable to reach the owner or someone in charge at the shop, I hope one of you sees this and replies to this review. I was the person that called a couple minutes ago at the restaurant and got hung up on because I was trying to get ahold of the owner, as much as I understand how hard it is for you and absolutely love the pizza community, I would want to get in touch with an owner of this location to discuss some things.
… moreTom Sunderlin
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5/5 – Absolutely Incredible Pizza!
Pizza Paradise completely blew us away. The pizza was absolutely amazing from the very first bite. The crust had the perfect balance of doughy softness, satisfying crunch, and a unique flavor that truly stood out. The sauce was spot on with rich, flavorful, and perfectly portioned in relation to the toppings. The cheese was excellent as well: high-quality, delicious, and refreshingly not greasy.
What impressed me most was the quality of the ingredients. Everything tasted premium, fresh, and thoughtfully sourced. And the best part? After eating, the pizza didn’t sit heavily on my stomach. I felt great, which is something you can’t say about most pizzas these days, including other local pizzas in the area.
Knowing they use NO seed oils and prioritize clean, high-quality ingredients seals the deal. This is exactly how pizza should be made.
Overall: This is now our go-to pizza spot. Highly recommend!
… moreKevin Fuller
Really good pizza. Sauce was my favorite part. Very clean inside. When I ordered they said 20 minutes. Showed up in 20 minutes and they were cutting pizza and putting it in a box just the way I like it hot and fresh. Definitely will be back. Thanks!!
… moreJesse
There are many pizza options in our little town and I love pizza, so naturally I was excited for a new place. Tonight was our first experience and we ordered the Pesto Paradiso. It was great! The sauce was a little sweet which I love, the crust had some crunch but wasn’t tough, and the ingredients seemed to be good quality. We’ll definitely order again ☺️ Our only suggestion would be a more equal distribution of the toppings and a little more balsamic vinaigrette, but even as is we’d order again. Pizza was done in the time frame that was given, easy in and out. Good job! Thank you for being a great addition to our community!
… moreJojo
Really good pizza and garlic knots! For me, it was a perfect pizza. They didn’t overwhelm it with sauce and it had the little bucket pepperonis! I will definitely be ordering again!
… more