Andria Grillo
Was really excited about trying this place. Saw a bunch of stuff on TikTok and it looked amazing. Ordered a white pizza, an extra cheese pizza & garlic knor. The white pizza had an ungodly amount of oregano or some type of seasoning. Almost made it inedible. The garlic knots were basically just lumps of bread with barely any garlic/oil. The marinara on the side was disgusting. The cheese pizza was OK. But pretty mediocre. I’m so disappointed because it looked so good on TikTok Definitely not worth the $60. Won’t be back.
… moreKendall Eva
Thank god this was an hour drive for me, I fear if it were any closer I’d be eat pizza here 24/7. The Pesto Roni was hands DOWN the best pizza I’ve ever had and their homemade ranch was tear worthy it was so good. My only regret is not getting a gallon to go lol
… moreSahil Parikh
You might think a pizza shop located inside a gas station is a red flag, but you’d be sorely mistaken to overlook this spot. Having lived in this area for over 30 years, this is one of the best pizza shops in the area if you’re looking for thin and chewy style pizza. They use fresh ingredients, and have great sides (mozzarella moons and garlic bites are awesome). Keep in mind that it’s primarily a counter shop, it’s not a dine-in spot.
… moreNoah Hein
Run do not walk to Pizza Lisa! I heard nothing but positive things about this place and seeing the pictures I had to try it myself! I cannot explain how good this place is! I got the PB and J boneless wings which were fire, they also make most sauces in house including their ranch which is next level. And I got the Spicy Pig pizza which was also NEXT LEVEL! Can’t recommend this place enough. Also very friendly staff and customer service!
… moreBuby Dragon
Stopped for a Cheese and a Roni pizza. Mixed reviews within the family. I liked it, perfect sauce to cheese ratio. Kids thought it was “greasy” but i think it was just the oils from the Roni. Small cups, which i find are better.
Also got an order of boneless buffalo wings (tenders). Great portion. Normally i do not like the smell of buffalo, these were different. They smelled good enough that i decided to try them. They were tasty.
This place is actually in a gas station so They seem to sell a lot of slices. Mo real seating so definitely a take out place. We will come back
… moreShelby Jacquelyn
Got Pizza Lisa as a large group order with my coworkers who were raving about all the TikTok reviews of this place. I got the Meatball pizza. Not sure what the hype is all about as it’s mid at best, it didn’t change my whole world nor would I go out of my way to get it when there are other pizzerias in Windham I like so much more. I prefer Dominoes if I’m being honest. Many mixed reviews within my group, some who enjoyed it and others who feel just like me.
… moreAnnabelle Gregory
Got the Nashville Hot Chicken Pie and the PestoRoni Pie – both were a 10/10 absolutely delectable!! Grabbed both the Ranch and Bleu Cheese, I’m a bleu cheese lover but OMG the ranch is to DIE FOR!! It’s my second time back and more to come new favorite pizza spot!
… moreJake Olson
Absolutely phenomenal pizza. I got the pesto roni. Even the crust tastes amazing
… moreArturo Ramírez
Fantastic place with friendly service. We visited this pizza spot for the first time last week and were pleasantly surprised by the quality of the food. The garlic knots were soft and fluffy, the pizza was made with fresh ingredients and perfectly baked dough, and the apple pie eggrolls were a delicious, unique treat. We also tried the cookies, and honestly, you can’t go wrong with any of the choices. We’ll definitely be coming back soon!
… morePete
Pizza Lisa has become one of our go-to takeout spots — every order is consistently delicious and a great value for the money. Their cheese pizza is classic and perfectly balanced with a crispy crust, rich sauce, and melty cheese that tastes fresh every time. The BBQ chicken pizza is just as incredible, loaded with flavor and tender chicken that makes it hard to order just one. Even as takeout, everything arrives hot, fresh, and full of that homemade quality you can taste. For the price and quality, Pizza Lisa is easily one of the best pizza places around!
… more