4.5 – 1,691 reviews • Pizza restaurant
Social Profile: 
Craving authentic pizza in Buckeye Lake, OH? Pizza Cottage has you covered! Our pizzeria makes each pizza with the freshest ingredients, guaranteeing a burst of flavor in every bite. Proudly serving the community, we’re not just about pizza; our menu also features an array of mouthwatering options, including hot subs, calzones, wings, and much more, perfect for any appetite. At our local pizzeria, every slice tells a story of tradition, quality, and the freshest, locally-sourced ingredients. At the heart of Pizza Cottage is our exceptional team. More than just staff, they are the essence of our establishment – friendly, passionate about food, and always eager to make your dining experience extraordinary. Call our local pizzeria today!
Local chain serving a menu of pizza, calzones, subs & wings in a casual setting.
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
Hours
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
pizza-cottage.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizza Cottage
Pizza Cottage is a collection of 10 Pizza Cottage restaurants located across Ohio owned by Lancaster entrepreneur Larry E. Tipton. Founded in 1972 by Jack and …
Locations – Pizza Cottage
Pizza Cottage is a collection of 10 Pizza Cottage restaurants located across Ohio owned by Lancaster entrepreneur Larry E. Tipton. Founded in 1972 by Jack and …
Pizza Cottage Buckeye Lake – Facebook
Pizza Cottage Buckeye Lake, Buckeye Lake. 4594 likes · 53 talking about … 4592 Walnut Road SE, Buckeye Lake, OH, United States, 43008. Links. . pizza …
Reviews
David Criss
Did I count 5 pizza delivery vehicles in the parking lot? Must be good! And it was. Seemed reasonable priced, tasted great, clean bathrooms. Plenty of parking. No view of Buckeye Lake, and no brewed ice tea. We will go back.
… moreKayleigh Shay
My fiancé and I stopped into Pizza Cottage on our way to visit my parents in Cincinnati from Charleston, SC, and it was truly some of the best pizza we’ve ever had. We unfortunately forgot our server’s name and are so sorry for that, but she mentioned she was getting off at 4 PM today and was wearing a silver bracelet—hopefully that helps identify her! She was absolutely amazing—attentive, friendly, and such a great conversationalist. Please let her know she did a fantastic job! We’ll definitely be stopping in again.
… moreNORTHBROOK1978
Was in the area . Took our niece to the Arboretum. The crust is super thin and crispy. Fresh toppings. Definitely recommend stopping in here. Nice covered outdoor seating. And the deepfried pepperoni chips are a must. Simple but really tasty…
… moreRob Asher
Love pizza places with arcades from my youth. This location in buckeye lake is far better than Circleville. White pizza was the favorite over Sicilian extra cheese pie. Red sauce is a little sweet for me. Good choice for buckeye lake.
… moreAdam W Nelson
Great place to take the friends and family. Super clean inside and the staff is really nice. Also the food is awesome! I love pizza Cottage and I will definitely go back. They also had karaoke going on outside on Friday night. You’re looking for more information on that I would call first.
… moreJohn Mcdaniel
We love their pizza, one of the best around the lake. For some reason today’s pizza was just slightly more salty than normal. May have gotten the bottom of the barrel sauce, I guess. If you want good pizza this is the place to go. We still enjoyed our pizzas, just something we noticed.
… moreDaniel Thomas
Nothing but rude customer service. The employee didn’t seem like they wanted to be friendly and give out snotty attitude. Why am I expected to tip in the drive thru???? All they did was hand me a pizza and you want a tip?!?! HA! Then when the cashier sees that they didn’t get a tip the service becomes horrible….. I can think of many other pizza spots around the lake that would have a better customer service experience!!!
… moreLeanna Shaw
This might be the first time I’ve ever had anything less than perfect to say regarding the food we received. The medium with mushroom was just WOW. There didn’t seem to have any cheese on it and it was hard to eat because it was over done.
… moreJack Holland
Food is good, staff are friendly. It’s your traditional pizza shop. I highly recommend them.
… moretom dusseau
Great pizza, Great service, Great experience! We will be back!
Cheese and pepperoni with extra cheese, garlic bread with cheese. These were great! Highly.
… more