Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Fine dining restaurant that serves prime rib every night! We also have a wide variety of seafood, steaks and combinations. We have a full bar with delicious old fashions. We are no longer accepting reservations but you can call ahead to notify us if you have a group of 8 or more so our staff can be better prepared.
Address and Contact Information
Address: E8095 WI-54, New London, WI 54961
Phone: (920) 982-5738
Website: https://www.pinetreesupperclub.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pine Tree Supper Club
Sundays: 3:30 pm – 8:00 pm. ADDRESS. E8095 HWY 54. New London, WI 54961. (920) 982-5738. FOLLOW. Black Facebook Icon · Black Twitter Icon. © 2026 Pine Tree …
Pine Tree Supper Club | New London WI – Facebook
Pine Tree Supper Club. Where you will find the best prime rib and old fashions in Wisconsin! Steakhouse · $$ · (920) 982- …
Pine Tree Supper Club | Travel Wisconsin
Pine Tree Supper Club. Address. E8095 Hwy 54 – New London, WI 54961. Phone. 920-982-5738. Socials. View Website Share. About Pine Tree Supper Club. Full dining …
Reviews
J C
Pine Tree is KING! If you know,,you know! Fantastic prime rib, I’ve always wanted to try something else on the menu but I can’t pass up the chance on the prime rib. I’ve been here 5 times& it’s always great. They make a delicious old fashioned as well, get it with the mushrooms! My girlfriend got the prime rib quesadilla also fantastic
… moreLynette Arnhart
We went to Pine Tree to celebrate a birthday. The drinks and appetizers were outstanding. The prime rib was the last available piece (about 6:15 on Thursday). The fish was a bit tough with too much butter and too little wine. The decor is dated, but that might be intentional.
… moreD.W. Fox
Overall we had a really good night here. Had prime rib and these afoot platter. The prime rib was great. The seafood platter tasted good but the sauce was really heavy and pieces of fish (1) was really small. Shrimp were good. Drinks were great. You definitely get your monies worth on the drinks.
… moreNikki Rhodes
I got the ribeye with shrimp scampi. The shrimp scampi was amazing. The ribeye was so thin. It was like meant for a sandwich and for the price of $43 they made their money and I did not get a very nice meal. My husband, however, got the ribs and they were fall off the bone and wonderful. The drinks were great the service not once. Did they ask us how our food was not even when we paid for our dinner at the front desk. Unfortunately, there are so many good separate clubs we will not be returning to this one.
… morePennie K
We did ask if they had to go orders, and were told yes. Had the Homemade Alfredo with Chicen and my husband had a Cheese burger, we figured since this is supposed to be a Supperclub and we were unable to go inside that we’d order something simple.
It upsets me when I give a bad review and Don’t really do it…but considering what we paid I’m thinking I’m ok. The Alfredo was terrible..if it is actually Homemade Sauce it was terrible!! There was absolutely No taste to it. Very sticky and heavy sauce…totally flavorless. I had to add butter,garlic salt, and parmesan cheese to add flavor. The chicken looked very appetizing yet it was tough and rubbery. My husband’s Cheese burger was nothing special but his fries were good.
They charged for anything extra i.e onions tomato. Overall I can honestly say We will not be recommending or returning. We paid close to 50$ for food that went in trash.
… moreIt upsets me when I give a bad review and Don’t really do it…but considering what we paid I’m thinking I’m ok. The Alfredo was terrible..if it is actually Homemade Sauce it was terrible!! There was absolutely No taste to it. Very sticky and heavy sauce…totally flavorless. I had to add butter,garlic salt, and parmesan cheese to add flavor. The chicken looked very appetizing yet it was tough and rubbery. My husband’s Cheese burger was nothing special but his fries were good.
They charged for anything extra i.e onions tomato. Overall I can honestly say We will not be recommending or returning. We paid close to 50$ for food that went in trash.
alanna yarbro
Awesome supper club! Brandy old fashioned are good. I have been here two times and the food was great each time. The serving sizes are good portions. Last time I had the breaded shrimp, which were cooked to perfection and were huge in size. The first time I had the prime rib and was not disappointed in any way. Service is friendly and the atmosphere is very home like. Definitely will be going back.
… moreMarty Ric
Food is the best! Staff were very friendly. Was a bit confusing as u are seated 1st, get drinks and order in the bar… to crowded to get to the bar again for a second drink while we waited, then are told when table was ready… 70’s style decor, but not there for fancy tables. Will definitely go again as the food was perfect! Steak and prime rib sandwich, both worth the drive.
… moreRandy Thompson
We went for primerib and was not disappointed. It was very tender and tasted great along with the au jus. Shrimp was great as well, just enough spice but not too overwhelming. We were extremely disappointed however on how long it took to get seated. We waited an hour and 45 minutes after our 7 o’clock reservation for 3 people. Luckily, we found some friends at the bar. When asking the hostess about our table, she indicated several times once the tables are available they would seat us, and the meal would be out shortly after. Several times I visited the dining room to see 5 tables open in the back room but still not seated. We were starving by this time, so once we were seated it seemed to have taken another 20 minutes to get the food. I just thought by having staff take your order prior to seating things would have moved faster, but an entire hour went by. Perhaps we just hit the busiest night or they were short staffed. The food though was delicious, just be prepared to wait.
… moreStephenie Smith
This is an excellent point of interest. Supper clubs of Wisconsin need to hit on so many points to be considered an optimal place. Pine tree hits on all points. Old fashioned’s, martinis a relish try, the prime rib options work great for those that can only eat a small cut. You can also get a massive cut. Brandy Alexander , grasshoppers and pink squirrels are sure to wow you. My daughters are over 10 so they split an order of chicken Alfredo which was finish all the way.
Only only down side was the music was a bit loud in the bar area but not awful.
My best advice as they are very busy. Make a reservation. You won’t be sorry trying this place.
… moreOnly only down side was the music was a bit loud in the bar area but not awful.
My best advice as they are very busy. Make a reservation. You won’t be sorry trying this place.
Jennifer Wright
The food was delicious. I thoroughly enjoyed the Pecan Salmon and will be back for it again. The old fashioned were good. Our waitress was great.
… more