Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
At Pie in the Sky we are believers in tradition and we build our pizzas with that in mind. Each of our pizzas is made to order to suit your individual taste. We begin with a hand stretched pizza dough, made with 100% virgin olive oil, then topped with our own sauce and a delectable mix of toppings using only fresh produce, top grade 100% beef and pork products and Vermont’s finest 100% Mozzarella cheese. The pizza is then transferred to a stone hearth to bake to a desired crispness.
Laid-back spot serving up casual Italian grub from whole pizzas & slices to hot & cold subs.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 240 Highgate Cmns Rd, St Albans City, VT 05478
Phone: (802) 524-5442
Website: https://www.pieintheskyvermont.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pie in the Sky • Locally Owned Pizza Restaurant
Pie in the Sky Pizzeria and Delicatessen is a favorite pizza restaurant of locals in Saint Albans, VT. Menu featuring Stone Hearth Pizza.
Pie In The Sky | Saint Albans VT – Facebook
Pie In The Sky, Saint Albans. 6174 likes · 14 talking about this · 5067 were here. Pizza place.
Restaurant Menu • Pie in the Sky, Pizza and Subs in St. Albans, VT
Mixed greens and garden veggies, topped with fresh mushrooms, black olives and mozzarella cheese. Served with your choice of Italian, Ranch, Oil & Vinegar, Fat …
Reviews
Margi Sigler
Love Pie in the Sky! Always fresh and delicious. Wish I could eat there every day. The calzones are incredible- and they’re mega-sized. So, so good. The best I’ve ever had.
… moreZach Benedicto
One of the best place to get pizza in Saint Albans! Went during lunch time. It was pretty busy but it only took couple minutes for us to get seated. We had the large pineapple passion pizza ($24.99). It was good and fresh! Soda was actually good and not flat. Our server was nice and attentive. Nice atmosphere with good choice of music. It’s a busy place for sure!
… moreEric Hunt-Schroeder
Pizza has been perfect every time that we’ve visited.
Recently visited in January 2026 and brought my parents to try. We got the pepperoni pizza for my kids and the Cuban pizza for us. The waiter was very friendly and checked in regularly.
We really enjoy coming here for food as we pass through saint albans. If you haven’t been, we highly recommend it!
… moreRecently visited in January 2026 and brought my parents to try. We got the pepperoni pizza for my kids and the Cuban pizza for us. The waiter was very friendly and checked in regularly.
We really enjoy coming here for food as we pass through saint albans. If you haven’t been, we highly recommend it!
J Ro
Pretty awesome place. We stopped in on a business trip. I wasn’t a super fan of the pizza sauce (reminded me of spaghetti sauce) but it was still pretty good. Super friendly staff. I cant wait to try other items on the menu.
… morejoseph wells
I know Dennis appreciates feedback so I only post this with the hopes it gets resolved. We have visited the restaurant many times over the years and the order we received was the worst I’ve ever had. I ordered a meatball bowl three meatballs with onions and peppers and cheese . The food was lukewarm warm at best very few vegetables a few pieces of cheese on top and the sauce was lukewarm warm and only came up to half of the meatballs. Three pieces of cold garlic bread.
… moreNaomi Rose
This place almost feels like home. As a local born and raised, this is a hot spot for any occasion. Everyone knows pie in the sky and their dedication to greattttttt pizza. But don’t let that stop you from trying their calzones, subs, and salads. Everything is a great option and it’s always a tough choice.
… moreLogan Sylvester
Ordered two pizzas got there and they had made one entirely wrong after being explicitly told i do not want a white sauce pizza and then they remade the pizza at zero cost but couldnt bother to make the pizza correctly again and put the topping i paid for on. Seriously disappointing because this is one of my favorite pizza spots in the area. Manager seemed annoyed when she asked me if i wanted my 75cents back that was the price difference and i said no I’d just like to get out of here at this point. Pretty shitty experience honestly. Glad i paid 60 bucks and tipped on the wrong order twice.
… moreGreg Sullivan
Hate to say it, but THE BEST Philly Cheesesteak is NOT in in Philadelphia, it’s here!! Great pizza, and calzone. The food here is worth the trip from Phoenix!!
… moreIlya B
Got a cheese steak and a Hawaiian pizza. The cheese steak is the best in the surrounding area. Great flavor and very fresh roll. Pizza is great as well, light and not greasy. Is now my go to place for a cheese steak in this area.
… moreAlex Jemetz
Pie in the Sky is our family favourite restaurant for pizza and other dishes, generous salads and delicious sandwiches. Tasty Vermont draft beers on tap and the service is very fast and attentive.
… more