Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Pie Boy Pizza is a pop-up at Baby’s Bagels from the Baby’s crew. Just like our bagels, we put a Utah twist on a classic east coast staple—the neighborhood pizza shop. The menu is simple: thin-crust New York–style pies, Caesar salad, cold beer, cocktails, and a wine. For dine-in, we do counter service with first-come, first-served seating. On the run? Pre-order on our website.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 204 E 500 S, Salt Lake City, UT 84111
Phone: (801) 613-0066
Website: https://pieboypizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Pie Boy Pizza
… Express Discover JCB. Baby’s Pizza logo. Select location. Find the nearest store. Pie Boy Pizza. 204 E 500 S. Salt Lake City, UT 84111. +100 miles. Store info.
Pie Boy (@pieboypizza) • Instagram photos and videos
Pieboy Pizza 204 E 500 S Salt Lake City, Utah 84111 (Hours on their account) #pizzareview #onebiteeveryoneknowstherules #pizzashop. Photo by Pie Boy …
Pie Boy Pizza, 204 E 500 S, Salt Lake City, UT 84111, US – MapQuest
Get more information for Pie Boy Pizza in Salt Lake City, UT. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Reviews
Mike Martin
Pizza was great (I think).. I get that the push from Barstool probably blew them up beyond what they can handle, but I was able to order Friday morning for a 5pm pickup. Got there just after 5pm and then waited in line for 20+ mins to get our to-go order pizza that was finished at 4:50pm, so when we got home, it was cold.
I know pizza enough to know that it was a good pie, but it sucked eating it cold. The Secret Pizza Club pizza was at least piping hot when we got it (and better), even though it is basically impossible to get now. I love that Salt Lake is finally trying to embrace good pizza, but try to figure out the logistics before you have Dave Portnoy pimp your spot. I still think Victor’s pizza is the best in the valley.
I tried the ranch, which was really good, but $2 for a small cup of ranch is kind of a slap in the face after you pay $28 for a pizza, but I guess that it Trump’s new America.
… moreI know pizza enough to know that it was a good pie, but it sucked eating it cold. The Secret Pizza Club pizza was at least piping hot when we got it (and better), even though it is basically impossible to get now. I love that Salt Lake is finally trying to embrace good pizza, but try to figure out the logistics before you have Dave Portnoy pimp your spot. I still think Victor’s pizza is the best in the valley.
I tried the ranch, which was really good, but $2 for a small cup of ranch is kind of a slap in the face after you pay $28 for a pizza, but I guess that it Trump’s new America.
Hannah Langley
First time trying Pie Boy and the pizza is so good it’s kind of ridiculous. The crust was perfect, the sauce was perfect, the cheese was perfect, and it wasn’t greasy. The homemade ranch really knocked it out of the park and is a must-get in my opinion. Ordered pickup for 5:30 and it was ready right on time, still hot and delicious by the time we brought it home. We’ll be ordering again and again!
… moreAmber Mitchell
Wow, just WOW. I found out about this place the day after trying Sam’s Secret Pizza Club for the first time and HAD to order to compare, let me tell you, Pie Boy totally one-upped Sam’s in flavor, crust chew, and texture. We had both pepperoni pizzas side by side reheated in the oven, no additions and Pie Boy almost made Sam’s taste… bland. Plus the ordering was SOOO much less complicated, no waiting for an email alert and them being out of stock before you can even add to cart. And DESSERT! Let me just say how EXCITED I was to get a little container of tiramisu. Just a couple cons, parking was bad, had to park in a paid spot and run a block while hoping I didnt get towed; while Sam’s had more than enough free spots. Also the interior was a little bit less nice. However, the pizza was so good I’m more than willing to kick my bf out of the car to grab the pie while I circle the block. It was THAT GOOD. 10/10 WILL be going again.
… moreAdam
Amazing pie, great flavor, good undercarriage, thin and crisp!!! It’s a small time shop doing way more business then they can handle. Amazing people!
… moreJenn Poole
Pizza was amazing, especially the crust! Best pizza in SLC!! Highly recommend!
… moreTaylor Anderson
This is the best pizza in SLC snd it’s not close. Typically I use the binary scale to keep life easier. 0’s and 1’s. It’s either on or off. That works for romantic partners and it works for pizza. This is clearly a 1 on the binary scale. But on the Google scale it’s a 5 and on a scale of 10 it’s probably a 9.6.
… moreSpencer Walker
I can’t emphasize how frustrating this place was to deal with. They don’t answer their phone, they don’t take online orders, there’s no parking for them, and from what I experienced, only a bunch of hipster Gen Z’s with morning better to do are willing to wait hours just to get their food and sit outside. 100% do not recommend. If you want authentic New York pizza, go to villagio.
… morecaroline vermilyea
They offer a simple menu, and they do it well! Warm, friendly, and delicious. Love the classic pizza joint ceaser, and appreciate the option for anchovies.
… moreShima Baughman
I love this pizza so much. Both cheese and pepperoni are the best NYC pizza in SLC. It’s also family friendly. Please open more nights a week
… moreAdrian Sellars
Favorite Pizza in SLC. It’s hard to find something like this in Utah and there aren’t too many places to get anything close to this. Some good wines available to compliment as well.
… more