Shana F
I’m sure that most people are tired of sifting through reviews, people who haven’t even gone here, or are just commenting on their funny/relatable advertisements.
Tell me about the FOOD, PEOPLE!!!
In short, excellent pizza (tried trio slice).
I live out East, we have plenty of pizza places, but I’ve heard great things about their specialty slices and their huge selections of them. I finally got here, and it was quite impressive! At least a couple dozen different kinds of crafted pizzas, for all kinds of tastes. The pesto/alla vodka trio slice was amazing! I loved it and the best part was there was plenty of pesto/vodka/sauce on it… no charring- perfectly cooked. I mean, I’m a pizza pain (extra sauce, searching the counter for what looks fresh and usually never go for heavy or chicken slices because they look either dry and overcooked or like they’ve been sitting all day- not here!) Holy cow, it all looks great! Judging by what I saw in person (plus laughed about at excellent advertising) and experienced, this place gets an A+ from me. Oh, and staff was very friendly, helpful, patient, and fast!
… moreScotty Hotty
Went in with my sister-in-law and mother-in-law after a busy day of shopping and we were amazed what a great selection they had of pizzas to choose from for our late lunch. The Man behind the counter was very friendly and helpful so we ordered our slices and also asked for a chicken Caesar pie to go. Place was clean and nice and we sat in a nice booth ate our slices then picked up our part to go and left. We were all surely come back as the food was very fresh and delicious. 5 Stars!!
… moreSandra Suttiratana
I have been here multiple times but I can never deviate from my usual order of the Sicilian pizza pie because it is SO GOOD. The portions are generous too! One Sicilian pie was enough for at least 3 people, and the price is reasonable ($28). The free bread basket was also delicious: my favorite is the garlic bread. The service was also very professional. The dining area is also huge. I cannot wait to come back!
… moreShane Rossi
Mike hot honey slice was so good. This place is a must go to if you’re close by. Went to the Massapequa location never went here. Tom Kelly you made a good choice
… moreKenny Cannon
My daughter and I love to go to different pizza places on Long Island to try them out. Phil’s was really good. The pizza very good and worth going in for. Not the best I’ve had but top 5. The chicken roll was not as good. The atmosphere is great. People are extremely friendly and welcoming.
… moresteven callado
So I purchased a full sized plain pie and it came out to $27(card)! For that price I’d expect either a huge pizza or it to be a really good pie. Now it wasn’t bad in any way but honestly just mid. The dough is more on the bready side if that’s what you like and the underside of the slices didn’t have that slight char that good NY slices have. The sauce had good flavor tho and the cheese was nice. Overall I just expected more with that price.
… morereynaldo ulloa
Phil’s Pizzeria is easily one of the best spots around. I stopped by and grabbed a regular slice—it was absolutely delicious! The cheese-to-sauce ratio was spot on, the flavors were great, and the crust had that perfect crunch you look for. I’d recommend everyone give this place a try.
The service was excellent, too. I was greeted with a big smile by the owner (not Phil!), which made the experience even better. I’ll definitely be back!
… moreBill wrinkle
The fig and burrata slice is amazing!! Team was great. I came in towards the end of the night and ordered some slices to go. Some guy name Phil helped me and was a really great guy. Would recommend and will be back.
… moreRobert Baker
This is the best of Long Island. The owner, Anthony, is one of the nicest and most genuine people I have ever met. Service is amazing. Staff is friendly and prompt. Food is fabulous. For the price, the portions are huge. I had the meatballs and peppers hero with parmigiana and vodka sauce. It tasted amazing. The atmosphere is relaxing and comfortable. Definitely worth returning to. Highly recommended.
… moreSonjay Joseph Fonn, DO
Visited because for some reason my algorithm sends me all his TikTok’s.
Decent pizza place. My Italian fiancé was disappointed because she got baked eggplant and a loaf of bread when she ordered an eggplant sandwich but ended up making her own sandwich. Could have been a miscommunication.
My italian hero sandwich was spot on.
Pasta with red sauce was tasteless. No amount of salt, Parmesan or chili flakes could resurrect that.
On the pricey side.
… more