Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Take out
… View more
Serving the Milwaukee metropolitan area for over 70 years. We specialize in Italian Breads, rolls, cookies and pastries. We no longer make our cakes in house. We recommend either Aggie’s Bakery or Scordato Bakery for any Cake needs. Due to staff shortages in all departments, please allow at least 48 hours in advance for larger orders. Visit our website for shipping options, we always ship priority mail but please keep in mind that with shortages in the shipping industry, packages may not arrive when expected(once we send the package it is out of our control).
Established resource for housemade breads, Italian pastries, specialty cookies & some deli meats.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1101 E Brady St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Phone: (414) 272-4623
Website: https://petersciortinosbakery.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Peter Sciortino Bakery
At Peter Sciortino Bakery, we make all of our products from scratch daily, using only the highest quality ingredients, to ensure that our customers receive the …
Peter Sciortino Bakery (@peter_sciortino_bakery) – Instagram
• • • • #avantimilwaukee #avantimke #milwaukee #italian #sicilian #petersciortinobakery #bakery #italiancookies #italianlegacy #bradystreet #414 #wisconsin …
Peter Sciortino Bakery | Milwaukee WI – Facebook
Hurry up and place your orders! Give us a call at (414)- 272-4623 or place it online! No photo description available. Bella …
Reviews
Melissa Christensen
One of the best Italian bakeries there is!! High-quality baked goods with fair prices and friendly service. The tiramisu was divine and the cookies are all tasty and fresh. Will visit here whenever we are in this part of Milwaukee!!
… moreLindsay Davenport
This place is truly special. I stopped in for the first time in 15 years and was warmly welcomed in by Shima, who was patient and gave excellent recommendations when asked. When I ordered two cannolis, she asked what topping I’d like the ends dipped in. Pistachio, chocolate, cherry or pecan. I couldn’t decide so I asked her to surprise me. She said “hmm.. Ah hah! I know what to do….” To my astoundment, when I got home, I noticed that she dipped every end of the cannolis into a different topping, allowing me to try all four. It absolutely made my day, maybe even my week as I keep smiling back on the memory. Acts of kindness like this are so special. I didn’t think to take a picture until after I started munching on the Pistachio end. What a sweet surprise and a sweet treat. Shima, you are wonderful! Thank you! Also, Vanilla coconut dips are my favorite cookie, and a close second is the chocolate dipped Amaretti.
… moreTE Gangnier
What an amazing neighborhood bakery. Bought a dozen donut items for a gift and some cookies to go. Ate a cinnamon bun (very large in size). The Italian cookies are out of the park ! They stopped to take care of the kids and were super nice.
Highly recommend!
… moreHighly recommend!
Scott W
Stopped in as part of a Brady Street Food Tour. Have had their bakery before, and has always been good. Love to look at all the amazing and delicious cookies. The Cannolis were very VERY good.
… moreGregory Melanson
Peter Sciortino Bakery is an amazing business and located on Brady Street! This bakery has fun and flavorful baked goods and sweets, and this is a ‘must stop’ on your morning routine [cup of coffee in hand] to work. Complimented by great customer service and great prices, Peter Sciortino Bakery is a great place to shop, and the positive experience makes every aspect of your Brady Street visit so much better!
… moreXO XO
We really enjoyed the super cute and delicious Christmas Cookies!! ☃️
… moreRyan Neumann
We ordered a large platter of Italian cookies for our wedding.
The presentation was amazing, and the cookies were delicious. All the guests raved about them – including my 100% Italian mother.
We highly recommend Sciortino’s!
… moreThe presentation was amazing, and the cookies were delicious. All the guests raved about them – including my 100% Italian mother.
We highly recommend Sciortino’s!
Claddagh 9
We were visiting from St. Louis and were told that Brady Street featured a lot of ethnic shops/food and we came upon this bakery. SO many choices; everything looked delicious and was presented so nicely. My friend got a rainbow cookie and I got a lemon cookie dusted with powdered sugar. SO good! We came back a little bit later and got two more rainbow cookies. It reminded me of the cookies my great aunt from Palermo made when we were kids.
… moreJessica Goldstein
The moment you walk in, the display cases are absolutely stunning — rows of pastries and cookies that make you want to try every single one. They even had unique cookies I’d never seen before but instantly wanted to taste. It’s definitely the kind of bakery you’ll want to come back to again and again just to sample something new each time. We tried a mini cannoli with cream and cherries, and I’ve honestly never had a cannoli like that before — it was one of the best I’ve ever tasted. A true gem!
… moreTammy “Lil’ Marzipan” B
The almond croissant was good, but the nutella croissant is absolutely delicious!!! Of course the cookies were fantastic, as always.
… more