Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Quirky waterfront choice serving hot beverages, wine, beer, cider & light meals.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 131 Parfitt Way SW, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110
Phone: (206) 317-6914
Website: https://pegasuscoffee.com/original-pegasus-coffee-house-bainbridge/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bainbridge Coffee House – Pegasus Coffee
Built in 1937, our landmark building was originally home to the Anderson Hardware store and was built by their staff, utilizing bricks salvaged from the old …
Pegasus Coffee
The Pegasus Coffee House on Bainbridge Island has a fascinating history. Originally built as a hardware store in 1937, it later served as a registration center …
Home | Pegasus Coffee House – Online Orders
Order specialty coffees, teas, meals & pastries right now for quick pickup from the Pegasus Coffee House on Bainbridge Island, WA.
Reviews
Brittany
A cute little coffee shop off the main strip. Pegasus is clearly a local favorite by how busy it was midday on a Thursday!
I could see them getting so busy the line would snake out the door, so we were lucky to sneak in before the crowd and order one of their specialty drinks, a cardamom latte!
The drink tasted authentic, not using artificial syrups or sugar. We would have loved to stay and enjoy the cozy ambiance, but we had more of the island to explore.
… moreI could see them getting so busy the line would snake out the door, so we were lucky to sneak in before the crowd and order one of their specialty drinks, a cardamom latte!
The drink tasted authentic, not using artificial syrups or sugar. We would have loved to stay and enjoy the cozy ambiance, but we had more of the island to explore.
Omar
Such a nice and quaint place to stop for coffee. The atmosphere feels cozy and welcoming, and the coffee itself is really good. It was packed when I went, but definitely worth the wait.
A great spot to relax and enjoy the island vibe. Would absolutely visit again.
… moreA great spot to relax and enjoy the island vibe. Would absolutely visit again.
Alli C
Such a cute little coffee shop. Very quaint and cozy. I tried the pumpkin pie latte. One of the best lattes I’ve ever had. Wasn’t overly sweet and syrupy. You could really taste the quality. My husband had black coffee and he said that it was a very good brew. We both ordered breakfast. The food was good, not great.
… moreManan
One of the best cofOne of the best coffee places I have ever been. The different coffees we ordered (cappuccino, machiato and cortado) were genuinely good. The food was also surprisingly tasty and the deserts took it to next level.
… moreChloe Medina
I’m definitely coming back here! Such a cute stop on our trip to Bainbridge! Amazing ivy growing up the building mixed with the brick. Good coffee and maple donuts! Seating is minimal but we got lucky when it wasn’t busy.
… moreSundeep Pidugu
I visited Pegasus Coffee House on Bainbridge Island and had a great experience. The place has a warm, cozy vibe and is perfect for a relaxed morning. I ordered a coffee and the smoked salmon avocado toast, and both were really good. The toast was fresh and flavorful, and the coffee was smooth. The staff was friendly and the atmosphere felt calm and inviting. Definitely a nice spot to stop by if you’re in the area.
… moreBhanuTeja Chaganti
I tried the mocha along with their freshly baked molten cake. They let you know upfront that the cake takes about 10–15 minutes, and that’s exactly how long it took. The place was crowded, with a line that meant waiting nearly 20 minutes just to place our order. The mocha was nicely balanced—not overly sweet—with strong, good-quality coffee and a subtle chocolate note. The molten lava cake, however, fell short for me. The texture and flavor of the cake itself were underwhelming, though the molten chocolate center was enjoyable. Overall, it’s a decent option, but definitely not as impressive as the hype suggests.
… moreEriko Shimojo
This was on our list to check out in Bainbridge but we were a little disappointed. We came on a Sunday so the line took awhile which was understandable. However, the coffee was average and the hot cake (that we paid $14+ and waited 20mins for) was a goopy mess :/
The vibes in the cafe were cute tho and the baristas were very friendly!
… moreThe vibes in the cafe were cute tho and the baristas were very friendly!
Lauryn B
It was my first time here and unfortunately my last. Overpriced for what we received and highly disappointed.
Matcha was so thick and not mixed properly, could not taste any of the flavoring as well.
I seem to be missing the (THREE) cheese in my grilled three cheese panini especially for a 9.50 price tag on wonder bread and off brand three blend cheese?
The veggie breakfast sandwich, the entire thing was falling apart, had a black spot on it, tasted awful so we threw our sandwiches away then left to get to get food and drinks somewhere else.
… moreMatcha was so thick and not mixed properly, could not taste any of the flavoring as well.
I seem to be missing the (THREE) cheese in my grilled three cheese panini especially for a 9.50 price tag on wonder bread and off brand three blend cheese?
The veggie breakfast sandwich, the entire thing was falling apart, had a black spot on it, tasted awful so we threw our sandwiches away then left to get to get food and drinks somewhere else.
Owen Phillips
OK, so we came here on a weekend which was our first mistake, but we waited almost half an hour for our food. This is a terrible place for lunch/brunch.
Once I finally received my “panini” I was greeted with what looked like a roofing shingle. Little to no flavor; would not come back here for food.
… moreOnce I finally received my “panini” I was greeted with what looked like a roofing shingle. Little to no flavor; would not come back here for food.