The Pagano Perspective
1st time here. Very cool place inside. Service was great. I loved the chilli. My turkey sandwich was great with their sweet potato fries dipped in their caramel sauce. We also got their onion top burger and it was good too. We will be back!
… moreDebbie Pidgeon
Upon entering it was a great ambiance that was welcoming. We had the fish tacos and tenderloin with sweet potato fries (comes with a caramel sauce). The food was delicious. We’ll definitely come from Indy for a great restaurant experience that ee had here.
… moreTodd Johnson
I have been in Greensburg, Indiana, for work, and the crew and I have had several pork tenderloin sandwiches. To date, this is the best so far, by far. My coworker liked 1 from another local Oldenburg eatery. In fairness, I didn’t try that 1 & he didn’t try this 1. Be sure you try this 1! The smash burger was also great!
… moreyvonne marpert
My husband and I eat here at least once a week. He raves about their fish sandwich with mash potatoes and 7 layer salad. The servers are always friendly and it has a warm atmosphere. You won’t regret this place
… moreKerra Manor
Pearl Street is genuinely one of our favorite restaurants. The food is always delicious, and the weekend specials are consistently amazing. We’ve had so many great meals here and really do love the atmosphere and menu.
I never write bad reviews, but this part honestly needs to be said. Our experience is repeatedly dragged down by one of their waitresses (I don’t want to specify her name). Every time she waits on us, she isn’t just short or unfriendly, but she’s openly rude, dismissive, and acts visibly annoyed from the moment she approaches our table. It’s confusing because we’re an easy, low-maintenance, extremely polite family, and we always tip at least 20%, so there’s truly no reason for the attitude. It feels like she goes out of her way to treat us poorly, and it genuinely ruins what would otherwise be a great dining experience.
… moreEugene Roush
Large party of 15. Service was exceptional, food was out quick and hot! 10 out of 10!!
☆Fish sandwich, incredible!
☆Wings, incredible!
☆Smash burger, incredible!
… moreDiane Thomas
Hidden gem in Oldenburg Indiana where a lot of locals go. We’ve been to Pearl Street Pub several times throughout the years. The food is always great. A family favorite is the grilled buffalo chicken sandwich. It’s the best I’ve ever had. Burgers are always a hit also. During this visit, our daughter asked us to pick up a grilled buffalo chicken sandwich for her. Service was excellent!
… moreDavid Cross
Great pub in Oldenburg. The food was served fast and it was good, including a locally sourced tenderloin sandwich that was about a foot long and a delicious cole slaw. And the beer was ice cold! All with great service.
… moreLAI
Fantastic little find! I got the reuben which was absolutely tasty! Not to mention, I am a coleslaw snob and this was by far the best coleslaw I have had, creamy with just the right amount of tang! Then we got a slice of ding ding chocolate cake to go — BIG MISTAKE!! That slice of cake was so delicious that my husband regretted we didn’t buy a whole cake to go! SOooo delicious! The service was grreat, too! Highly recommend!!
… moreSharon Miller-Navarro
Always enjoy having lunch here. They had such a cute way of filling the tables and chairs for social distancing.
… more