Paul Main
Have discovered this place and it is an awesome hang out. Joined their mug club and head there with the neighbors often. Great staff, great selection of tap beers and bottles. Food is also very good. I recommend Pearl Street very highly. Looking forward to dining and drinking here more.
… moreJack Lattner
Pretty disappointed to be honest. Pizza was very subpar. Spent around $35 for a large pizza and the pizza was so bland despite getting a supreme. Huge chunks of green bell peppers and mushrooms which was not pleasant. The sauce tasted like you got it out of a can. Just a sad experience for how much money we paid for the pizza. Spots of the pizza were uncooked and had raw dough. Competition offers better for less.
… morePatrick Kelly
Went to Pearl Street Pizzeria for a quick bite before we headed out to the airport. We order a pan tossed Margherita and Meat Lovers Pizza. The Margherita was fresh, and it was tasty. The environment was good, but it was a but slow, and some of the waitresses were sitting at a guest table and talking (must have been locals). It was a nice little spot, and I would come back and have their hand tossed pizza.
… moreDerek Gustin
Came for an early dinner, parking was easy to find. We were sat at a booth immediately. The waitress was very attentive and patient with us being first time guests. We started with the pretzel appetizer. They were soft and buttery with a side of beer cheese that had a slight spice to it. Also, we ordered a supreme and mad greek pizza. Both had excellent flavor and crust. We will definitely be back.
… moreTiffany L
This pizza was unique! Deep dish but not overly oily. Was thick but so chewy. We mainly eat veggies and they had a couple veggie options. Would definitely come back.
… moresankalp bhatnagar
Pearl Street pizzeria in fishers is a fine pizza place. Ample parking in front of the restaurant. They have a nice reception area and 2 benches if you have to wait before seating. Ample dining spaces inside the restaurant and has a modern trendy vibe inside. The servers are very friendly and helpful and they made the experience amazing. I ordered old fashioned and I didn’t read the description before ordering, it has a cinnamon spice in it and I am not a big fan of cinnamon so I let my server know and apologize that I didn’t read the description and she immediately took it off for me and got me one without the cinnamon flavor which was perfect for me. Loved the services. I ordered cheesy breadsticks, spicy chicken and gorgonzola soup, and half-and-half Buffalo chicken and veggie pizza which was cooked to perfection. Ioved the place and experience so definitely recommend trying it out.
… moreJohn Englert
Everyone is very nice and friendly. Bailey and Mike even remember our drinks, lol. They are extra special! We haven’t tried everything on the menu but every pasta, pizza, and appetizer has been fantastic. Best Mexican pizza I’ve ever had. Full bar and lots of cold draft beer. Wine too of course. Half price bottles on Tuesdays! Mug club gets you extra 4 onces of beer. You cannot go wrong if you like Italian. This place could be 6 stars.
… moreTeresa Zenitsky
Mostly good, but skip the Pear and Gorgonzola pizza. Arugula is cooked under the cheese, not placed fresh on top, and is REAL gross. Gross texture, and not good taste. Pears seem right out of a can.
… moreKristen Lattner
The pizza was really bland and not something I would ever crave again unfortunately. It also seems really expensive for what we got. Had to rebake it when we got home and the dough was still raw in some places. Not feeling too good after eating that!
… moreMatt T
We attended a pine to posh here and the accommodations were great. The back area was reserved and we had a large open space to work and eat.
The wings were amazing and the pizza was great.
… more