Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1624 Marion-Mt Gilead Rd, Marion, OH 43302
Phone: (740) 389-4732
Website: http://paynespizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Payne’s Pizza & More
Welcome to Payne’s Pizza & More, where our dedication to handcrafting … MARION. Menu & Prices are subject to change. Our products are made using …
Payne’s Pizza Online Ordering
1624 Marion Mt. Gilead Road Marion, OH 43302. View Map. +1(740) 389-4732. Print Menu. Order Information. Notice for Pickup. 25 Mins. Notice for Delivery.
Payne’s Pizza & More – Marion – Order Online
Payne’s Pizza & More Marion. 1624 Marion Mt Gilead Rd, Marion, OH. Delivery. Pickup. Pickup from 1624 Marion Mt Gilead Rd, Marion, OH. Schedule your order for …
Reviews
Liberty Schultz
The overall taste was really good- the crust and sauce and cheese all tasted good together, but our only complaint is there was no where near enough cheese. It was the thinnest layer, but the middle pieces had a decent amount.
They said they didn’t have a small so a medium was $11, but when we picked it up it was the same size as 2 other places small pizzas.
… moreThey said they didn’t have a small so a medium was $11, but when we picked it up it was the same size as 2 other places small pizzas.
Jon Hanlon
We ordered 2 subs. Was told it would be delivered in about an hour. After having to call and check on it, oh it’s on its way like they always say. Wife called just got ready to cancel it the driver shows up. One hour and 40 minutes later after placing the order. Food was cold. Probably won’t be ordering there again.
… moreKrista Porter
We eat here quite a bit (monthly or bi-monthly) and I have never had pizza better than I have this Memorial Day weekend. We got a sub and salad too…all delivered fresh and pizza was hot! Thank you delivery dude!! Thank you for driving way out here in the country. Also, Whoever is doing the cooking this weekend- you rock! The pizza had gooey cheese yet completely done!!! We ordered twice it was so good!! Keep up the good work and we will keep on ordering!
… moreT Sarmi
The sub we ordered had too much onions. Everyone at our table smelled nothing but onions the whole time. We thought it was funny. The pizza sauce was a little more sweet than I’d prefer, but it was a good pizza.
… moreDouglas Pennington
I ordered a Stromboli and it was on a bun instead of a crust folded over the toppings. The bread was so hard around the edges that it couldn’t be eaten. When I called to complain they hung up the phone on me. There was very little pizza sauce and very little cheese on it. I don’t recommend anyone to order or eat here. My mother ordered cream of broccoli soup and she got melted cheese with just a couple little pieces of broccoli in it. The soup was disgusting to even taste.
… moreangela oney
Pizza was very good and service quick! Ordered 2 12 inch pizzas and an 18 inch pizza and all done very quickly!! Clean establishment. Accommodated 6 for a small birthday party and table reserved when we arrived. Would highly recommend!
… moreRichard Whitman
Always on point and never disappointed..we do a lot of take out and always hot and fresh and serve over the phone!!! Great job Payne’s staff wish I could give more stars!!
… morehc “hcains2238” cains
This is my first time eating at this place and I got the lasagna. The breadstick was pretty disappointing and the salad was a little upsetting as well. The lasagna was burnt around the edges a little bit, but it was still really good.
… moreMike & Melissa
Eaten here a few times. Great subs, pizza and salads. Friendly staff and homey atmosphere. Great food for the $$. A place I’d take my friends.
… moreJessica Houser
Ordered kid’s spaghetti and one was an ok amount but one had about 20 pieces of pasta under the cheese that was burnt to the bottom of the container. I realize the meal isn’t expensive but neither is pasta. It said “half sized portion” on the menu. I can’t imagine an adult sized portion only being twice this.
… more