Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Hours
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 665 Samoa Blvd, Arcata, CA 95521
Phone: (707) 822-6199
Website: https://www.paulslfnypizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Paul’s Live from New York Pizza | Pizza restaurant in CA
Come in and try the best pizza in CA!
paul’s live from New York | Arcata CA – Facebook
Paul’s Live from New York Pizza | Pizza restaurant in CA. PAULSLFNYPIZZA.COM. Paul’s Live from New York Pizza | Pizza restaurant in CA. Come in and try the …
Paul’s Live from New York | Restaurants – Food Network
Paul’s Live is a New York pizza joint with one little twist — it’s in California. Here, you can find “old-school, authentic, East Coast pie …
Reviews
Sara March
Best pizza in Humboldt! Classic, NY style – delicious!
Lots of choices and gluten free options. The Olive Special is excellent.
… moreLots of choices and gluten free options. The Olive Special is excellent.
Abbie Strickland
If you haven’t tried the meatballs in marinara- you are depriving yourself of the best meatballs some girl on google reviews ever boasted about. They are so good! The marinara is amazing and the fresh basil really sets it off. The service is also just as amazing- the employee who consistently wears jordans and basketball shorts always goes above and beyond. You wont regret stopping by!
… moreNancy Cicatelli
I have to recant my rating. I wanted to order a reg.Veggie pizza but they don’t have that.So I went back and forth with the girl taking my order. I asked for bell peppers, olives, mushrooms, basil and garlic. after 20 minutes of her not knowing the difference between vegan and gluten free. I ended up with a gluten free Pizza with NO bell peppers. I used to love this place but, come on! don’t most pizza places have a veggie pizza. I think the place has gone down hill. the front is dirty
… moreThe snap Chap
Loved the atmosphere, beer selection with happy hour specials, and amazing service. The staff here is great and accommodating. The salads and cannolis are great, but my gripe is the cheese on the $30 pizza had zero stretch and flavor. The crust was dry and lacked flavor as well.
… morepowers evan
The pizza here is so good, if you like thin crust this is one of my favorite pizza places in Arcata.
… moreBowen Byers
Awesome pizza parlor with great New York style pizza selection. Huge slices of huge pizzas, they have a nice variety of topping combinations. Two slices was plenty filling for one. Overall a solid A grade.
… moreDr. KooMo
We ordered for pick up on our way to our campsite. Husband has the Hawaii 5-0 as he lives his pineapple and ham pizzas. I had the Pesto Paradise substitute sausage for pepperoni. Excellent! We talked about driving the hour back to get another before we leave the area.
… moreStew Gee (Stewgee)
Really enjoyed our visit to the Arcata branch.
We ordered far too much pizza – very large portions here – a 14 inch pizza each plus a large salad was more than double what we wanted – a (generous) individual slice and side salad would have been great, or a pizza and a large salad for three.
Anyway, great bases and tasty toppings and friendly service make this a great place for dinner – just don’t go mad when making your order.
… moreWe ordered far too much pizza – very large portions here – a 14 inch pizza each plus a large salad was more than double what we wanted – a (generous) individual slice and side salad would have been great, or a pizza and a large salad for three.
Anyway, great bases and tasty toppings and friendly service make this a great place for dinner – just don’t go mad when making your order.
Jo’lene Morgan
Really uncomfortable experiance. I ordered a roll after confirming it would be a “roll” like a cinnamon roll pizza style. I wanted no bell peppers/olives.
Got the “roll” but it was a folded yet open-style liquid-filled mess it also had bell peppers. My husband took it back because it was very soggy and inedible. He exchanged it for 3 slices of pizza.
I was grateful that they exchanged it without hassle however on the very first bite there was a rock/pebble a little smaller than an eraser. It chipped my front tooth and caused a lot of pain shooting up into my gums. It’s still hurting. I called and let them know that we didn’t want it remade but that they should take it off the sale shelf for safety reasons. The lady said “ok yea, Thanks for letting us know…” but she seemed really irritated and hung up as I was saying “yea no problem I just don’t want anyone else getting hurt” the line went dead…. well I have pictures so I’ll share those.
Don’t get the roll if you don’t like sopping wet soggy bread filled with liquid.
Don’t get the godfather if you value front teeth!!!
… moreGot the “roll” but it was a folded yet open-style liquid-filled mess it also had bell peppers. My husband took it back because it was very soggy and inedible. He exchanged it for 3 slices of pizza.
I was grateful that they exchanged it without hassle however on the very first bite there was a rock/pebble a little smaller than an eraser. It chipped my front tooth and caused a lot of pain shooting up into my gums. It’s still hurting. I called and let them know that we didn’t want it remade but that they should take it off the sale shelf for safety reasons. The lady said “ok yea, Thanks for letting us know…” but she seemed really irritated and hung up as I was saying “yea no problem I just don’t want anyone else getting hurt” the line went dead…. well I have pictures so I’ll share those.
Don’t get the roll if you don’t like sopping wet soggy bread filled with liquid.
Don’t get the godfather if you value front teeth!!!