Nick Palermo
Our food was awesome but the service was 10x better! The gentleman who took care of us was very attentive & overall just a super nice guy. Thank you again!
… moreAlan Merkel
2/26/26 We were here 2 weeks ago and loved this place. Today we are considering twice and done. Yes Pete the owner was still working even in the kitchen! But, no Petey to be seen anywhere. Service at the bar by the fill in waitress/bar tender not so great. Food was no where near as great as last time. Eggplant rolls were barely warm, obviously premade cold in the freezer or fridge. Extra thin pizza was NOT thin any very soggy. So, I guess you be the judge and jury.
Our first time to visit this place, yesterday. Seems like a wonderful place and I think it is going to be one of our regulars! We are not pasta and pizza eaters usually, that is why we have never been here. Great happy hour and daily specials! Food was really good especially the eggplant rolls! They were so good we ordered more! Meat ball sliders were nice. The meat ball was solid and not fatty or falling apart. I actually cut my in slices like a steak to eat it gracefully. She liked the fried chicken sliders too. The owners, staff and customers were all very friendly. Pete, one of the owners, was greeting people as they came in. He missed us coming in but his son, Petey, greeted us. We sat at the bar and enjoyed the visit with them all. Pete made sure to come over to us and not only introduce himself but had a conversation with us and included us in conversation through out our visit. He, even though being the owner, was bussing tables, delivering food, bring to go boxes, offered to package the leftovers, seating people, greeting customers and conversing with everyone. THIS IS HOW A PLACE IS SUPPOSE TO BE!! They promised to look forward to our next visit. AND, WE LOOK FORWARD TO VISITING THEM TOO! We had two orders of eggplant rolls, fried chicken sliders with fries, meatball sliders (opted out of the fries to save them the expense) and two bottles of wine. Total with specials pricing, tax and a $25 tip was $100. And, well worth it.
… moreErin Campo
I’ve been here many times and always have been extremely happy with the food. We celebrated my daughters 21st Birthday in the back with around 35 people and service was great and again food was amazing. I cater from them for all my parties and all my guests couldn’t stop complimenting the food. Loved seeing Elvis there this past weekend. Such a great family place. Thanks Pete and staff
… moreDavid Bruno
Pizza was superb!!! My favorite around now. Great atmosphere and a neat place to relax, hide out, and watch some sports. I’m certain the entire menu of food is great. Will be back.
… moreHelen Jacek
I’ve been here a couple times now. Service is great and the meatballs are the best! I’ve also had their gnocchi which was good too. Prices are reasonable and they have a nice patio area when the weather is nice. My only complaint is no cappuccino machine.
… moreMichael Cimino
We ordered an appetizer the eggplant roll, didn’t get it till the middle of our main dish!!! I had the chicken vesuvio it had no flavor. 3 pieces of very thin sliced chicken breast! It was missing the garlic and peas, was missing the white wine flavor….being italian and from Elmwood Park this is not how you serve/ make chicken vesuvio!!
… moreB
The food was good. We had the loaded fries, Krab mac n cheese, and pizza. My least favorite was the pizza. There are much better pizza spots nearby. Our server was quick and nice. The coffee was cold and one of the cups had lipstick. Even with those two things, I would still give it 4 stars. But then this happened. There was a mistake on our fries and in the middle of us eating them, not complaining at all as they were good, another young woman came up with our correct order of fries and proceeded to yank away the incorrect fries without asking how we felt. We were literally reaching to get more as she took them away and set the correct ones down. This was completely unnecessary and rude. They are also are not following covid guidelines closely.
… moreKelly
Don’t get the chicken marsala. Gave a 5 star review because they didn’t charge me for it. Waiter took forever to come back to the table for me to say it wasn’t good. The sauce was the same consistency as water… not even kidding. Other dishes tasted great for everyone else but the chicken marsala was an embarrassment.
… moreLori Dunn
I try to visit every time I’m in Bartlett from New York state once or twice a yearo! The Italian beef pizza is my favorite! I brought friends in and they loved their meals too!
… moreLynn Philips
We had a small family celebration at Pasta Mia. They were fantastic. The food was delicious and everyone had an enjoyable time at the party. We were not rushed, celebrated with many drinks and dinner choices. The service was A+
… more