Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Counter-service place offering hot & cold subs on house-baked bread, plus pizza, calzones & salads.
Hours
| Monday | 6 AM–8:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 6 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 6 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 6 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 6 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 6 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1014 Main St, Buhl, ID 83316
Phone: (208) 543-5210
Website: http://www.papakelseyspizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Papa Kelsey’s Pizza
Tasty Pizzas, Hearty Subs, and Fresh Salads ; PIZZA. Premium meats, mozzarella and loaded with toppings ; SUBS. Tasty deli and hot sandwiches on fresh bread …
Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs 1014 Main St – Order Online
Get delivery or takeout from Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs … Papa Kelseys Pizza Subs (Main St, Buhl). Sign In. Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs. 1014 Main St, Buhl ID …
Papa Kelsey’s
See our latest menu, find our hours, and order online directly from us. Locations in Twin Falls, ID, Twin Falls, ID, Buhl, ID.
Reviews
Kendra Spicher
I had the best Veggie Sub! It’s a cute restaurant with clean tables and plenty of space. Very welcoming. The “whole” sub was huge, more like two full sandwiches, but I was still glad I got it because the bread was nice and fluffy and the amount of veggies on it was perfect. Super delicious!
… moreBen M
I always get the Italian Combo Sandwich when I go to Papa Kelsey’s. I always get the 16” whole size. I normally split it when another person. It might not fill you both up completely, but it’s enough to get you both to your next meal. If you were to try to eat the whole sandwich yourself, you probably wouldn’t have to eat again for the rest of the day. The sandwich is delicious and full of meat and if you split it, it’s inexpensive. I’ve been getting these subs here for a long time and the quality has always been the same. Their oven baked sandwiches are some of the best around. The sandwich will come with a small bag of lays potato chips. The inside of the restaurant looks sharp and has a nice modern look to it. I’ll recommend Papa Kelsey’s any day.
… moreMackenzie
Their Italian combo is the best sandwich ever but it’s almost impossible to get a hold of anyone to place an order on the phone.
… moreTim Athearn
Overall terrible pizza. The crust was dry and tasted like card board. The cheese tasted fake. The proportion was OK. Not much sauce on it. We picked it up at the designated time and it was cold. Two large pizzas for $45, not worth it.
… moreChyanne Stone
Ordered pickup. Was informed the worker forgot the pineapple on one sub, its okay, it happens. But when I got home there was no vegis on Any of the 3 subs. The salad had 2 inches of standing water at the bottom and my sub was very burnt.
… moreDebbora Bergeron
Oh my! Size matters
I ordered a whole tukey bacon sandwich.
Got home, opened the bag, and –
Hello come in Tokyo! It was huge and super yummmm
I could only eat half – but now I have another meal
Atmosphere – it’s cute inside. I love the cow art.
Service – I was looking over the menu on the wall, trying to find (The One) lol.
The young lady that took our order rushed us to order.
The young man brought our ‘Togo’ order out to us – that was very kind
The food is worth a return visit.
Thank you Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs!
… moreI ordered a whole tukey bacon sandwich.
Got home, opened the bag, and –
Hello come in Tokyo! It was huge and super yummmm
I could only eat half – but now I have another meal
Atmosphere – it’s cute inside. I love the cow art.
Service – I was looking over the menu on the wall, trying to find (The One) lol.
The young lady that took our order rushed us to order.
The young man brought our ‘Togo’ order out to us – that was very kind
The food is worth a return visit.
Thank you Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs!
Karlie James
Food is decent but no where near worth the amount they charge. I’m ashamed for how much we just spend on SANDWICHES. There are minimal ingredients and the quality is okay. Sandwiches at home from now on ♀️
… moreK.T. Griffin
We stopped by late on a Saturday but the staff was welcoming and patient, and the food was amazing! Get the chipotle steak sandwich, you won’t regret it! They toast it perfectly, like a panini, and they don’t skimp on toppings!
… moreSarahM Weintraub
First time here! The dining area was very clean and the staff were friendly. We had 8 of us and the food was done very timely.
This the 6″ Malibu Chicken with chips. It was yummy!
… moreThis the 6″ Malibu Chicken with chips. It was yummy!
Rayna Fredy
Ordered a roast beef sub, do you have to ask for lettuce and tomatoes? Bc I got bread and 2 pieces of roast beef. Terrible sandwich
… more