James Harper
First time trying Papa J’s Pizza & Subs and I’m honestly impressed. We got the buffet and it did not disappoint. The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and had that perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and crust. They kept everything stocked and hot, and the overall experience was great. You can tell they care about quality. I’ll definitely be back and would highly recommend it to everyone.
… moreErika Maxwell
Came in today for the buffet. They asked what we like and got to work on the pizza while we had the salad bar. Lots of toppings for the salad. Garlic cheese bread is incredible and so are the Cinnamon sticks. $14.99 for adults. Well worth it. Left absolutely stuffed.
… moreAlvin
We stopped in around 8 o’clock The guy at the register made all the food fresh for us. They are really nice. The food was awesome. The cheese bread was our favorite by far and we got the buffet, but they sent us home with a to go box. This is my new favorite buffet definitely worth it
… moreScarecrow
Excited to give the new pizza place a try only issue I had was my pizza was incredibly greasy even after having it cooked well done ( which was on point) that it leaked through the box and stained the car seat from the ride home and maybe offer crust toppings since its a little bland and dry for my desire. The pizza and bread were very good & toppings were far from skimpy! This is a new pizza place freshly opened so trial and error no criticism. Imma try again next week and probably delete this review but for feedback figured it was worth sharing
Welcome to the community yall!!
… moreStacy Heinzerling
Papa J’s dill pickle pizza is SO good! Perfectly tangy, cheesy, and unique. The flavors work incredibly well together, and the crust is delicious. Highly recommend!
… moreF S
First time! HIGHLY RECOMMEND! The Food is EXCELLENT. The customer service is EXCELLENT. My husband and I think they may be the best pizza in all of monroe county the bread, the no droop, the FLAVOR!!! My husband bought us a medium for a snack, I ate 6 slices, (I’m sorry baby…) but the taste is incredible! Incredible recipe!! Go get yourself lunch and dinner at Papa Js, you will continue to go there often! The Flavor is A ONE OF A KIND!
… moreTara Taylor
We went to try the buffet. Salad bar had tone of toppings and it was delicious. We were the only ones in there so we made our requests and they mad the pizzas and we had fresh hot all you can eat pizza pop breadsticks and cinastix it was a great experience great food nice establishment and over all a good time for me and my family I’m sure we will be back
… moreRobert Barry
Gentleman at the counter said I was the first to order the new burger today… and they nailed it!! Fries had just the right amount of salt and were spot on!! Only thing I wish was you could choose how they cook your burger but it is what it is. Will definitely be back for it! Never had a bad meal here and this is the 4th time ordering from papas. Pizza and cheese bread 10/10 also!
… moreBrandy Van Sickle
We ordered from here. We got a large New Yorker with extra cheese and pepperoni and small BBQ chicken pizza with small Cheesy bread with ranch. IT WAS THE BEST PIZZA IN TOWN! It was hot ingredients was fresh. The taste was amazing. Their ranch is delicious. Will be ordering again.best part delivery was 4.50… 10/10
… moreArthur Hill
The pizza was very good with excellent quality ingredients and the salad bar was very good as well! Fresh ingredients and an amazing atmosphere that brings this small town spot together. Cannot recommend enough!
… more