mike bone
Sometimes its great sometimes its not. Guess it depends on who you get whoms working. Always ask for extra pepperchinis and sometimes you might get 1 extra other times you get someone else you might get 5. Needs to be an area on the app to request this, I dont mind paying extra as long as I get it. When they have the $9.99 anyntopping pizzas you get like 3 of each toppings you chose. Defeats purpose of ordering it.
… moreMelissa Wilson
I got a steak hoagie from here they burnt the cheese and bread and all the sauce ran out onto the outside of the wrapper. It was the worst steak hoagie i have ever bite into. Also I would never order the epic stuffed crust, it is so greasy and everything just fell off when you picked up a piece.
… morekmd0170
If you like them getting your order wrong and then them giving you a free pizza with a bunch rotted portabello mushrooms on it…… you’ll love this Papa John’s!…… I almost feel like I’m inconveniencing them when I order from them by phone. You can find better pizza within 2 miles for $5 less.On the positive side,they are always friendly in person just not on the phone, and the store is always clean. I probably had 1 bad experience. If I order again I will update my review accordingly.
… moreCali Howard
Christian was great. Accidentally ordered the pizza and hour later than intended but when I showed up he adjusted and got me my pizza within 10 minutes!!
… moreAnna Pheil
UPDATE: July 15, 7:30 pm —The pizza was sooooooo good again! The guys and gals there are truly making the best pizza. Two for two for now! Thanks you all! Yummmm . You all are going above and beyond!
Sometimes the pizza here is mediocre , so I haven’t ordered in awhile, but today, June 7, 2025, at 3:00 pm, cheers to the team working because it was the best Papa John’s I have ever had! All our pizzas were done so perfectly and it was soooooo yummy!! I don’t know who you all are, but I want you to make my pizza all the time! And also thank you for being so friendly when I picked my pizza up! Thank you!! I will be ordering again! Maybe you can train the others!!
… moreBrandon Johnson
The dough must have changed. My pizza the past 3 times has been flat, dry, and the crust doesn’t rise. The crust not only doesn’t rise but it been 2 inches from the the cheese all the way around the pie. It’s pathetic. This place sucks! I went to the Clifton location on short Vine Street and they had the nice rising crust 1/2 inch around and the pizza was juicy and great. Never again at the Salem rd. location. Never!
… moreSkyler
Got pizza from here last night. Everything in the order was undercooked. I only ate two pieces and now eight hours later Im throwing up undercooked pizza.
Never had issues here in the 4+ years Ive been ordering but Ive never been given rushed undercooked pizza that made me sick before.
… moreAlexander Rolsen
I have had better from this place. I even tipped the driver. I asked for 2 extra Garlic Dippin Sauce. Didn’t even get it or the chance to tell the driver he was already in his car before I could ask if it was there.
… moreUnohooClan UnohooClan
I love Papa John’s but this recent visit our order was messed up. I called and had to go back up to get the fixed pizza and got home just to find it STILL was wrong! So, we didn’t get what we were supposed to get and definitely not in a timely manner! I called to speak to manager, I haven’t heard back. So around $45 was spent and we didn’t eat 2 pizzas at all. Why? My child is allergic to sausage and it was all over it when we said NO sausage! Second time issue! Eating was was seriously delayed and ended up having to make food at home instead. You guys really should follow up with people when you say you will. I shouldnt have to explain things 5 times either.
Other than that I will say we really like Papa johns! Great pizza etc. the only other thing I can say that could stand to change is the fact that they have increased prices too much. W e use to buy once or twice a month, but now we only order once every 4 or 5 months.
They have the best garlic sauce that comes with pizza. We usually get pizza or pizzas, cookie and 2 liters every time!
… moreIzzy
We order carry out from here after work once a week or so and the same guys are always working when I go in, I swear they kill it everytime. The pizza is consistently so good and everyone is always nice.
… more