Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Newberry, FL, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Newberry pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Newberry or stop by 14126 W NEWBERRY RD for carryout to order the best pizza in Newberry, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 14126 W Newberry Rd STE 70, Newberry, FL 32669
Phone: (352) 240-1970
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Papa Johns Pizza W Newberry Rd
At Papa Johns Pizza in Newberry, FL, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, …
papa johns stores in newberry, fl
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in Newberry, Florida to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Papa John’s Pizza Delivery in Newberry, FL | Full Menu & Deals
Papa John’s Pizza in Newberry now delivers! Browse the full Papa John’s Pizza menu, order online, and get your food, fast.
Last Updates
Reviews
Alex Bayard
Taylor from this store is the sweetest person!!! She chatted with me for so long while I was waiting on the phone with Papa John’s support and then while waiting for my pizza to be remade (because of an issue I caused, the store wasn’t at fault and was actually really generous in rectifying it for me). Thanks for the awesome customer service in every facet, Papa John’s (and Taylor❣️)!
… morepri
Taylor was so lovely! I’m new to the area and she was so knowledgeable and helpful. She is a very sweet and hard worker and definitely deserves a raise! Also, the food was hot, delicious, and was ready so quickly. I have been to this location 2 other times now, and my experience is always amazing with helpful and friendly employees. I will definitely be back soon!
… moreLee Swoyer
Best Papa Johns, and the only place you need to go to in Jonesville for pizza. They’re the absolute best. Also get the cheeseburger pizza you won’t regret it
… moreCrystal Yan
I just bought a pizza from this store for takeout. I didn’t open and checked it. When I got home, I found the garlic source is open, and it spread out all over the pizza. It looked disgusting. How can this happened? Put an open source in the box?
… moreKaty Houser
If I could go lower I would. The service at this location has gone down hill so bad. There’s so many times of waiting for food and no one knows what’s going on or where orders are. It’s chaos at best. After waiting all that time the food quality is terrible. I don’t know what’s wrong with this location but probably any other one would be better
… moreMario Castejon
I walked in, ordered and paid for a one-topping large pizza. I paid $16.25 + tax, just to find out after I had paid that they offered the same pizza online for take out for $9.99. I mentioned this discrepancy and was told that they have different specials online and in the store. I felt cheated. In addition, when we got home and started eating the pizza, the dough was undercooked.
We had to drive back to get it replaced. Not a good experience at all.
… moreWe had to drive back to get it replaced. Not a good experience at all.
Utopia569
I usually go to this location and the one on 16th for my favorite stuffed crust pizza. I got the cheddar stuffed crust today and it was very good. At this Newberry location Taylor went above and beyond for my order and the pizza she made was very delicious. I definitely recommend getting a stuffed crust pizza from this location in Newberry.
… moreTaylor Redding
Recently placed an order online for pizza to be delivered for a school function the previous date of the function. Following the order, I called and confirmed with an employee over the phone the time and place as the school has a certain amount of time to eat lunch. The time for the kids to eat rolls around and no food. A notification was sent saying the delivery has been given to door dash. Called papa Jon’s and spoke to the manager, who said sorry basically we can’t get there from here and nothing they can do. Have to call around to find the door dash person and beg them to deliver straight to the school so the kids could eat. Customer service is dead and this is what I get for not going to Villaggios. Won’t make that mistake again.
… moreJulianne Summerlin
April is super sweet! This location makes the best pizza! The store is so clean!
… moreTarah Kelley
Taylor was working by herself today and busting her butt to get our order ready. We had a little mishap but she quickly fixed it and went above and beyond. Great to see hard workers like this out there still
… more