Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Carlisle, PA, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Carlisle pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Carlisle or stop by 500 S HANOVER ST for carryout to order the best pizza in Carlisle, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
500 S HANOVER ST – Carlisle, PA – Papa Johns Pizza Locations
Call us for pizza delivery in Carlisle or stop by 500 S HANOVER ST for carryout to order the best pizza in Carlisle, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
papa johns stores in carlisle, pa
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in Carlisle, Pennsylvania to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Create Your Own Pizza – Papa John’s
Enjoy the ease of ordering delicious pizza for delivery or carryout from a Papa Johns near you. Start tracking the speed of your delivery and earn rewards …
Last Updates
Reviews
A F
After 20+ years of loyalty I am sadly boycotting Papa John’s. I have been going there since my Dad showed me when they first opened in Denver. They used to be known for their quality. Nothing tasted good. Not the pizza or wings. This is our 4th bad experience. Once at Washington DC, once in Charlottesville, once in Hershey and now Carlisle. Hershey we did not eat because there was only worker and they lost our order.
… moreDavid Monreal
I have been disappointed with the quality control of this particular Papa John’s. I love their pizza and so do my kids but they send out pizzas like this. This isn’t stuffed crust! With no cheese and little sauce about ⅓ of a slice has zero toppings.
… moreCarlos Pedroza
This place is dumpster grub! I ordered a pizza and wings to my hotel room 9 minutes away, per google. I was quoted a delivery time of 25-35 minutes, which was cool for a Friday night. 35 minutes after my order I received a message that papa John’s lazy faces passed delivery onto garbage door dash, which I purposely avoided when placing the order! 90+ minutes later, i received an ice cold pizza-like disc that had cardboard-ish color to it and lukecold wings soggy in sauce I didn’t order from a walking dead reject. This was after I paid $5 for delivery and $5 tip on a $14 order. If ever back there I know exactly where NOT to order from! Save your money and just chew a stick of gum!
… moreRyan M
Pizza is a bit light on the toppings and way too much cheese. May as well be a very expensive cheese pizza. The cheese stuffed crust is good for 2 slices. After that I find myself wanting the regular crust and pulling cheese off. I’m cheesed out.
… moreThomas
Overall if you have some good coupons it is a decent place to try.
I will most likely not be reordering food as I prefer a different chain.
Wings were… underwhelming for the price you pay… They were small bone in wings which is fine but the price per is $$$. Taste wise they were good once you forgot the price.
Pizza: Was decent, it is definitely a fast food pizza. Topping quantity was a bit lacking.
Garlic Bread: Was not really garlicy but a decent quantity for price.
Staff was 10/10 and deserve a raise.
… moreI will most likely not be reordering food as I prefer a different chain.
Wings were… underwhelming for the price you pay… They were small bone in wings which is fine but the price per is $$$. Taste wise they were good once you forgot the price.
Pizza: Was decent, it is definitely a fast food pizza. Topping quantity was a bit lacking.
Garlic Bread: Was not really garlicy but a decent quantity for price.
Staff was 10/10 and deserve a raise.
Eric Harker
Service was great.
I ordered online and they had it done exactly when it was supposed to be done.
Pizza was delicious.
We did get the jalapeno garlic bites. However we did not like them. Something we will not get in the future.
However just because we don’t like them doesn’t mean someone else doesn’t like them.
I’ll get pizza here again.
… moreI ordered online and they had it done exactly when it was supposed to be done.
Pizza was delicious.
We did get the jalapeno garlic bites. However we did not like them. Something we will not get in the future.
However just because we don’t like them doesn’t mean someone else doesn’t like them.
I’ll get pizza here again.
Rodele Assad
I ordered a medium pizza just like I have been doing for the past 4 to 5 days now and they have all been the same exact order and all got delivered the same way and it was good but today 6/4/2025 I ordered another one at 6:40pm, when it got delivered the box size is smaller than the rest of the other times that I ordered it and on top of it when I opened the box the pizza was really burnt. Now I’ve always ordered a well done pizza but this time it was burnt burnt…the crusts was so hard there was no way my kids or myself could’ve even enjoyed it not to mention it’s our favorite part on the pizza. So I called the store a young lady answered, soon as I voiced my concerns she immediately started speaking rudely as she got loud over the phone and now that I think about it I had this similar incident happen with me with this same individual before…I remember because she’s the only one that speaks aggressively over the phone. So anyways I let her know hey the food I ordered was medium but the box that I received is seems smaller than the one that I got yesterday for them being the same size that I ordered and also the pizza is too burnt I can’t even feel the softness of the crust. She started arguing with me stating that I got the right size of pizza and I ordered a well done pizza so that’s what I got. So I continue to tell her “no this is a different size according to the boxes that am looking at and yes I ordered a well done pizza because that’s the only way it tastes and looks cooked but that did not meant that I wanted my food burnt. She yelled at me over the phone as she tells me she’s going to refund my money for my pizza. I waited a little I didn’t get no signs to let me know that they refunded my money so I called back but because she recognized my phone number she picked the phone up and never said anything and she hung up so I called back they just sent the phone on hold for 5 to 10 minutes before they finally answered. It was the same young lady. I let her know that I didn’t get any prove that she refunded the money then she said aggressively that I wasn’t going to get proof and if I needed one I can go to the store n get it so I said I paid for delivery fee and my food wasn’t right so why couldn’t she just email me prove and once again she responded aggressively and yelling “I’m not going to DoorDash your prove to you; if you want it come to the store.” So I asked her why she giving me an attitude when they are the one that wronged me so at this point am upset because of the ways she’s talking to me and screaming on the phone so I grabbed my car keys and drove to the location. When I got there I called 911 because I didn’t want anyone lying on me about something that I did not do so basically for my protection I called them to come to the store location so while am on the phone with the 911 dispatcher all three of them that was working this evening are literally yelling at me and talking over me I couldn’t even hear the dispatcher questions that she was asking me and one of her guys that was working said “all this craziness over some pizza…” as if their behavior was ok and justified. The dispatcher had asked me to step out so I can be able to talk to her so I did and she asked me to wait in the car till the cops came. When the cops came I explained to him and he went in the store while I waited in the car for him to return when he came back to the car he gave me a receipt with a voided amount of $20.06 on there and said “that’s what they refunded me and how the young lady said that she couldn’t refund the delivery fee because it was out of her hand and asked me not to return at least for the rest of today so I told the cops that I was not even planning on to ever go back at all ever and I left. I just wanted to mention that when I went to the location I did take one of my empty boxes from my previous orders this week and also the ones that they delivered today to show them proof of why I thought the sizes was not the same but they didn’t care they was just being rude and aggressive for no reason.
… moreSamantha Taylor
I walked in the wrong door by mistake I get screamed at. I apologized and the person was rude to me the entire time after that. I will never order again after being treated like that. I know I wasn’t paying attention never been there before but that reaction was uncalled for.
… moreBobby B
$15 for this little cheese pizza that don’t even look alike pizza. Dough feels like 100 year old. Big thanks to papa John. This was my first and last time ordering from you guys
… moreKira Leigh
I just tried their new Alfredo pizza and it was really good! Everyone there has such a great attitude when I walk in.
… more