Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Panthers Pizza, Nappanee’s go-to spot since 2018, delights Elkhart, Kosciusko, and Marshall counties with diverse menu offerings. Enjoy our signature pizzas, comforting pastas, calzones, fresh salads, and hearty sandwiches, all made from high-quality ingredients. Join us for lunch specials, local catering, or gift someone special with a Panthers experience. Savor the flavors and Panther Pride in every bite—locally owned and operated! **ORDER ONLINE**
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8:30 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 105 S Locke St, Nappanee, IN 46550
Phone: (574) 773-0022
Website: https://pantherspizzanappanee.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Panthers Pizza – Nappanee, IN
Panthers Pizza, located in the heart of Nappanee, IN, has been the premier pizza destination for residents and visitors of Elkhart, Kosciusko, and Marshall …
Panthers Pizza | Nappanee IN – Facebook
Panthers Pizza, Nappanee. 2926 likes · 4 talking about this · 260 were here. Pizza and Italian eatery in Nappanee, IN. Delivery to Nappanee, Wakarusa,…
PANTHERS PIZZA – NAPPANEE, IN | Online Ordering – Clover
PANTHERS PIZZA. 105 S LOCKE ST, NAPPANEE IN. (574) 773-0022. Open 10:30 AM – 8:30 PM EST. Great Deals. 14″ 2- Topping $14.99*. $11.81.
Last Updates
Reviews
K C
Ordered delivery.. arrived within an hour. One of the only places that delivers out here. It was nice to have that. Thank you for offering that as a service. The Pizza was hot. Delivery driver was nice. Ordering was easy. Can’t complain about that.
However, It’s on the pricier side. Around $30 for 1 pizza with delivery and it was pretty flavorless. I asked for a thin crust pepperoni and definitely did not receive that. The crust is very thick. Disappointed because I didn’t want regular thick crust pizza, and I wasn’t able to eat more than a piece. :/ There was at most 10 pieces of pepperoni on the large. Lacking sauce and cheese as well. (Looks like there is ton, but it’s just the thick crust making it look like that.)
Don’t know if I would ever try this place again. Will opt for little ceasers, papa john’s, pizza hut, dominos, ect. instead.
Edit: SOME of the pieces were thin crust. My apologies. About less than half was thin. Just seems it was not rolled out very even.
… moreHowever, It’s on the pricier side. Around $30 for 1 pizza with delivery and it was pretty flavorless. I asked for a thin crust pepperoni and definitely did not receive that. The crust is very thick. Disappointed because I didn’t want regular thick crust pizza, and I wasn’t able to eat more than a piece. :/ There was at most 10 pieces of pepperoni on the large. Lacking sauce and cheese as well. (Looks like there is ton, but it’s just the thick crust making it look like that.)
Don’t know if I would ever try this place again. Will opt for little ceasers, papa john’s, pizza hut, dominos, ect. instead.
Edit: SOME of the pieces were thin crust. My apologies. About less than half was thin. Just seems it was not rolled out very even.
Kim haining
Updated review:
5 stars moved to 1 and will NOT BE RETURNING! I ordered a small cheese pizza, extra cheese with a side of banana pepers. Total came to $22.54. The pizza was uneven and very little cheese, as seen in the pictures. Looked like a high school kid made it and didn’t care! The peppers were put ON the pizza in a cup, so there was an indent of a cup on the pizza. Crust was hard, like homemade play dough that went dry. Used to be great but now the worst pizza ever.
Old review:
Really good! I have been looking for decent pizza in the area and this place is probably my new “go-to” spot. Its smaller than I figured, and parking is hard to come by, but we’ll be back.
Had a medium “Panther” pizza, mozzarella sticks and Panther bites and all was tasty. Filled us up very quick!
… more5 stars moved to 1 and will NOT BE RETURNING! I ordered a small cheese pizza, extra cheese with a side of banana pepers. Total came to $22.54. The pizza was uneven and very little cheese, as seen in the pictures. Looked like a high school kid made it and didn’t care! The peppers were put ON the pizza in a cup, so there was an indent of a cup on the pizza. Crust was hard, like homemade play dough that went dry. Used to be great but now the worst pizza ever.
Old review:
Really good! I have been looking for decent pizza in the area and this place is probably my new “go-to” spot. Its smaller than I figured, and parking is hard to come by, but we’ll be back.
Had a medium “Panther” pizza, mozzarella sticks and Panther bites and all was tasty. Filled us up very quick!
Jeremy Miller
Was pleasantly surprised by the freshness of food and enormous portion! I got a 12″ canzone and cheesy garlic sticks! Will return to try the famous cheesy double decker pizza! A nice little spot just off main intersection! A must visit for sure! Especially if love good fresh dough pizza!
… moreHolly Zartman
Ordered for delivery. Told us it would be an hour. Here we are 1 hour and 45 minutes later and no pizza. All they say is it is out for delivery. Never had this issue before. They can’t tell us where the driver is, or when our order went out for delivery. And just so happens there is no manager there and no one knows where the manager went. This will be the last time we order and we will NEVER recommend this place again.
… morejonathon Rios
I’m traveling from Texas. I haul rv’s and stay in Nappanee. This place reminds me of the friendly hospitality at home. The pizza is wonderful! Highly recommend.
… moreAlfredo A.
Cold, doughy, floppy. Has potential but it was cold and not done underneath. I had to put it back in my oven at home. You can see the wet raw side view
… moreLaura Wadkins
I ordered a pizza, sandwich, and spaghetti online at 4:57pm. They gave no estimate on when it would be ready, so I waited to pick it up until 5:40pm. At first they couldn’t find my order online. Once they found it, my pizza was done, but the rest wasn’t. 15 mins, they said. Okay… I’ll go wait in my car. I went back inside after 15 mins (plenty long enough to make pasta and a sandwich) and it still wasn’t ready. “Give us another 10 mins”.
This is ridiculous. I will not be ordering from them again.
Also, the restaurant is filled with smoke from the oven. It’s terrible! You can see it in the air. I can’t believe they work in that environment and expect customers to sit and eat in it.
… moreThis is ridiculous. I will not be ordering from them again.
Also, the restaurant is filled with smoke from the oven. It’s terrible! You can see it in the air. I can’t believe they work in that environment and expect customers to sit and eat in it.
Theresa Sergent
Great meatballs!!! The portion of the Spaghetti and meatballs was enough for two adults!!! I can’t wait to try the pizza next time!!!
… moreenders227
Great homemade pizza! Panther bread is awesome as well. Great value on their single slice meals too!
… moreKimberly Conrad
Ordered here because they offer 2 separare halves on one pizza. Pizza was delivered hot and loaded with cheese and toppings, which is a welcome change. Definitely our new favorite local pizza place.
… more