Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Local chain serving specialty pizzas, familiar pasta dishes, salads & subs in modest surrounds.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 68 Mountain Blvd, Warren, NJ 07059
Phone: (908) 755-3336
Website: http://panatierispizza.com/warren/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Menu – Warren – Panatieri’s Pizza & Pasta
Warren, New Jersey’s Famous Panatieri’s Pizza & Pasta Italian Restaurant offers Italian family recipes that are made fresh daily using the finest quality …
Home – Panatieri’s Pizza & Pasta – Warren
Panatieri’s Pizza & Pasta – Warren. New Jersey’s Famous Panatieri’s Pizza & Pasta Italian Restaurantoffers Italian family recipes that are made fresh daily …
Panatieri’s Pizza & Pasta – Warren NJ – Facebook
Panatieri’s Pizza & Pasta – Warren, Warren. 191 likes · 1 talking about this · 114 were here. NJ’s Famous Panatieri’s Pizza & Pasta Italian Restaurant…
Reviews
keisha dean
I’ve ordered from this restaurant a couple times and it had always been great until this last time. My grandma’s pizza was cold. It was edible but cold. The chicken wings were hard and dried out. I couldn’t even eat them. I even tried combining them with the wings that were sauced and they were just too hard to eat. To make matters worse the delivery driver left the food on the wet ground. This definitely is not the experience I’m used to.
… moreJoseph Eulo
Panatieri’s Pizza & Pasta — Warren, NJ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
As a DoorDasher who’s been all over New Jersey—north, south, and everywhere in between—I’ve eaten a lot of pizza. It kind of comes with the territory. Somewhere between deliveries, traffic, and lukewarm GPS directions, I’ve made it my personal mission to stop into mom-and-pop pizza spots, grab a couple slices, and see who’s really holding it down.
Panatieri’s Pizza & Pasta in Warren? Yeah… they’re doing it right.
I went with the plain thin-crust slice, because if a pizza place can’t nail that, nothing else matters. And this slice was delicious. Thin, crisp, and cooked just right—not floppy, not cracker-dry. The sauce had solid flavor without overpowering anything, and the cheese? Perfectly balanced. Just enough to be satisfying, not so much that it slides off and drips down your hand like a mozzarella landslide. I could actually eat the slice like a normal human being. That alone earns respect.
This is the kind of pizza you finish and immediately think, “Yeah… I’d come back for this.” No gimmicks. No overthinking. Just classic Jersey pizza done with care.
After delivering food all over this state, I can say with confidence: Panatieri’s is one of those local spots that deserves the love. If you’re in or around Warren and want a legit, no-nonsense slice from a real neighborhood pizza joint, put this place on your list.
I’ll definitely be back—probably between dashes, probably grabbing “just one more slice.”
… moreAs a DoorDasher who’s been all over New Jersey—north, south, and everywhere in between—I’ve eaten a lot of pizza. It kind of comes with the territory. Somewhere between deliveries, traffic, and lukewarm GPS directions, I’ve made it my personal mission to stop into mom-and-pop pizza spots, grab a couple slices, and see who’s really holding it down.
Panatieri’s Pizza & Pasta in Warren? Yeah… they’re doing it right.
I went with the plain thin-crust slice, because if a pizza place can’t nail that, nothing else matters. And this slice was delicious. Thin, crisp, and cooked just right—not floppy, not cracker-dry. The sauce had solid flavor without overpowering anything, and the cheese? Perfectly balanced. Just enough to be satisfying, not so much that it slides off and drips down your hand like a mozzarella landslide. I could actually eat the slice like a normal human being. That alone earns respect.
This is the kind of pizza you finish and immediately think, “Yeah… I’d come back for this.” No gimmicks. No overthinking. Just classic Jersey pizza done with care.
After delivering food all over this state, I can say with confidence: Panatieri’s is one of those local spots that deserves the love. If you’re in or around Warren and want a legit, no-nonsense slice from a real neighborhood pizza joint, put this place on your list.
I’ll definitely be back—probably between dashes, probably grabbing “just one more slice.”
M Pa
BE AWARE. Employee stealing money.
My total was $17.15, I gave $20 cash and employee did gave me proper change.
New Jersey s already expensive and employee wants to make tip out of our money. Not everyone is rich.
… moreMy total was $17.15, I gave $20 cash and employee did gave me proper change.
New Jersey s already expensive and employee wants to make tip out of our money. Not everyone is rich.
Kaden Ahmed
This is a really good pizza place. I used to come here all the time. I suggest them getting a hand sanitizer dispenser. nothing fancy. it’s a cheap and good way to slightly improve this place especially around the winter where people get sick.
… moreDisen Huang Albrecht
Feel like the taste of the pizza here has improved compared to last year. FYI they also have cannoli (their only dessert offering) which is not written on the menu.
… moreDiane Florey
Ordered fettuccine Alfredo and called Panatieri’s to request that it ensure the fettuccine was well saturated with the Alfredo sauce cuz the last two times it was dry. Same problem again occurred (it was a pickup order). I won’t be ordering this again from here. 🙁
… moreDebbie Conroy
Great place. So many types of pizza to choose from and a full range of menu items. Food is fantastic. Owners are very nice. Highly recommend.
… moreMolly Riedler
Currently undergoing renovation but omg… so many pizza options, strombolis, rolls, and the taste is just as good as i remember it 10 years ago if not better 🙂
… moreRimla
This is a great place to grab a quick slice. Their Sicilian pizza is as close to “authentic” as I could find in NJ. Sicilian slices are all about perfecting the crust. They did a great job.
… moreBaigsters
We love the plain pizza pie. Service is a hit or a miss. We order pizza pie and sandwiches and last few times we have very less chicken in the sandwiches. One of the grilled chicken foot long sandwiches was missing an entire filet on half of the side.
… more