Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Paisano’s Pizzeria – New City, NY – 730 NY-304 – Hours, Menu, Order
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-9:30 PM; Shop address is 730 NY-304, New City, NY 10956730 NY-304, New City, NY 10956; (845) 709-6234.
Best Pizza in New City, NY | Paisanos Pizza (New City) | Pizza near …
Paisanos Pizza (New City): the best Pizza in New City, NY. Order directly online today for takeout or delivery. Save money, support local business!
Paisanos Pizza | New City NY – Facebook
Paisanos daily combo specials. Order any day of the week, any time of the day!!! Pick up AND delivery!!!!! … 845-709-6234.
Reviews
NT D
An objective review for an online/pick up order:
My usual pizza place went on vacation this week so I thought I’d try someplace new. Paisanos was close and new so I gave it a shot.
I ordered through the SLICE app and special considerations like “well done crust,” “lite on garlic butter/oil” for the garlic bread, and “no broccoli, just plain white pie” for their white pie with broccoli were met (on a side note i’m not sure why they just don’t offer a plain white pie?).
I browsed through their pictures and saw their pies looked extra greasy/oily but was happy to find upon eating them, that they aren’t. (hold a slice up, very very minimal grease drips if any) I ordered a specialty white pie with broccoli (minus the broccoli), a plain cheesy pie, extra cheesy pie, mozzarella sticks, and garlic bread. There looked to be no difference between my plain cheese pie and my extra cheese pie(that i did pay extra for). Upon tasting them, it appears it wasn’t extra cheesy at all. The white pie was good but both the ricotta and the mozzarella tasted very generic (think Polly-o vs Great Value). On our cheese pies they added either oregano to the pies after the fact or it might have been incorporated into their sauce. As a result their cheese pies have a VERY heavy oregano flavor (for anyone who doesn’t like oregano you may want to call ahead and request they not add it). Of the people in my party who had the cheese pies, they agree they tasted “very salty.” The marinara sauce that came with the mozzarella sticks was SO DELICIOUS and flavorful! The tomato in the marinara spoke for itself without needing the usual Italian Seasonings to spruce it up. They should consider using that for their pizza sauce. Their mozzarella sticks came in a pack of 6, were THICK, and about 2.5 inches in length. They had more of a beer batter crust on them than breadcrumb crust which was delicious in its own right, but the cheese once again tasted generic. The garlic bread was about 10-12 inches long and was very soft. They honored the request for “lite on garlic butter/oil” so the inside wasn’t soaked but was instead a nice light coat making it perfect. The garlic looked freshly chopped. Before I placed my order I had called to ask if they sell garlic knots as I didn’t see it on the app. The woman was very nice and informed us they only make garlic knots on Fridays.
The pictures attached were taken AFTER we ate. 2 slices are from the large regular cheese pie, 2 slices are from the large extra cheese pie. We see and tasted no difference. We had 2 left over mozzarella sticks with the marinara sauce. The garlic bread (both an inside and outside view). Small white cheese pie with broccoli (minus the broccoli).
… moreMy usual pizza place went on vacation this week so I thought I’d try someplace new. Paisanos was close and new so I gave it a shot.
I ordered through the SLICE app and special considerations like “well done crust,” “lite on garlic butter/oil” for the garlic bread, and “no broccoli, just plain white pie” for their white pie with broccoli were met (on a side note i’m not sure why they just don’t offer a plain white pie?).
I browsed through their pictures and saw their pies looked extra greasy/oily but was happy to find upon eating them, that they aren’t. (hold a slice up, very very minimal grease drips if any) I ordered a specialty white pie with broccoli (minus the broccoli), a plain cheesy pie, extra cheesy pie, mozzarella sticks, and garlic bread. There looked to be no difference between my plain cheese pie and my extra cheese pie(that i did pay extra for). Upon tasting them, it appears it wasn’t extra cheesy at all. The white pie was good but both the ricotta and the mozzarella tasted very generic (think Polly-o vs Great Value). On our cheese pies they added either oregano to the pies after the fact or it might have been incorporated into their sauce. As a result their cheese pies have a VERY heavy oregano flavor (for anyone who doesn’t like oregano you may want to call ahead and request they not add it). Of the people in my party who had the cheese pies, they agree they tasted “very salty.” The marinara sauce that came with the mozzarella sticks was SO DELICIOUS and flavorful! The tomato in the marinara spoke for itself without needing the usual Italian Seasonings to spruce it up. They should consider using that for their pizza sauce. Their mozzarella sticks came in a pack of 6, were THICK, and about 2.5 inches in length. They had more of a beer batter crust on them than breadcrumb crust which was delicious in its own right, but the cheese once again tasted generic. The garlic bread was about 10-12 inches long and was very soft. They honored the request for “lite on garlic butter/oil” so the inside wasn’t soaked but was instead a nice light coat making it perfect. The garlic looked freshly chopped. Before I placed my order I had called to ask if they sell garlic knots as I didn’t see it on the app. The woman was very nice and informed us they only make garlic knots on Fridays.
The pictures attached were taken AFTER we ate. 2 slices are from the large regular cheese pie, 2 slices are from the large extra cheese pie. We see and tasted no difference. We had 2 left over mozzarella sticks with the marinara sauce. The garlic bread (both an inside and outside view). Small white cheese pie with broccoli (minus the broccoli).
Daniel Philip
New Spot!
great pizza, tasted really good and had loads of toppings. I liked the faint sweetness of the crust and the chicken tasted great.
Tried the chicken bacon ranch and the chipotle chicken slice . Amazing
… moregreat pizza, tasted really good and had loads of toppings. I liked the faint sweetness of the crust and the chicken tasted great.
Tried the chicken bacon ranch and the chipotle chicken slice . Amazing
Luke Jaeger
Great little pizza shop, the owner loves to make pizzas and you can often find some of his mad scientist creations in the front window. Always has some sort of classic desert in the fridge, store is always super clean. Great news shop and if you love pizza, gotta come try it.
My personal favorite: The SCAR. spinach, chicken (grilled), avocado, ranch.
… moreMy personal favorite: The SCAR. spinach, chicken (grilled), avocado, ranch.
alisa fea
All new items to the menu. All delicious choices. Recommend the rice
Balls, paninis, tortilla soup. Pesto is to die for!! Go check out the new items and see for yourself. Best garlic knots in town now!
… moreBalls, paninis, tortilla soup. Pesto is to die for!! Go check out the new items and see for yourself. Best garlic knots in town now!
Melanie McKaba
I found the serving size to be quite small for the price charged. The food was good but not great. If you are a regular, I think you get better treatment than someone off the street who just came in for the first time.
… moreJeffrey Ruck
The last few times I’ve ordered, the pizza is very inconsistent… Even on the same order. I nice medium done crust is perfect
Regular pie has great flavor. Sauce tastes like the perfect tomato, not to sweet and not to tart. Cheese is just good mozzarella.
Nice, clean and new location!
… moreRegular pie has great flavor. Sauce tastes like the perfect tomato, not to sweet and not to tart. Cheese is just good mozzarella.
Nice, clean and new location!
Stefan H
Under new ownership. Pizza was good, when hot. Had a chicken calzone, which was decent, again when hot. Family dinner takeout special only Monday -Thursday. Would go back.
… moreRamon Perez
The best pizza that I ever try, highly recommend paisanos pizza.
… moreSarah Arras
Thank you Paisanos of New City for offering gluten free and vegan cheese options so our whole family can enjoy pizza night!
… moreAli Ilsley
This chicken franchise sandwich is the cheapest sandwich ever. Half of this sandwich with barely any chicken. Literally just a bread sandwich. Service was bad- half out order was missing and we waited for them to make the other half. Obviously the food was cold and the girl had an attitude. Take your money elsewhere in New City because this was not worth it
… more