Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
This laid-back, old-fashioned Italian eatery serves specialty pizza, pasta dishes & sandwiches.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1129 Broadway St, Cape Girardeau, MO 63701
Phone: (573) 335-0366
Website: https://www.toasttab.com/pagliais-pizza-1129-broadway-st
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pagliai’s Pizza & Pasta | Cape Girardeau MO – Facebook
Tomorrow hours 10:30am-7ish. Due to weather and game time being rescheduled we are adjusting our hours. Opening at 10:30 and closing when it makes sense due to …
Pagliais Pizza 1129 BROADWAY ST – Order Online
Pagliais Pizza 1129 BROADWAY ST. 1129 BROADWAY ST, Cape Girardeau, MO. Pickup Only. Pickup from 1129 BROADWAY ST, Cape Girardeau, MO. Schedule your order for …
Pagliai’s Pizza & Pasta – Cape Girardeau – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Pagliai’s Pizza & Pasta at 1129 Broadway Street in Cape Girardeau. Order online and track your order live.
Reviews
Cris Fisher
Wow, this place was fantastic! We got two different pasta dishes, one with seafood and a white sauce and one with penne, veggies, and a marinara sauce. Both came in their own baking dishes, both were piping hot and both were delicious! Garlic bread was excellent too. Our waitress was friendly and the prices were reasonable. We will definitely come back and recommend this place to others.
… moreAaron B
Stopped in for a meatball sub—meatballs were delicious, but a bit skimpy for the size of the bread. Unfortunately, the service felt rushed and a little dismissive. As a solo diner taking up a table during the lunch rush, I get it—but it still felt unwelcoming
… morerichey orman
Delicious pizza, pasta and appetizers in a laid back atmosphere. All the staff, waiter/waitresses are all great, they definitely keep your glad full no matter what you’re drinking. Nice selection of adult beverages as well!
I’d highly recommend stopping in for a bite if you’re in the area.
… moreI’d highly recommend stopping in for a bite if you’re in the area.
Dan B
Had Pagliai’s Special pizza and a trip to their small salad bar. Food was good and service was good. I wouldn’t say food was great but it was good. No complaints. I would recommend it.
Another time had salad and spaghetti. Both good.
… moreAnother time had salad and spaghetti. Both good.
Lena Korzhevska
I liked the atmosphere of the place, and great service. However, let’s be honest – this is not Italian pizza. Probably, that is American adaptation of Italian style, but being in all parts of Italy and knowing what Italian pizza looks and tastes like – this is not the one. Nevertheless, the pizza they serve is tasty, nothing against. Just not Italian…
… moreSienna Müller
I was positively surprised to find that they could accommodate my dietary needs as a vegan, I ordered the baked veggie pasta and they even had vegan cheese. It was incredibly delectable. Salad bar also had some options. I was very pleased, would definitely visit again if I were in the area.
… moreChris
We eat here often and the food is amazing and always get a pizza to take home. The service is wonderful, sometimes you have to wait for a table but believe me, it is well worth the wait.
… moreWade Hutson
Love their pizza with a beer. Our family has been coming for years.
… moreShean Seward
Bad food and bad service. The service seems more attentive to larger crowds but looked over myself my girl and my son. They also over a table that was seated of a woman and a little kid. So it took awhile to get drinks. But you could clearly see service being attended to the multi top tables seated near. Appetizer came in at reasonable time. But then I got my pizza. No lie I look like Totino’s pizza. It was dry and had bacon bits on it. I gave one bite a try. Two bites a try and then I was done. Took awhile to get the server’s attention to tell her. And the management never came over to talk. Not going there again.
… moreBill Minter
Pizza was good, next time going to ask them to cook a little longer, for a crisper crust on it. Would have given a 5 star if pizza had been cooked a little longer, but will be going back again SERVICE WAS EXCELLENT, SERVER WAS GREAT ALSO
… more