Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 6 AM–4 PM |
| Thursday | 6 AM–4 PM |
| Friday | 6 AM–4 PM |
| Saturday | 7:30 AM–3 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 112 N Main St, North Liberty, IN 46554
Phone: (574) 656-3321
Website: http://overthetopbakerycafe.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Over The Top Bakery Cafe – North Liberty, IN
Located in downtown North Liberty and part of the Potato Creek Shops, Over The Top Bakery Cafe is a great destination to find all of your handmade baked good …
Over The Top Bakery Cafe | North Liberty IN – Facebook
Over The Top Bakery Cafe in North Liberty, IN. We have handmade cookies, cakes, donuts, and more!
Over the Top Bakery Cafe – North Liberty, IN | joe coffee
Over the Top Bakery Cafe in North Liberty, Indiana. 4.9 stars (197 reviews). Cafe. Hours, menu, photos & directions.
Product
Reviews
alex h
I was on the hunt for a red velvet cake for my wedding. I searched high and low until I stumbled across Over the Top; the only bakery in my area that could accommodate one of my non negotiables! It was well worth the 25 minute drive out of town.
They did a PERFECT job capturing the vintage look I wanted for our special day. And the taste? Incredible. Moist but not too rich, perfect crumb, and the buttercream was a lovely balance of sweetness.
We got some donuts and coffee the morning we picked up and I highly recommend those too.
Couldn’t recommend them enough!
… moreThey did a PERFECT job capturing the vintage look I wanted for our special day. And the taste? Incredible. Moist but not too rich, perfect crumb, and the buttercream was a lovely balance of sweetness.
We got some donuts and coffee the morning we picked up and I highly recommend those too.
Couldn’t recommend them enough!
Nick Baughman
Just a good country-folk-style coffee and bake shop. Simple and pleasant service.
… moreKatie King
The most perfect small-town bakery/cafe. Super friendly, hard-working, and amazing food. Wish they served the tea by the gallon. They have a variety of donuts, pies, breads, and café-style breakfast and lunch items. All amazing! And the price is definitely lower than anyone I’ve found near the South Bend area. Try it once, and you’ll be back again and again.
… moremannyfresh353
I drove from South Bend to try their paczkis. It was worth the drive. I bought some for the whole family and everyone loved them. While I was there, I grabbed a couple breakfast sandwiches to go. I ordered the bacon egg and cheese croissant and it was huge. They have a decent menu if you are looking for breakfast or lunch. The staff member who took my order was very friendly and welcoming. Did I mention you can order your treats online? That was a perk for me. If you are in the area or up for a drive, stop in for a quick bite or treat. You will not be disappointed.
… moreBrenda Spychalski
This bakery has THE BEST plain cheesecake, topped with strawberries, I’ve ever had! I ordered the cheesecake because it’s my nephew’s favorite and we were celebrating his birthday. Everyone thought it was so light and creamy and it was topped with enough strawberries for every bite. It didn’t last long! The only downside is they don’t sell individual slices, as of this review, because I know others who would like to try it vs having to order an entire cake. I’ll be ordering my cheesecakes from here going forward.
… moreAshley Bell
Absolutely amazing food and treats!!! The staff are just as sweet as the spectacular donuts!!! Every single time we go in it’s a great experience! The food is so delicious and you can tell they take pride in everything they make!! They have handmade wood kitchen utensils, jams, baked breads etc. They have a really cool table for the kids to play and color on while they wait for their yummy food!! The photo doesn’t do its justice lol
… moreKatie Martin
I cannot even begin to describe how happy I was with our order! My son turned 7 this year and he wanted donuts instead of cake! We ordered 3 dozen donuts with a red, white & blue baseball theme to match his party. THEY. WERE. PERFECT. My boy’s face lit up when he saw them! Thank you, Over The Top Bakery! We will be back very soon!
Amazing, friendly service. Extremely reasonable prices. Perfection!
… moreAmazing, friendly service. Extremely reasonable prices. Perfection!
Michiana Tree masters
Love the tasty treats friendly staff and in such an amazing small town!! I get a dozen from here for meetings all the time!
… moreJeremy Johnson
The BEST donuts anywhere! Worth the drive and won’t disappoint. Looking forward to getting a chance to try there breakfast and lunch. Amazing Apple Fritters!!! Very friendly. Barely got in door before the family attacked me.
… moremisha
I own The Cornerstone at Cedar wedding venue in Bourbon, Indiana. We enjoy cupcakes every weekend from different bakeries, but these are definitely some of the best cupcakes. They are moist, and the frosting is perfect . Job well done!
… more