Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Basic spot for a variety of pies, fried starters, salads & Italian entrees in a simple cafe setting.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1 Main St, Garnerville, NY 10923
Phone: (845) 429-4862
Website: http://oiprestaurant.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Original Italian Pizza & Restaurant | Garnerville NY – Facebook
Original Italian Pizza & Restaurant, Garnerville. 1041 likes · 201 were here. To read ABOUT US please see info.
Bruno’s On Main: Bruno’s On Main | Classic Italian Dining in …
Discover Bruno’s On Main, a Garnerville favorite serving authentic Italian cuisine made with traditional recipes and fresh ingredients. Join us for pasta, …
Original Italian Pizza Owner: We Will Reopen by June 1st (Or Sooner)
GARNERVILLE, NY – In an exclusive interview, Joe David, the owner of Original Italian Pizza (OIP), announced that the beloved pizzeria will …
Reviews
J
The best Italian pizza in the area. They are authentic, coming from NYC I have high standards for my pizza. They also sell Cannoli and Nutella filled zeppole, and prepaid Jamaican beef patty’s.
… moreAshley Johnson
This place has some of the best pizza I’ve ever eaten. Pictured below is their equivalent to a Supreme Pizza (I believe they call it Dumpster Pile, just know it comes with sardines) and it is glorious. Everything from their basic pepperoni/sausage pizza to this has always been perfect. Pricey, yes, but worth it.
… moreMISTER RILEY
Always luv the vybz customer service is always top notch and Bob always takes the time to speak and interact no matter how busy it is! Pizza is always great and if there’s a problem they have no issues addressing it and making the customer happy!!! Appreciate your hard work guys! Customer 4lyfe
… morePlot Twist
Paid $15 for this bull$hit shrimp platter
All the pizzas are a rip off
… moreAll the pizzas are a rip off
cindy m
The Staff is Awesome! Very welcoming! When you leave a place feeling like you just got the best customer service, it makes the food taste 100% better. Would Recommend the Garlic knot Sliders !
… moreJ. Betta
Ordered a Grandma pie with crumble sausage and chopped white onion and was very unhappy. It definitely was not a grandma pie. It was a square made pie made exactly like a regular pie. Not made with the correct sauce and cheese as far as the sausage and onions they put on it was very little of it. It was quite a disappointment would never go back or recommend this place.
… moreJames Cool
We had their pizza last week post the new ownership. I’d say this is the best pizza I’ve had in the North Rockland area in years. Light and crispy crust!
… moreDamian
Food is not cheap, gave an estimate on pickup order…. Got there when I was told it would be ready and had to wait an additional 20 minutes…. Not the end of the world. They were not busy, so not sure why the estimate was so off.
… moreMeats1389 “meats”
The place is ran by teenagers. The service/food is atrocious. We used to be loyal customers but not anymore. The prices are astronomical, and the food subpar. My wife ordered the eggplant salad and half of the container was filled wit water. This is the 2nd time. There was about 8 teenagers behind the counter all of them clueless. This place needs Gordon Ramsey
… moreitz icy
Horrible service Wed afternoon, I always order the same food around the same time to my mother who is 87 years old can eat since i’m not home and i always try to call when they are less busy around 5-6pm, not a hard order but the guy who took my order was being extremely rude, and later that afternoon when i came to pick up my food the whole order was wrong, not a single thing was right, and this isn’t the first time, and i was being okay with it until he started being rude saying “well it’s your fault you don’t speak clear on the phone” as he was raising his voice to my mother? are you serious, we let it slide and thought maybe he was having a bad day which it’s no excuse whatsoever but today Friday I also order and I can’t believe it, I came in and there was more than one person complaining about their orders being messed up, how rude the same guy was being, how the one sending delivery’s was messing everything up, def my last time and my family’s and friends last time ordering from there, they don’t know how to communicate and can’t handle busy hours. It’s upsetting seeing how a good place like this it’s starting to go downhill
… more