Address and Contact Information
Address: 421 Neighborhood Rd, Mastic Beach, NY 11951
Phone: (631) 395-3332
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Onofrios Italian Restaurant: Authentic Italian Dining in Mastic Beach
At Onofrio’s Italian Restaurant, we celebrate authentic Italian cuisine in a warm, inviting atmosphere. Nestled in Mastic Beach, NY, our eatery focuses on …
Onofrio’s Pizza in Mastic Beach, Long Island, Review … – Facebook
Also, in my opinion, their pizza is the best. If you like a very cheesey, New York style pizza this place is for you. They also stay open year ‘ …
Onofrio’s Menu (Updated 2026) – Wheree
The Mastic Beach Restaurant & Bar · American Restaurants. 93 Riviera Dr, Mastic Beach, NY 11951, United States.
Reviews
Mark J. Radzikowski
Small quant place. We were in town for a wedding and stopped here night before for dinner. We did not have reservations, but we’re able to get a table upon arrival. The bar seats I believe 5 patrons but the dining area seats about 50. Great home made food, and chicken parn was amazing. Parking was a bit tricky, so we parked in street about 500 ft away.
We will visit again upon next opportunity when in the area
… moreWe will visit again upon next opportunity when in the area
Dorothy M.
A wonderful Italian restaurant!
Food was delicious!
Thanks to my son for taking me there. I’m from Northern NY and have not had a meal like that in years
… moreFood was delicious!
Thanks to my son for taking me there. I’m from Northern NY and have not had a meal like that in years
Mark Glass
This place reminds me of home. The food is real and cooked right. The atmosphere is no rush just enjoy the moment and the food.
… moreNOYB
EDIT/WENT 6/16 to go out for father’s day. We were very very disappointed. Been living here 10+ yrs tried Ontofrio’s now but you might pass it looking for the sign to say it. Easily you can spot which I didn’t know changed owners which reflects on the sign as Steve & Patti’s-same place different owners.( does say Onofrios est.1950 underneath).
This day it wasn’t packed @ that time. Don’t expect it to be big inside.
FIRST it’s very nice when you walk into a place & are greated! To be honest Steve & Patti it would have been better if they didn’t. Both fellows had STAINED TSHIRTS on & no it wasn’t that something just spilled on them. Im sure you could agree on that.
It was 2 of us the bill was just over $80 before tip! That’s pricey for what we got which I will detail. Portions weren’t big, no alcohol, no desserts…read on
-Our drinks were icetea & soda. This is only place ever been that serves your water and drinks w no ice. Then when asked for ice brought us 1 cup out w some. Idk y skimp on ice. Fyi beverages saw him pour out of a can usually it’s fountains. Took several times ask for our beverages.
-Ordered the appetizers of tortellini and muscles for him. 1 french onion soup and came w 1 salad. Hope u like 1 of 3 choices of dressing-greek ,blue cheese,creamy italian. Got italian as don’t like the others, the italian had weird taste I didn’t eat it. (We are not picky and eat out all different types food, places)
-french onion soup was just ok.
-app tortellini I had was actually the best of everything, was very good.
-he had muscles in white which were cooked perfect and on the bigger side
-he had seafood combo cooked fine tasted fine except red sauce
-I had shrimp parm w penne alla vodka for the pasta. The pasta penne alla vodka is my favorite but not good. It’s the sauce they use don’t like. Took 2 bites and couldn’t eat it.
-see by the pics not much to eat less then 10 shrimp. They are not breaded if that’s what u r used to.
-sorry but this is an italian place. The red sauce sb yummy. It was the worst I’ve had out at an Italian place ever.
I got sick right after we left all night.
-he used men’s room said just can’t understand the upkeep. The walls not all way painted but not as if they started to repaint them more it’s been the 1st paint job never got chance to finish. Needs to be cleaned too. It’s not good feeling walking into something like that.
Maybe times are tough for them Idk but very disappointed as we went to celebrate fathers day.
As a reviewer I just tell as it was/is as I would want someone to be honest when reviewing place.
We won’t go back, I have family moving out this way they won’t go.
PS another poster said there was live music not when we went. Maybe it’s on different day/night.
—
Below from week before top post..
They are closed Monday’s will have to try another time (have all stars because haven’t tried yet so wouldn’t give bad review)
… moreThis day it wasn’t packed @ that time. Don’t expect it to be big inside.
FIRST it’s very nice when you walk into a place & are greated! To be honest Steve & Patti it would have been better if they didn’t. Both fellows had STAINED TSHIRTS on & no it wasn’t that something just spilled on them. Im sure you could agree on that.
It was 2 of us the bill was just over $80 before tip! That’s pricey for what we got which I will detail. Portions weren’t big, no alcohol, no desserts…read on
-Our drinks were icetea & soda. This is only place ever been that serves your water and drinks w no ice. Then when asked for ice brought us 1 cup out w some. Idk y skimp on ice. Fyi beverages saw him pour out of a can usually it’s fountains. Took several times ask for our beverages.
-Ordered the appetizers of tortellini and muscles for him. 1 french onion soup and came w 1 salad. Hope u like 1 of 3 choices of dressing-greek ,blue cheese,creamy italian. Got italian as don’t like the others, the italian had weird taste I didn’t eat it. (We are not picky and eat out all different types food, places)
-french onion soup was just ok.
-app tortellini I had was actually the best of everything, was very good.
-he had muscles in white which were cooked perfect and on the bigger side
-he had seafood combo cooked fine tasted fine except red sauce
-I had shrimp parm w penne alla vodka for the pasta. The pasta penne alla vodka is my favorite but not good. It’s the sauce they use don’t like. Took 2 bites and couldn’t eat it.
-see by the pics not much to eat less then 10 shrimp. They are not breaded if that’s what u r used to.
-sorry but this is an italian place. The red sauce sb yummy. It was the worst I’ve had out at an Italian place ever.
I got sick right after we left all night.
-he used men’s room said just can’t understand the upkeep. The walls not all way painted but not as if they started to repaint them more it’s been the 1st paint job never got chance to finish. Needs to be cleaned too. It’s not good feeling walking into something like that.
Maybe times are tough for them Idk but very disappointed as we went to celebrate fathers day.
As a reviewer I just tell as it was/is as I would want someone to be honest when reviewing place.
We won’t go back, I have family moving out this way they won’t go.
PS another poster said there was live music not when we went. Maybe it’s on different day/night.
—
Below from week before top post..
They are closed Monday’s will have to try another time (have all stars because haven’t tried yet so wouldn’t give bad review)
Suezanne Ritter
Cute Cozy Place…Friendly Atmosphere and the Food was Yummy…we dined in
… moreLouweeg
Great quality food, we love going here as the restaurant has been there forever. You know exactly what you going to get, and it is always really good.
… morePatrick Curran
Been coming here for at least 20 years. By far the best pizza! Great place for dinner as well!
… moreDari “darikyun” V
It’s a lil pricey but worth EVERY PENNY, the service is fantastic with friendly staff and the food is to die for. Their candlelit dining room really adds to the ambiance of fine dining!
… morePatricia Linehan
I grew up in Mastic Beach 50 YEARS ago. from 1972- till 1978 .I still talk about Onofrio.s . it is the best pizza I have ever eaten.
Patricia Linehan
… morePatricia Linehan
Stina Tinelli
Ran into this place by accident, picking something up in mastic. Walked in with 2 kids in a small dark place like “oh no”
Lemme tell you, they were super welcoming; the food was great, the service was great! But most importantly, their sauce was really really really good!
Idk if it’s a local spot or a hidden gem, but definitely worth checking out
… moreLemme tell you, they were super welcoming; the food was great, the service was great! But most importantly, their sauce was really really really good!
Idk if it’s a local spot or a hidden gem, but definitely worth checking out