Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 732 W New Orleans St Suite 120, Broken Arrow, OK 74011
Phone: (539) 367-2563
Website: https://oldworldpizzamenu.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Deliciously Authentic Pizza | Broken Arrow | Old World Pizza
This in our opinion had to be the best pizza we’ve had in Oklahoma. My wife says it’s the best calzone she’s had and my son loves the chicken bacon ranch pizza.
Old World Pizza in Broken Arrow review – Facebook
Okay, that’s a little extreme but you get my point. I enjoy quality veggies on a supreme pizza, especially when it’s paired with quality meat, …
Order OLD WORLD PIZZA – Broken Arrow, OK Menu … – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from OLD WORLD PIZZA at 732 West New Orleans Street in Broken Arrow. Order online and track your order live.
Reviews
Deborah Boevers
This is my all time favorite pizza now!!!
Fresh ingredients, extremely great crust, tons of toppings and nice people working there. And it’s clean including the restrooms.
I came out to try the place after hearing about a car driving into the front glass. I guess to show support for the private owned pizzeria.
What a great find! Oh you need to be hungry if you order the 16 inch. We had 1/2 supreme and 1/2 pepperoni and my daughter ordered a 10 inch Bianca pizza…all of it was delicious.
We had 2 teas and a pop(free refills too). Oh plus 4 ounce homemade ranch dressing and only spent $53.00! For those who like a beer with their pizza there is a full bar.
The slices are huge and there will be leftovers for breakfast too!
… moreFresh ingredients, extremely great crust, tons of toppings and nice people working there. And it’s clean including the restrooms.
I came out to try the place after hearing about a car driving into the front glass. I guess to show support for the private owned pizzeria.
What a great find! Oh you need to be hungry if you order the 16 inch. We had 1/2 supreme and 1/2 pepperoni and my daughter ordered a 10 inch Bianca pizza…all of it was delicious.
We had 2 teas and a pop(free refills too). Oh plus 4 ounce homemade ranch dressing and only spent $53.00! For those who like a beer with their pizza there is a full bar.
The slices are huge and there will be leftovers for breakfast too!
Suzanne Owens
The pizza is absolutely delicious! The owners use fresh, quality ingredients. The crust is thin, slightly crisp and flavorful. The toppings are generous and have a roasted flavor. The Greek salad is the BEST zi have ever tasted, and the Lemon Blueberry cake melts in your mouth. If you haven’t bern to Old World Pizza you are missing out!!
… moreJordan Lay
We ordered a pick-up and the cashier offered, and sweared by this Carmel cheese cake. DO NOT sleep on their dessert because this was the BEST!!! The way my husband described the womens customer service was so nice! Thank you so much for taking care of him!
… moreGrayson Kinnison
Everything was delicious! Loved the caesar salad, pizza, and desserts. Staff was very attentive and friendly.
… moreTravis Law
A perfect pizza. We stopped in for dinner and loved it. They know how to cook a great pizza. Great tasting toppings very good sauce and cooked to perfection. Smiles and friendly service is icing on the cake. I will be back for more pizza.
… moreWyatt Cobb
Old World Pizza in Broken Arrow has become one of my go-to spots, and every visit reminds me why. I’m a regular, and the quality is consistently outstanding.
I always start with their Caesar salad. The homemade dressing, crunchy croutons, and fresh lettuce make it one of the best in town. This time I ordered the Pizza Bianca, which is an amazing vegetarian option with so much flavor. The food always tastes fresh and thoughtfully prepared.
Service is fast and friendly, and you can tell the owners truly care about the customer experience. They’re always present, making sure people are happy with their meals, which adds a personal touch you don’t get at just any pizza place.
The atmosphere is warm and family-friendly! I even enjoyed watching the Indiana vs. Penn State game while eating pizza, which made the experience even better. I’ve also had dessert here before, and it’s just as delicious as the entrées.
Whether you’re looking for a casual date night spot, a family dinner, a lunch break, or high-quality takeout to enjoy at home, Old World Pizza is always a great choice. Highly recommend!
… moreI always start with their Caesar salad. The homemade dressing, crunchy croutons, and fresh lettuce make it one of the best in town. This time I ordered the Pizza Bianca, which is an amazing vegetarian option with so much flavor. The food always tastes fresh and thoughtfully prepared.
Service is fast and friendly, and you can tell the owners truly care about the customer experience. They’re always present, making sure people are happy with their meals, which adds a personal touch you don’t get at just any pizza place.
The atmosphere is warm and family-friendly! I even enjoyed watching the Indiana vs. Penn State game while eating pizza, which made the experience even better. I’ve also had dessert here before, and it’s just as delicious as the entrées.
Whether you’re looking for a casual date night spot, a family dinner, a lunch break, or high-quality takeout to enjoy at home, Old World Pizza is always a great choice. Highly recommend!
Ashley Moran
I’ve been coming to Old World since they opened. Whether dining in or take-out, its always been a wonderful experience. Pizza, Garlic Knots, Calzones, Salads and desserts never miss! Fresh ingredients and homemade sauces can’t be beat! I need to try the pastas, Im sure they are equally amazing! The owners and staff are extremely welcoming and will do anything to make your visit or take-out order the way you requested.
Today I got a small supreme pizza and a Caesar salad. Delicious!
Go give them a try and be hooked like I am.
… moreToday I got a small supreme pizza and a Caesar salad. Delicious!
Go give them a try and be hooked like I am.
Emma Fields
I absolutely love this place! I have never been disappointed. Their homemade ranch is amazing and doesn’t have that vinegar taste! I love their pepperoni pizza and a 10” is a good size if you are wanting to have a personal pizza and possible leftovers. I have never had bad service nor have I ever had bad food here. Highly recommend if you are in the mood for some local pizza!
… moreLuke M
We had a party of 8 and got there about 2 hours before they closed Sunday. We had a supreme pizza, meat lovers, ultimate margherita, and the chicken alfredo pizza. The service was great and the pizza was out of this world. We have lived in Broken Arrow almost 20 years and this was the best pizza we have had anywhere. The last few years anytime we get a supreme from Dominos, Papa Johns, Pizza Hut, etc., its just a cheese pizza with a few sparse toppings. The pizzas at Old World Pizza were loaded with toppings and the ingredients were fresh, they did not use canned mushrooms, they were fresh and big chunks. Andolini’s has nothing on them and Old World was actually cheaper. Our first visit and our new go to pizza place!!!!!!
… morebrian chitty
Had to take the time to review this amazing pizza restaurant! This pizza is super unique and delicious. The crust is were its at. Reminded me of similar crusts I’ve enjoyed in New York. We had the supreme and meat lovers pizza along with the ” folded bread” appetizer. Couldn’t stop indulging myself ha ha. In addition, the customer service was top notch. You can tell the owner takes pride in their pizza shop. Try this place, you won’t be disappointed!
… more