Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Are you ready for a real Italian feast with delicious dishes and fantastic service? If so, look no further than Old Town Pizza. After one visit, you’re sure to be hooked on our hometown pizza shop in Monrovia, CA. Mouthwatering pizza served just the way you like is our specialty, as we offer a wide array of pizza choices served piping hot and made with fresh ingredients. You’ll want to try one of our specialty pizzas, such as our Meat Lover’s, Sicilian, Mexican, or The Works. Add a few of our tantalizing side items, and you’ll be clamoring for more. We’re always your choice for exquisite pizza with a better crust and for getting better value for your money. Stop by today and enjoy our cozy outdoor seating, or call ahead for delivery.
Basic pizzeria with outdoor seating dishing up standard pies & other Italian-American staples.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 338 S Myrtle Ave, Monrovia, CA 91016
Phone: (626) 357-1789
Website: https://www.otpizzamonrovia.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Quite a few people were disappointed when Old Town Pizza closed …
MONROVIANOW.COM. New pizza restaurant may replace Old Town Pizza. News and observations about Monrovia, California. Andy Fernandez and 27 …
Monrovia’s Old Town Pizza closing after more than 30 years
Old Town Pizza is closing, and a slice of downtown Monrovia life slips away with it. The Myrtle Avenue staple, on the corner of Lime Avenue, …
Old Town Pizza loses its lease; plans to move
Monrovia Old Town Pizza has lost its lease and will have to close, but owner Jake Benitez hopes to reopen at another location.
Reviews
Nathan Perez
Really tasty Italian food at a low price. Pizza was cheesy enough for a cheese pull, but not drowning in cheese either. Good sauce and good crust. The spaghetti was good too! Tangy sauce and pasta cooked perfectly. Nice staff and clean place. Can’t go wrong!
… moreBrenda
This pizza is so delicious! One of the things that make it so good is the dough. It doesn’t have that dry flour taste like a lot of dough but it has a really good flavor. One of our favorites is the margarita pizza. We also ordered the eggplant parmesan pasta dish, which was outstanding! The sauce was so flavorful and you could really taste the garlic. I’m sure you could order any pizza and it would be great. They are located right across the street from the park and on a summer night, the weather is so beautiful to sit outdoors and dine. After enjoying your delicious, authentic Italian meal, you can mosey on down the street for dessert since this is right next to a bunch if other shops.
… moreE Yen
The restaurant looks outdated. We got the heart-shaped pizza for Valentine’s Day. We were so disappointed. It only came in one topping, and the crust was so thick. I think most of the pizza was crust. It is such a gimmick. The pizza didn’t blow me away. It needed more cheese.
… moreSoCo
I wanted to support local business and Old Town Pizza did not disappoint. I placed my order online, and the website was very user friendly. My delivery confirmation stated my pizza would be delivered within 40 minutes and it was much faster than that. I am currently staying in an apartment that is like a maze, so it took a minute to find the driver but he was so very nice. Excellent pizza and great customer service, I definitely would order from here again and highly recommend trying it!
… moreA.
Kailey was amazing! So helpful and professional.
A must try pizza place in Monrovia. Thank you Kailey
… moreA must try pizza place in Monrovia. Thank you Kailey
Roberto Mojica
The food was very tasty. Pasta with chicken and vegetables and cheese. I did enjoy it. But it took half an hour to get it ready. One cook and so many orders. That was the inconvenience. Garlic bread came with it but they should have served while we were waiting. Also, I compare their restroom to a public park . Please it doesn’t take that long to clean it.
… moreSB cl907
Pizza came out really crispy, great the two times I’ve been there!
… moreLisa Marie Lozano
The first time I came here I thought it was great and the pizza was awesome. They have a gluten free option and they made it so good.
I ordered from them online today, and they did not give me a gluten free pizza. I asked the guy at the counter who gave me my order if my pizza was made with gluten free crust and he said yea.
I ate two slices of it, and thought it was weird that it didn’t look like the other time I ordered it— I realized, too late, that it was not gluten free. I’m now awake, nauseated and wanting to vomit through every orifice, and my stomach is killing me. (No, Benadryl doesn’t work)
Probably won’t be coming back after this, which is sad.
… moreI ordered from them online today, and they did not give me a gluten free pizza. I asked the guy at the counter who gave me my order if my pizza was made with gluten free crust and he said yea.
I ate two slices of it, and thought it was weird that it didn’t look like the other time I ordered it— I realized, too late, that it was not gluten free. I’m now awake, nauseated and wanting to vomit through every orifice, and my stomach is killing me. (No, Benadryl doesn’t work)
Probably won’t be coming back after this, which is sad.
Martha Gunter
Best little pizza place in Monrovia. I love their how crispy the crust’s edge is and how cheesy each slide is too!
… moreEric Johannsen
The pizza is excellent. The delivery driver is very friendly. This place is top notch in food and service. I haven’t eaten in the store and have only had food delivered. My #1 pick when looking for great pizza and excellent service.
… more